- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper aims to learn to simulate the stock market by having traders models as agents that learn through interactions. In doing so it combines factor-based stock predictors with a multi-stock order-book market. A few studies of population behaviors has been conducted to show the traits of proposed method learning stock dynamics.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
There are a few issues in this manuscript that prevents an acceptance in its current form.
The biggest issue is the lack of discussion and comparison of recent LLM based multi-agent stock market simulation methods, which both consider order book structure for studying the dynamics. To name a few: Gao et al., 2024 https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19966, Papadakis et al., 2025 https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.09255 , Hashimoto et al., 2026 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s42001-026-00465-4 . Such omission largely limits the contribution of this manuscript. Even though this manuscript choose to focus learned / fine-tuned models rather than context engineering more powerful models, however the validity of such choice remains unclear for the claimed problem to solve (studying stock dynamics), making the whole narrative under justified, and technically missing a wide body of works.
There are also concerns regarding the methods and experiments. For example, no noise / stochasticity in market has been modeled. Also, the LLM used in this experiments contains only contains only Qwen3.5-2B, which is are not sufficient. Furthermore, as the author mentions, "FML contains 32 research traders, 20 synthetic stocks, and 32 features, over 120 decision days" which is insufficient for a thorough stock market behavior analysis.
For presentation, the formalization in Sec 3 is hard to parse. It feels like formalization only for formalization's seek. A wide range of detail are also missing, likely explain the difficulties in assessing the merit of this work.
Questions for authors
None
2 comments
2. Evaluation horizon (day 120 vs. day 512)
We compared the same runs at two time points. The interaction measures how much peer learning changes the gain from the focal traders’ own updates. Values are means across five seeds, in percentage points (pp).
| Traders | Day | Focal gain with frozen peers () | Focal gain with learning peers () | Interaction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 32 | 120 | 0.188 | 0.024 | −0.164 |
| 32 | 512 | −0.742 | −0.412 | 0.33 |
| 64 | 120 | −0.071 | −0.037 | 0.034 |
| 64 | 512 | −1.091 | −0.368 | 0.723 |
- Focal learning gains were lower at day 512. With 32 traders, the early gains turned negative under both peer conditions. With 64 traders, the gains were already negative at day 120 and fell further by day 512.
- The interaction was larger at day 512 in both populations. With 32 traders, peer learning reduced the early benefit of focal updates by 0.164 pp but softened their later penalty by 0.330 pp. With 64 traders, peer learning softened the penalty at both time points, by 0.034 pp at day 120 and 0.723 pp at day 512.
We will report results for each 128-day window in the revision to show how the interaction develops between these time points.
3. Update interval and share of learning peers ()
The table reports mean focal learning gains at day 512 for 32 traders, averaged across five seeds, in percentage points (pp). Rows show the update interval (), and columns show the share of peers that learn (). Bold marks the highest mean gain for each peer share. The final column reports the interaction: focal gain at minus focal gain at .
| Update interval () | Interaction | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 day | −0.716 | −0.521 | −0.487 | −0.968 | −0.746 | −0.124 | +0.592 |
| 5 days | −0.742 | −0.729 | −0.601 | −0.573 | −0.691 | −0.412 | +0.330 |
| 10 days | −0.668 | −0.714 | −0.877 | −0.395 | −0.177 | −0.325 | +0.343 |
| Spread across intervals | 0.074 | 0.208 | 0.390 | 0.573 | 0.569 | 0.288 | — |
- The ranking of update intervals depended on how many peers learned. At 40% peer learning, daily updates outperformed 10-day updates by 0.390 pp. At 60%, the ranking reversed: 10-day updates outperformed daily updates by 0.573 pp. Daily updates led again at 100%.
- The peer-learning interaction was positive at all three intervals. Full peer learning narrowed the penalty from focal updates by 0.592 pp for daily updates, 0.330 pp for 5-day updates, and 0.343 pp for 10-day updates. Mean focal gains remained negative in all 18 settings.
1. Missing market-simulation literature and choice of agents
Thank you for identifying these relevant studies. We will add a dedicated comparison discussing ABIDES, ASFM, StockSim, FCLAgent (PAMS), TwinMarket, and FinEvo:
✓ denotes a capability present in the evaluated setup; × denotes its absence there rather than an architectural restriction. Continual learning refers to deployment-time parameter updates during market interaction; a shared training pool supplies training samples to multiple learners (distinct from market feeds, social communication, or prompt histories). StockSim reflects its order-level mode; FCLAgent is Hashimoto et al.'s trader in PAMS; FinEvo reflects its implemented market-interaction setup, where parameters remain fixed during simulation.
Why trainable parameter-updating models rather than context-engineered LLMs? Prompt- and memory-based LLM agents are well-suited for studying narrative reasoning or behavioral framing, but they conflate linguistic drift with learning and do not allow controlled attribution over update cadence, minibatch budget, or training-pool composition. Our research question specifically asks how the value of parameter-level continual learning changes when counterparties also learn. Trainable cross-sectional scoring controllers (MLP, Transformer, and Qwen+Head) built atop ABIDES enable exact common-start focal/peer switches, matured-label construction, and matched historical/personal/public sample pools—isolating interactive learning dynamics that context engineering alone cannot cleanly separate.
Stochasticity. FML includes random market, sector, and stock-level shocks, as well as random background order flow. Learning agents also sample minibatches independently. We will clarify these sources of randomness and report the seed settings.
Presentation. We will reorganize Section 3 around one decision day to show how traders make predictions, place orders, and later learn from market outcomes. We will introduce each equation alongside the step it explains.