- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the effect of gocentric human data for a fixed world-action model framework. Real-robot and RoboDojo results show useful transfer from aligned human demonstrations, benefits from video pretraining.
Critical strengths
The question that how to use human data is important. Duration/diversity scaling comparisons fix the backbone, initialization, and training budget, and include matched-volume composition controls at 2K and 4K ho
Critical weaknesses
- The paper is more like an experimental report; many of its conclusions have already been discussed in prior work, and the model’s performance is not particularly strong.
- The supervision comparisons use different data and compute budgets, which is confusing.
Questions for authors
- Do the differences between video-only, video-action, and staged training still exist on the same 12K-hour samples under matched compute?
- Please provide more details about real-robot trial counts, RoboDojo training/evaluation seeds and confidence intervals.
- The best model in Table 1 does not use mid-training, but the model in Table 2 use 0.1K hours of multi-task robot data. At which stage are these data used, and do they include downstream adaptation?