- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the inference-time alignment problem for pretrained diffusion models, aiming to estimate the guidance drift that steers the generative distribution toward a weight-tilted target without retraining the model. Built upon Doob’s h-transform theory, the authors leverage the property that the h-function satisfies the space-time harmonic equation of the reverse diffusion generator, and propose a weak residual regularization estimation method. By converting the harmonic equation residual into a weak form with only first-order derivatives via integration by parts, they incorporate it as a penalty term in the least-squares objective measured by the dual Sobolev norm, constructing a regularization-bias-free estimator of the h-function, and further obtain an estimate of the guidance term .
The core theoretical contribution is a non-asymptotic high-probability upper bound on the error of the guidance estimate. The paper claims the convergence rate exceeds the classical minimax rate for first-order derivative estimation of smooth regression functions when the weight function has a uniform positive lower bound. It also transfers the guidance error to the total variation distance of the sampled distributions. For validation, the authors verify the convergence rate on synthetic data, and test class-conditional tilting alignment on pretrained MNIST and CIFAR-10 diffusion models, with comparisons to two analogous methods, DEFT and DOIT.
Overall, this work makes a meaningful exploration in the statistical theory of diffusion alignment. The weak residual regularization idea has certain theoretical novelty, and the derivation is relatively rigorous. However, there are critical flaws including overly strong core assumptions, severely insufficient experimental validation, and unclear practical application value. In my view, the current version does not meet the acceptance standard of ICLR.
Critical strengths
- Starting from the harmonic property of reverse diffusion, the paper establishes a complete proof chain from weak residual construction and energy identity coercivity analysis to empirical process deviation bounds and final convergence rate. It is rich in technical details and logically self-consistent, demonstrating solid grounding in statistical theory.
- Constructing a penalty term that vanishes at the true solution by leveraging the PDE property of the h-function itself avoids the bias-variance tradeoff of traditional regularization. This design provides a new perspective for nonparametric guidance estimation of diffusion models, with certain theoretical reference value.
Critical weaknesses
-
The entire theoretical analysis is built on the strong assumption that the score of the pretrained model is perfectly accurate (Section SETUP). In real scenarios, however, the score is fitted by neural networks and inherently suffers from approximation error. The paper does not quantify how score error propagates to the final guidance estimate, nor does it prove the robustness of the method to score perturbations. This makes all convergence rate guarantees in the paper only applicable to the ideal scenario of a “perfect pretrained model”, and their practical validity is questionable.
-
The compact support assumption and the existence of negative moments of the weight are difficult to satisfy in real high-dimensional generative tasks. More critically, the paper’s core claim of “exceeding the minimax rate” only holds in the extreme ideal scenario where the weight function has a uniform positive lower bound (). For most practical alignment scenarios (e.g., rare-class generation, likelihood weighting for inverse problems), the weight approaches zero over most of the sample space, leading to significant rate degradation. The paper does not provide sufficient discussion or verification on this point.
-
The only two small-dataset experiments are far from sufficient to support the validity and practicality of the method. They neither verify the generalizability across different tasks and resolutions, nor provide comprehensive comparisons with mainstream alignment methods, resulting in weak persuasiveness of experimental conclusions.
Questions for authors
Major Concerns & Suggestions for Improvement
1. Relax theoretical assumptions and quantify robustness
1.1 It is recommended to relax the idealized exact-score assumption, analyze the impact of score estimation error on the final guidance rate, and provide robust error bounds with score error. Otherwise, the practical significance of the theoretical results is very limited.
1.2 It is advised to more fully discuss the rationality of the compact support assumption and the negative moment assumption of the weight, clarify the rate degradation pattern under different values of , and analyze the convergence performance of typical weight functions in real scenarios.
2. The experimental section needs substantial expansion and deepening
2.1 Expand experimental scenarios: Supplement experiments on higher-resolution datasets (e.g., ImageNet subsets) and more alignment tasks (e.g., attribute editing, inverse problems of image reconstruction) to verify the scalability of the method.
2.2 Improve baseline comparison: Add comparisons with mainstream inference-time alignment methods such as Classifier Guidance and CFG, conducting a comprehensive comparison across multiple dimensions including alignment effect, sample quality (FID/IS), inference speed, and memory overhead, to clearly present the advantages and disadvantages of the method.
2.3 Add ablation studies: Conduct systematic ablation on key hyperparameters such as estimation window position, penalty weight (\mu), and depth/width of the fitting network, to analyze their impacts on estimation error and sampling performance.
2.4 Strengthen result analysis: Enrich the interpretation of experimental results in the main text, for example, explaining the theoretical rationale of the heuristic guidance scaling (), and discussing the trade-off between distribution shift and sample diversity across different methods.
3. Innovative contribution needs further clarification
3.1 It is suggested to more clearly elaborate the essential differences between this work and existing theoretical works on diffusion alignment (e.g., Chang et al. 2026, Guo et al. 2026), and clarify the core innovations to avoid incremental contribution from mere technical combination.
3.2 It is recommended to discuss the curse of dimensionality in high-dimensional scenarios, and specify the actual rate performance of the method on high-dimensional data, instead of only giving order-of-magnitude statements while avoiding the magnitude of constant factors.
Jinyuan Chang, Chenguang Duan, Yuling Jiao, Yi Xu, and Jerry Zhijian Yang. Inference-time alignment for diffusion models via variationally stable Doob's matching. arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.06514, 2026.
Zhengyi Guo, Wenpin Tang, and Renyuan Xu. Conditional diffusion guidance under hard constraint: A stochastic analysis approach. arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.05533, 2026.
3 comments
-
We agree that higher-resolution generation, editing, and inverse problems would strengthen the experimental evidence. Our experiments were designed around the paper's main contribution: understanding how weak residual regularization improves statistical guidance estimation, then checking that the resulting method remains competitive with DEFT/DOIT when the score is learned. The image results serve this applicability goal rather than a claim of state-of-the-art performance. Extending them to new tasks requires task-specific rewards, baselines and evaluation protocols, beyond the present theoretical focus and rebuttal resources. We have therefore included these directions in Discussion and limitations.
-
We agree that CG/CFG would broaden the empirical comparison and have identified this as future work. We chose DEFT and DOIT because they directly address estimation of Doob's -transform guidance, making them the closest methodological comparisons for our contribution. CG/CFG remain relevant, but evaluating them fairly would require suitable noisy-state classifiers or conditional checkpoints, beyond the current setup.
The original text of the article already included a comparison of the alignment method against reference FID values on the CIFAR-10 and MNIST datasets. In response to your request, we have expanded this analysis to include evaluations of intra-class diversity, the Inception Score (IS), and LPIPS (for CIFAR-10) in Appendix J.11.5, as well as metrics for generation speed and memory consumption in Appendix J.11.1. While the reward values on CIFAR-10 are nearly identical, the IS scores for the WEIRDO and DEFT methods are 7.664 and 6.582, respectively, with comparable intra-class LPIPS values of 0.432 and 0.438. Thus, in our experiment, WEIRDO performs comparably to DEFT and outperforms DOIT, while simultaneously providing superior class-balanced coverage. The computational cost of sample generation is comparable to that of DEFT and lower than that of the current implementation of DOIT, however, the auxiliary fitting stage for WEIRDO is slightly more resource-intensive. We would like to emphasize that these results confirm the practical applicability of our method and demonstrate that it is on par with its closest competitors.
-
Thank you for suggesting these checks. We tested whether performance depends on a particular fitting window, penalty, or network size (Appendices J.11.2-J.11.3). The synthetic experiments show a useful range of penalties, with deterioration under excessive regularization, window comparisons retune the penalty. The CIFAR-10 depth/width ablation is especially useful for assessing whether the default network is a reasonable practical choice: across three training seeds, smaller networks weaken alignment, doubling width gives a modest gain at nearly twice the memory, and additional depth does not consistently help. The study uses a fixed number of optimization steps, shared reference data and sampling noise, and automatic penalty calibration.
-
We have clarified that scaling is useful but heuristic: is generally not harmonic, so is not generally exact guidance for . Finite DDIM steps and the guidance cap are also outside the local continuous-time guarantee.
Appendix J.11.5 presents an analysis of the trade-off between diversity and target-value alignment. With , the proportion of target values for the MNIST dataset increases from 52.2% to 82.9%, while coverage decreases from 0.9674 to 0.9195. Furthermore, for the CIFAR dataset—while maintaining a nearly identical reward—WEIRDO achieves higher coverage and an LPIPS score comparable to that of DEFT (LPIPS was evaluated only for CIFAR-10, as its meaningfulness for the MNIST dataset is limited). These results highlight that our method offers a reasonable trade-off between the strength of alignment and diversity, performing on par with its closest competitors, DEFT and DOIT.
-
Our main contribution is a statistical guidance-estimation rate obtained by exploiting the harmonic equation in weak form. The penalty vanishes at , integration by parts leaves only first derivatives, and compatible trial/test classes let value and residual errors control the gradient. This is the mechanism that avoids a target-shifting regularization bias and improves the derivative-estimation rate, rather than merely introducing another guidance architecture.
Compared with Chang et al., the essential difference is the penalty: their gradient regularizer is generally nonzero at , so its coefficient must decrease to control bias. Our weak residual remains compatible with the target at fixed regularization strength. At with a positive weight floor, our exponent is versus their the comparison concerns the stated rates, with different constructions and time/norm conventions. Our negative-moment condition also permits weights without a uniform floor, with explicitly quantified rate degradation.
Guo et al. share the Doob-transform viewpoint but target hard-event conditioning and learn from pretrained trajectories using martingale and quadratic-covariation identities. Their covariation construction learns and its gradient separately. WEIRDO instead uses independently noised reference pairs and a weak harmonic penalty to control the derivative of a single fitted , followed by clipped division to obtain guidance. Their learning guarantees in Section 4.3 therefore address a different construction, our distinguishing result is the explicit sample-size rate for this weak-residual guidance estimator, including the negative-moment regime and its score-error extension.
-
We agree that dimension dependence and constants matter when interpreting the rate. Our result improves the sample-size exponent at fixed dimension. We make quantities such as and explicit and track the remaining prefactors as , although not every structural constant is numerically evaluated. We agree that intrinsic-dimension rates are an important next step, and we have expanded the section dedicated to this in the "Discussion and Limitations". For nonlinear manifolds or their neighborhoods, they require a new geometric approximation analysis and developing that result would be a substantial separate project.
We thank the reviewer for such a detailed assessment. The main theoretical addition in our revision is a quantitative extension of Theorem 5 to an imperfect reference score, motivated by your question 1.1. and Theorem 7, now stated in Section 7 before the experiments, identifies how score error enters the guidance guarantee and when the original statistical rate is preserved, Appendix K gives the full statement and proof. Additional experiments address sensitivity, computational cost, and diversity, their tables and protocols are collected in Appendix J.11.
Thank you for highlighting this limitation. Theorem 7 and its full version in Appendix K allow a fixed, externally supplied score with population error ∥s−s∥L2(ν⊗ρ)≤εsc, with probability taken over the fitting sample. With the theorem's adjusted clipping level, the high-probability squared guidance-error bound has statistical dependence
(εn+γG2εsc2)s/(s+4),
with confidence 1−ζ−γ and the other prefactors stated in the theorem. Here γ∈(0,1−ζ) allocates additional failure probability to the score-error transfer, ζ is the original statistical failure probability and G the trial gradient bound. At fixed confidence, the original statistical rate is preserved when G2εsc2=O(εn). For w≥B>0, dependence on the combined squared-error term is linear, for finite s, the exponent remains s/(s+4). The appendix also gives an expected-error version with its corresponding clipping level and deviation-event remainder. For your convenience, we have written out a short:
Proof sketch. Let εsc2 denote the average squared score error on the fitting pairs and time window. Cauchy-Schwarz and ∣∇h∣≤G bound the empirical weak-form perturbation by Gεsc∥ψ∥V^,δn, without differentiating the score error. The inner maximization and the minimizer's basic inequality therefore add a term of order G2εsc2 while still controlling the residual for the true score. The existing coercivity estimate converts this control to gradient error, and clipping gives guidance error. For the fixed supplied score, averaging over the reference fitting sample gives E[εsc2]≤εsc2. Markov's inequality bounds the empirical error by εsc2/γ with failure probability at most γ, combining events yields confidence 1−ζ−γ. Direct expectation gives the second version, with projection controlling the exceptional event.
The controlled checks in Appendix J.11.4, Table 11, isolate the mechanism addressed by the theorem: only the score in the fitting objective is perturbed, while the reference law and exact guidance remain fixed. Across eight paired replicates, 1% RMS score error causes no resolved degradation. At n=100,000, mean relative squared guidance error is 1.05×10−4 with the clean score, 1.84×10−4 with a 3% oscillatory perturbation, and 1.38×10−3 at 10%, also constant perturbations have much milder effects. We wish to emphasize that these experimental results qualitatively confirm the main conclusion of the theorem we have added.
The compactness assumption concerns the clean reference law p0, not the Gaussian-noised marginals. At fixed resolution, images with bounded pixel values lie in a compact set. This also covers model outputs when the sampling pipeline clips them to that range, as our image sampler does. Thus the assumption has a concrete interpretation for pixel-space generation, also the noised marginals may still have full support.
Also for finite s, the exponent is 2(β−1)+d2(β−1)s+4s, exceeding the generic derivative benchmark when s>2{2(β−1)+d}. A uniform positive floor is therefore sufficient, not necessary. For d=1, β=2, uniform X0∈[0,1], and w(x)=x1/10 for x>0, w(0)=1, there is no uniform floor, yet Ξ8=5 and the exponent is 4/9>2/5.