- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses the problem in WSSOD that "exposing all samples equally from the start injects high-uncertainty gradients" and proposes the Evidential Certain–Uncertain Refinement mechanism. The mechanism decouples confident and uncertain regions via Dirichlet evidence, and refines ambiguous features with certainty-weighted prototypes and intra-class self-attention. The comparative experiments and visualization results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
The paper is well organized, clearly structured, and fluently written. The figures and tables are clear, making the paper easy to read and understand.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper claims to achieve state-of-the-art performance, but the results in Table 1 show that the proposed method underperforms SAMSOD on several metrics. This gap undermines the paper's claim to be state-of-the-art.
- The paper is concerned with the distinction between background (BG) and foreground (FG), yet it lacks visualization experiments that demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method in distinguishing BG from FG, which weakens the paper's novelty.
Questions for authors
- GN is not defined in Eq. (1). Does it refer to Group Normalization?
- As the core component of the proposed ECUR, EUCM appears to be presented through only a single equation (Eq. 12 in Section 3.3), while all the remaining equations are citations of existing work. This gives me some concerns regarding the novelty of the paper.
- In Table 1, the proposed method appears to fall clearly behind SAMSOD in the comparison. Does this weaken the novelty and effectiveness claimed for the paper?
- In Figure 4, the effect of ECUR does not look very pronounced. Have the authors considered comparing it with simple segmentation post-processing algorithms, such as Connected Component Filtering, which is commonly used in segmentation post-processing? Please explain the specific role of ECUR in conjunction with the visualization.