- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
CT2X studies the geometric reliability of CT-based virtual X-ray views. It compares direct pose use with pose recovery from virtual landmarks and, under the same rendering budget, adds single-view optimization with an extra real radiograph. The experiments use a controlled CT cohort and four public datasets, with actions derived from the reference annotations in the public-data experiments.
Critical strengths
The paper clearly distinguishes acquired images from virtual outputs and reports unsuccessful cases rather than only successful registrations. The use of official XVR/RayEmb implementations and patient/object-level statistics is a strength.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited novelty. CT rendering and pose refinement are already used in DiffPose [3] and XVR [1], while Cui et al. [4] and Cho et al. [5] study multi-view constraints and registration uncertainty, respectively. The main attribution result is also largely expected: exact landmarks are projected from an estimated pose and then used to recover the same pose. Under Eq. (7), the same rigid action preserves 3D landmark mTRE, as Table 6 notes. It is unclear what new understanding these checks provide beyond existing registration work.
-
Table 1B includes only six objects, and most of the mean improvement comes from one case. The 95% interval for the mean change includes zero (-11.49 to 0.94 mm), and the number of objects below 2 mm drops from 5/6 to 4/6. Since the budget comparison uses a fixed optimizer, it does not show whether the unresolved single-view error comes from insufficient information or the optimization procedure. The learned rejection model also misses all seven failures, but its input features, training procedure, and decision threshold are not described in Section 4.4 or Appendix D. Without these details or a comparison with existing registration-quality methods, its failure is difficult to interpret.
[1] Gopalakrishnan et al. Rapid patient-specific neural networks for X-ray to volume registration. Nature, 2026. [2] Shrestha et al. RayEmb: Arbitrary Landmark Detection in X-Ray Images Using Ray Embedding Subspace. ACCV, 2024. [3] Gopalakrishnan et al. Intraoperative 2D/3D Image Registration via Differentiable X-ray Rendering. CVPR, 2024. [4] Cui et al. Robust and Accurate Multi-view 2D/3D Image Registration with Differentiable X-ray Rendering and Dual Cross-view Constraints. ICRA, 2025. [5] Cho et al. Uncertainty Quantification in Image-based 2D/3D Registration and Its Relationship with Accuracy. International Journal of Computer Assisted Radiology and Surgery, 2025.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors repeat the direct-versus-virtual comparison with a downstream method that uses rendered image pixels rather than exact projected landmarks?
- Does the second-view benefit persist across different view pairs and alternative single-view restarts or optimizers under matched rendering budgets?
- How is the learned rejection model trained and thresholded, and how does it compare with an existing registration-quality estimator?
- What rotation center and composition order are used for action noise, and how do these perturbations relate to actual acquisition errors?