- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript proposes a framework for transcriptomics-driven molecular generation, called DECO. The authors first show that transcriptomic response similarity has very little correlation with molecular structural similarity, and use this observation to motivate learning the chemical latent space independently of transcriptomic information. The method combines a pretrained molecular VAE with conditional latent diffusion, using both global and gene-level transcriptomic features. It also introduces auxiliary losses to encourage condition usage and a decoder adaptation strategy to handle errors in generated latents. The experimental results on LINCS L1000 show improvements over TransGEM, XMolRL, and CURE in structural similarity and PRNet-predicted response consistency, including cell-line and scaffold OOD settings.
Critical strengths
-
I like that the method is motivated by an actual observation in the data. The weak correlation between transcriptomic response similarity and chemical similarity is interesting, and it provides a reasonable motivation for not forcing the two modalities into a shared representation. I think this makes the overall approach more convincing than simply introducing another conditional diffusion architecture.
-
DECO outperforms the compared methods on both structural similarity and predicted response consistency across all three splits. I also appreciate the ablations on global and gene-level conditioning, decoder adaptation, and auxiliary objectives. These results suggest that the improvements are not coming from a single component alone.
Critical weaknesses
-
One of my main concerns is that the response metric compares PRNet predictions for the generated molecules against PRNet predictions for the reference molecules, rather than directly comparing them with the desired experimental transcriptomic response. I understand the motivation for using a frozen predictor, but I think this distinction matters. A generated molecule could receive a good score because PRNet considers it similar to the reference molecule, without necessarily reproducing the desired cellular response. Since transcriptomics-driven generation is the main goal of the paper, I would like to see stronger evidence that the improvement goes beyond agreement with this particular predictor.
-
In additon, the authors argue that weak response–structure correspondence motivates learning the chemical latent space independently. I find this reasonable, but DECO also introduces dual-scale conditioning, additional training losses, and decoder adaptation. The current ablations show that these components help, but they do not directly compare decoupled and coupled representation learning under the same generative architecture. I therefore find it difficult to tell whether the gains mainly come from decoupling or from the other improvements. This is important because decoupling is presented as the central contribution of the paper.
Questions for authors
-
In Appendix E.2, the response metrics compare PRNet predictions for generated and reference molecules. Why not also evaluate the generated molecules against the experimentally observed target transcriptomic profiles? Could the authors clarify how well the PRNet-based improvements correlate with agreement with the actual desired responses? This would materially affect my confidence in the main experimental conclusions.
-
Could the authors compare DECO with a coupled representation-learning variant using the same VAE, diffusion architecture, conditioning modules, and decoder adaptation? I would be interested to know whether independent chemical representation learning still provides an advantage when the other components are controlled for. This would help me judge the importance of the paper's central design choice.
2 comments
After rebuttal
Thank you for the authors' responses. Could the authors answer the weaknesses that I concerned.
Until now, I think that this manuscript need improve more on the paper quality. So I keep my current rating.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback.
Q1. Response-consistency evaluation
Following prior work, we compare PRNet predictions of generated and reference molecules to reduce the influence of prediction errors shared by the same surrogate model.
We acknowledge that this evaluation relies on a predictive model and does not constitute experimental validation of the generated molecules' biological activity.
Q2. Controlled evaluation of decoupling
We compared Decoupled and Coupled training, initialized from the same pretrained molecular VAE and retaining the core diffusion and conditioning architecture.
Decoupled keeps its chemical representation fixed during conditional training, whereas Coupled jointly optimizes the chemical representation and conditional generation. We also adapted the Coupled decoder to its own latent prediction errors after joint training to reduce differences in decoder robustness.
Table 2. Decoupled versus Coupled.
Table 3. Quality-constrained conditional coverage (10 samples, PRNet MSE threshold = 10⁻³).
Success requires validity, ChemPass, and surrogate-response MSE ≤ 10⁻³; 128 identical conditions per split.
Decoupled achieves higher validity and Morgan similarity across all splits, and higher average quality-constrained coverage, although the Cell OOD difference is small and Coupled slightly leads in Scaffold OOD Fraggle@10.
Joint optimization also contracts chemical latent variance from 27.94 to 0.66 on 1,024 held-out molecules. These observations support the practical value of the decoupled strategy under our evaluated training setting, beyond the original component ablations.