- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FiberR2R, a framework for reconstructing RAW images from RGB images. It first learns a differentiable forward ISP model, then trains a network to predict an RGB-conditioned RAW anchor, and finally refines the result with a residual network. The main idea is to estimate how sensitive the learned ISP model is to changes in individual RAW coordinates, and use this information to guide the training process. Experiments on several camera-specific datasets show that the method performs well in terms of RAW reconstruction accuracy.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is well written, the figures are well presented, and the overall structure is good. The authors also provide code and demos in the supplementary material, which helps improve the reproducibility and credibility of the work.
-
The method achieves strong overall performance and is compared against current state-of-the-art methods, demonstrating its effectiveness. The ablation studies are also carefully designed.
-
The paper has a clear motivation and addresses an important limitation of existing methods. I believe it could be suitable for a poster presentation after the necessary revisions.
Critical weaknesses
-
Efficiency problem, the paper reports only parameters and GFLOPs, without any wall-clock runtime. Given the sliding-window inference (64×64 windows with 16-pixel overlap), please report full-resolution inference time and the GFLOPs measurement resolution, as well as the total training cost of the three stages compared with the baselines.
-
The paper provides limited discussion of related work, and I encourage the authors to include more relevant studies in the revised version to strengthen its technical depth. Since the central motivation is to reuse RGB annotations to train RAW-domain perception models, the discussion should cover recent work on RAW-domain perception, such as Dirty-Pixels (Diamond et al., TOG 2021) [1], ROD (Xu et al., CVPR 2023) [2], RAW-Adapter (Cui & Harada, ECCV 2024) [3], and RAWild (Liu et al., NeurIPS 2026) [4]. For RGB-to-RAW reconstruction, metadata-based approaches (Punnappurath & Brown, WACV 2021) [5] and the AIM 2022 Reversed ISP Challenge (Conde et al., ECCVW 2022) [6] are also relevant.
-
Appendix A.1 / Fig. 6 claims the generated RAW can “recover high-bit-depth information to eliminate glare.” However, information clipped in 8-bit RGB cannot be reliably recovered; the network likely produces plausible estimates instead. Ground-truth comparisons or quantitative detection results (e.g., on NOD) are needed to support this claim. Otherwise, the authors could consider softening the claims in this section.
[1]. Dirty Pixels: Towards End-to-End Image Processing and Perception
[2]. Toward RAW Object Detection: A New Benchmark and A New Model
[3]. RAW-Adapter: Adapting Pre-trained Visual Model to Camera RAW Images
[4]. RAWild: Toward Sensor-Agnostic RAW Object Detection via Physics-Guided Curve and Grid Modeling
[5]. Spatially Aware Metadata for Raw Reconstruction
[6]. Reversed Image Signal Processing and RAW Reconstruction. AIM 2022 Challenge Report
Questions for authors
-
In the submitted supplementary materials, most of the folders in the “example” directory appear to be empty. Could the authors please check this part?
-
Although the paper already includes a fairly comprehensive set of comparisons, I’m curious whether the proposed method still has an advantage over generative-based models such as RawGen [7]. Could the authors include additional experiments to compare their method with these approaches?
[7]. RawGen: Learning Camera Raw Image Generation (ECCV 2026)
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed response and the additional analyses. The efficiency measurements, expanded related work, revised claims on near-saturation recovery, and the RawGen comparison address my main concerns. From my perspective, this is a poster-level paper, and I remain inclined to accept it.
Thank you for your thoughtful follow-up and for taking the time to assess our responses and additional analyses. We sincerely appreciate your recognition of our work and your continued support for acceptance.
Response to Reviewer 2ADi: efficiency, validation, and supplementary examples
Thank you for recognizing the reconstruction results and for the concrete suggestions on efficiency, related work, application claims, and the supplementary examples. We have revised each of these areas. The detailed point-by-point response is in Response_to_Reviewers.pdf, pp. 6-9, in the updated supplementary ZIP. All appendix and table references below refer to the revised manuscript uploaded in the PDF field.
W1 - Full-resolution inference and training cost (Appendix A.8, Tables 16-18). We measured five methods on all 947 test images, with three repetitions per image, using one H20 GPU per image, FP32, and TF32 disabled. Timing includes preprocessing, transfers, model execution, and stitching, but excludes file I/O and model loading. FiberR2R's domain-mean latency is 4.140-9.574 seconds, giving 1.87-2.13x speedups over the specified RAW-Flow retest. ReRAW is faster. FiberR2R has the lowest measured native allocated peak memory among these wrappers, at 232.2 MiB; this is not a comparison of separately optimized deployment footprints. We clarify that 11.49M parameters cover the deployed Anchor and Refiner, and 10.63 GFLOPs refers to one 64x64 RGB window, excluding the training-only ISP. We also provide stage-wise epoch/update budgets, GPU counts, and measured update times. Complete historical GPU-hours are unavailable, so these measurements are not presented as a complete training-cost ranking.
W2 - Related work (Section 2). We reorganized the discussion around RAW-domain perception and the information available for RGB-to-RAW reconstruction, incorporating Dirty Pixels, ROD, RAW-Adapter, RAWild, Spatially Aware Metadata, and the AIM reversed-ISP challenge. The revised discussion distinguishes the motivation for labeled RAW data from the separate question of whether generated RAW improves downstream perception.
W3 - Validation near saturation (Appendices A.1-A.2, Tables 5-6). We removed the claims of recovering clipped information and eliminating glare. The new analysis compares predicted gradients with paired measured RAW, screening all 947 images and selecting regions using RGB and ground-truth structural support, not prediction quality. For the 470 images eligible for partial near-saturation analysis, domain-mean gradient NRMSE is 0.269-0.612, with every 95% interval below the analytical zero-gradient reference of 1. Completely clipped cells do not show consistent structural recovery. We therefore claim conditional RAW estimation with measured structure fidelity under the stated conditions, not a demonstrated detection or driving-safety benefit.
Q1 - The empty example directories. The omissions were intentional to satisfy the 100 MB attachment limit, but the original documentation did not make this clear, and we apologize for the confusion. The updated package includes the inference implementation, one Canon EOS 5D checkpoint, its full-resolution RGB input and paired RAW reference, and pre-generated comparisons and per-example metrics for all five domains. The other four checkpoints and input pairs are omitted for size, so those four outputs cannot be regenerated from this compact package alone. Source code/README.md explains this coverage, and the demo/validation entry points process the available Canon example rather than requiring all five. This is an inference demonstration, not a full training or five-domain benchmark reproduction.
Q2 - RAWGen (Appendix A.7, Table 15). We added a camera-specific RAWGen adaptation on all five domains and evaluated both native resizing and tiling on the complete test sets. We disclose its single-RGB-view training and the unverified equivalence of its XYZ codec to the official pipeline, rather than treating the resulting scores as a definitive ranking against a faithful RAWGen reproduction. The existing benchmark comparisons with RAW-Diffusion and SpiralDiff remain unchanged.
We have tried to make both the new evidence and the remaining documentation limits easy to inspect. We hope the revised measurements, paired-RAW validation, and clarified supplementary package address the concerns underlying your suggestions.