- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
I tried to read this for quite a while, but I cannot make any sense of this paper. It has something to do with neural operators. Without the slightest attempt to explain or motivate anything, the paper starts throwing around claims and undefined notation. The "related work" section is literally 4 lines and 4 citations.
Just from the abstract, I think this is about applying BO to select something undefined, and by some "theorem" involving all sorts of undefined notation, one often cannot do better than some "radial box" baseline, but I then trust the authors they are confident they can. Just I (and likely no other reader) will be able to follow them on their wild journey here.
I have no idea (and also no interest in speculating) whether AI was used here. If so, this reads like hallucination going off the rails.
What is quite funny (and I suppose unintendedly so) is the bloated vocabulary used here: "bites", "obstacle", "falsifiable", "organized so the answer can come out either way", "machine-checked numbers", "THE DECISION QUESTION", "like-for-like". What is any of this supposed to mean?
Critical strengths
I have literally absolutely no idea. And the authors make no effort conveying it. There are some claims, but the rest is drowned in undefined notation and super-short sections like 2.2, which suddenly stop nowhere.
Critical weaknesses
This paper is (excuse my French) a disorganized mess. Maybe 90% of all notation is not defined, or maybe defined later (at some point, I stopped checking). No motivation, no explanation of terms.
"(a) Downward-closed (enumerative). A symmetric downward-closed set in d = 2 is a non-increasing staircase b : {0,...,kmax}→ {0,...,kmax+1}with k active iff |ky|<b(|kx|); closure holds by construction. At fixed cardinality the admissible pool is tiny — 42 sets at M=27, 907 at M=145, 9,825 at M=221 — so zt is the exact maximizer of the acquisition, closing the oracle-versus-implementation gap that would otherwise void Theorem 3."
And it goes on and on like this.
Questions for authors
After reading the revision, I change my score to 2. I think with quite some effort, I could understand what is done here. Now, the authors need to work harder in order to tell me why I should spend the effort. This would be easiest by focussing on who is the audience here (maybe not even ML/AI, but rather applied physics?), and then give them some down-to-earth reasons why the considerable extra complexity of what is done here, would be worth their attention.