1. The claimed contributions are not fully supported.
OFFIDEX is claimed to be "the first office assistant for which requirement clarification is an explicitly rewarded multi-turn objective". However, that the requirement clarification is an explicit reward does not necessary mean that it is a better-performing office assitant, especially in terms of the final deliverable quality.
The paper also listed "A recursive self-purifying experiential RL framework" as a major contribution, but as far as I understand, this RL framework is not complete in this work. GRPO is discussed, configured but not run (according to Appendix B.5: "Its execution is deferred to the next loop iteration because the compute tier required for RL jobs on the platform was not provisioned within this iteration"). Therefore, it remains unclear how effective this RL framework would be.
The third contribution talks about several quantitative analysis, which may be beneficial, but it is unclear how these findings can direct model improvements.
2. The presentation makes it diffucult to assess the paper's contributions.
The paper is not rigorously written. In equation (4), while can be inferred, it lacks a definition for wi and Si. At the end of section 4.3, the paper refers to "G0" and "Stage III", which are defined after these references (in section 4.4 and section 4.5).
While these are not major issues, the result section (section 6) is even harder to read. Table 1 mixes some components from V2 sampling with V3 results, making the comparison difficult to interpret. The writing of section 6.2 through section 6.5 are hard to follow. Statement like "Behaviour moved; quality did not" in section 6.5 is not easily understandable as a takeaway sentence. Appendix tables are frequently referred to (for example, section 6.3 refers to Table A11 and A12), indicating that the authors need to change the organization and make sure that the essentially important results are in the main body. The frequent use of self-defined jargons (e.g. P1/P2, V1/V2, G1/G2, bo1/bo8, Stage I/II) also adds to the reading difficulty, requiring readers to cross-reference all the time. Besides, figures 3 - 5 are not clearly annotated and are hard to interpret as well.
Related work, mechanism, and baselines
We thank the reviewer for the direct assessment. W1: "Writing, motivation, related work." We agree §2 is too compressed. The revision will expand it to about one page with four paragraphs (clarification/proactive dialogue; multi-turn agentic RL and clinical inquiry; rubric rewards, judges and reward hacking; office benchmarks and self-improvement), each ending with an explicit “difference from OFFIDEX” sentence. The introduction will lead with the two motivating numbers: 83% of 16,608 community questions are ≤20 characters; five prompted frontier models answer first on 12–86% of held-out requests. We will add a notation table and a glossary and remove the P1/P2, V1/V2, bo1/bo8 labels. W2: "Discussion and baselines." §6 will be rewritten around mechanisms: why a clinical hard veto collapses a graded office reward; why the clarification budget is inverted-U; why positive-only RFT fails. For baselines, the main text will include a compact Table A25: five frontier models under the same prompt, simulator and judge score 0.12–1.21 lower on paired differences, with 12–86% zero-Q and 0.7–6.8 protocol violations, while passing more rubric items when they deliver. We will present base/SFT/RFT and the reward ablations in one table. ReAct/Reflexion are not direct baselines because they lack a clarification action and a hidden-information simulator; we will cite them as context. Stage IV remains unvalidated; the contribution is the environment plus the diagnostic findings.