- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper seems to propose a novel approach to graph neural network construction where sub-structures are treated using deep equilibrium networks. They benchmark their approach by comparing to deep equilibrium GNNs.
Critical strengths
The idea to combine structure decomposition with deep equilibrium networks is, to my understanding, novel.
Critical weaknesses
I found it difficult to understand the content of this paper, largely due to what I believe are severe organizational difficulties. While I recognized many of the keywords I often struggled to piece together a single coherent message in each section.
Moreover, insofar as I understand it, I have concerns about the applicability of the method. Just to name one potential issue: the proposed decomposition into strongly connected components and the rest of the graph may not be applicable for many graphs. Molecular graphs, which seem to be a core focus of the paper, can have very few strongly connected components. (For that matter, in Figure 1 the module is not a strongly connected component.)
I am sorry I am not able to give a more comprehensive analysis: I found it truly difficult to understand the central points of the paper due to presentational difficulties. If the other reviewers disagree to the point where I am convinced this is a "me" problem, I will revisit my score. Otherwise, I recommend resubmitting to a later conference following revision with a focus of clarity of explanation.
Questions for authors
No questions.