acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Dual Behavior Sequence Enhancement and Conditional Diffusion for Cognitive Diagnosis

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Cognitive diagnosis aims to infer students' latent cognitive states from their historical learning behaviors and predict their knowledge mastery on target exercises.Although existing methods have achieved promising results in cognitive state modeling, they still inadequately exploit temporal dynamic behaviors during students' learning processes. Moreover, ability representations derived from limited historical interaction statistics are susceptible to response fluctuations.To address these limitations, this paper proposes a Dual Behavior Sequence Enhancement and Conditional Diffusion method for Cognitive Diagnosis (DBSCD).The proposed method centers on modeling students’ response sequences and time-interval sequences from historical interactions, while incorporating corresponding exercise and knowledge concept information to construct a more comprehensive representation of students’ historical cognitive states.This enhanced state is then employed as a condition to guide the conditional diffusion process in progressively refining explicit ability representations, thereby yielding more robust student cognitive states.Finally, the model integrates target exercise-related information to perform fine-grained cognitive diagnosis at the knowledge concept level.Experimental results on two real-world educational datasets demonstrate that DBSCD achieves favorable diagnostic performance, validating the effectiveness of both dual behavior sequence modeling and the conditional diffusion-based ability refinement mechanism.The source code is available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/DBSCD

Primary area:
unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords:
Cognitive Diagnosis,Conditional Diffusion, Dual Behavior Sequence Modeling

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_27z6OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper identifies two limitations in cognitive diagnosis (CD): existing methods mostly rely only on response outcomes and interaction relations, without fully exploring learning dynamics encoded in time intervals; explicit ability estimates derived from limited historical interactions are susceptible to response fluctuations and insufficient concept coverage, resulting in unreliable cognitive state estimation. The authors propose DBSCD, which builds dual-behavior sequences via joint modeling of response outcomes and time intervals, takes explicit concept accuracy as a statistical prior, refines ability representations through conditional diffusion, and adopts content-enhanced item representations and an IRT-style prediction head. The method is validated on two online datasets and a newly constructed offline exam dataset named Computer. The core merit of this work is the real-world offline exam dataset, which expands the evaluation scope from online tutoring logs to high-stakes exam scenarios. However, four major issues remain:

  1. Insufficient novelty: A number of prior CD studies have already integrated temporal information, but none of these relevant works are cited. The claim that "the temporal dimension remains unexplored in CD" is unsupported.
  2. Weak evidence for the core contributions.
  3. The specific mechanism by which learning dynamics influence diagnostic performance is not clarified.
  4. Lack of mechanistic case analysis. For the reasons above, this paper is not recommended for acceptance.
Critical strengths
  1. This work introduces a new real-world offline examination dataset, dubbed Computer, that extends the evaluation scope of cognitive diagnosis from timestamped online tutoring logs to high-stakes exam scenarios.
Critical weaknesses

Insufficient novelty and missing discussion of closely related work. To the best of my knowledge, UTIRT, KPT, CT-NCM, TC-MIRT and several other studies have already incorporated temporal information into cognitive diagnosis, yet none of these direct prior works are cited or discussed in this paper. Furthermore, the paper fails to clarify the essential distinctions between the proposed DBSCD and these existing methods. As a result, the central claim that "the temporal dimension has not been explored in cognitive diagnosis" is factually untenable and not well supported.

  1. Weak empirical evidence for the core contribution. The empirical support for the core contribution — conditional diffusion-based ability refinement — is notably weak. In the ablation study, removing the diffusion module leads to an AUC drop of only 0.0009 on XES3G5M (from 0.8029 to 0.8020) and 0.0022 on MoocRadar (from 0.8716 to 0.8694). These effect sizes are comparable to, or even entirely fall within, the reported standard deviations across random seeds (0.0007 and 0.0022, respectively). The observed change in accuracy on XES3G5M also falls within the range of experimental noise, meaning the diffusion module does not deliver statistically meaningful performance gains.

  2. Unelaborated functional impacts of learning dynamics. The specific impacts of learning dynamics remain largely unillustrated. The paper only states that learning dynamics reflected by time intervals are insufficiently exploited, but does not elaborate on their concrete functional effects — for example, how time intervals map to forgetting mechanisms, knowledge retention patterns, or other well-established learning theories.

  3. Lack of interpretability and conditional analysis in experiments. The experimental design is deficient in in-depth case analysis and interpretability evidence. Across the entire paper, there is no empirical analysis or case study to explain why the introduction of time intervals and the diffusion module is effective, nor under what conditions (e.g., for specific student groups, exercise types, or interaction patterns) the proposed approach yields consistent benefits.

Questions for authors
  1. In the ablation study of the "w/o diffusion" variant, what specific component or operation replaces the proposed diffusion module? Is it substituted by an identity mapping, a linear projection layer, or another baseline operation?

  2. The abstract claims that the work models temporal learning dynamics. Does simply treating time intervals as embedding features provide sufficient justification for this claim? Furthermore, is there empirical evidence demonstrating that learned time interval embeddings outperform explicit forgetting curve formulations or classical stochastic process models in capturing temporal learning patterns?

  3. The baseline methods NCD and ACD exhibit notably poor AUC performance relative to other approaches. Have the authors analyzed the underlying reasons for this underperformance? For instance, does it stem from the inherent limitations of the methods, suboptimal implementation details, or misalignment with the experimental settings?

  4. To enhance the generality and cross-method comparability of the experimental results, the authors are requested to include at least one widely adopted benchmark dataset that is commonly used across mainstream cognitive diagnosis methods for experimental comparison.

Reviewer_QWnWOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes DBSCD, a cognitive diagnosis framework that combines dual behavior sequence modeling with conditional diffusion to estimate students’ knowledge mastery and predict their responses to target exercises. The method addresses the underuse of temporal information and the potential unreliability of ability estimates derived from limited response histories. It uses a Transformer to encode historical responses and time intervals alongside exercise and knowledge concept information, and supplements this representation with target-relevant local statistics. The resulting behavioral representation conditions a diffusion model that refines latent representations of concept-level historical accuracy. A gating mechanism combines the original and refined ability representations, while exercise representations incorporate ID embeddings, textual semantics, and knowledge concept structure. The model is jointly optimized using response prediction, diffusion denoising, and ability reconstruction losses. Experiments on two online educational datasets and one offline examination dataset report improved response prediction performance over the evaluated baselines, with ablation studies examining the contributions of selected components.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper is generally well written and easy to follow, with a clear explanation of the motivation and the overall framework.
  2. Experiments on two online educational datasets and one offline examination dataset, together with comparisons against multiple baselines and component ablations, provide a reasonably comprehensive evaluation of predictive performance.
  3. Incorporating response outcomes and time intervals provides a useful perspective on student behavior, while evaluation on real-world examination data demonstrates the method’s potential applicability to educational assessment.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The main novelty appears to lie in using target-aware historical behavior to condition the diffusion-based refinement of explicit accuracy-derived ability representations. However, it remains unclear whether diffusion is necessary for refining the ability representations. A controlled comparison with simpler alternatives, such as an MLP or a residual network that takes the same initial ability representation and historical behavioral features as input, would help establish the specific benefit of the diffusion mechanism.
  2. The ablation study does not fully cover the major proposed modules. While the conditional diffusion module is explicitly ablated, the dual-behavior historical enhancement module is only partially examined by removing time information. Likewise, the content-enhanced exercise representation is evaluated through individual feature removals rather than a clear ID-only counterpart. Module-level ablations would help clarify the contribution of each major component.
  3. Section 4.2 describes DDIM sampling during inference but does not explain how the diffusion-enhanced ability representation is obtained during training, or whether the prediction and reconstruction losses backpropagate through the denoising process. Section 4.1 also leaves the positional encoding, pooling operation, and projection of time embeddings unspecified. In addition, the timestep indexing and final output in Eqs. (9)–(10) should be clarified.
  4. Section 4.2 motivates the diffusion module by arguing that accuracy-based ability estimates are sensitive to sparse interactions. However, this claim is not directly examined in the experiments. Evaluating the full model and the variant without diffusion using different lengths of historical interaction sequences would help determine whether diffusion provides greater benefits when historical evidence is limited.
Questions for authors
  1. The main novelty appears to lie in using target-aware historical behavior to condition the diffusion-based refinement of explicit accuracy-derived ability representations. However, it remains unclear whether diffusion is necessary for refining the ability representations. A controlled comparison with simpler alternatives, such as an MLP or a residual network that takes the same initial ability representation and historical behavioral features as input, would help establish the specific benefit of the diffusion mechanism.
  2. The ablation study does not fully cover the major proposed modules. While the conditional diffusion module is explicitly ablated, the dual-behavior historical enhancement module is only partially examined by removing time information. Likewise, the content-enhanced exercise representation is evaluated through individual feature removals rather than a clear ID-only counterpart. Module-level ablations would help clarify the contribution of each major component.
  3. Section 4.2 describes DDIM sampling during inference but does not explain how the diffusion-enhanced ability representation is obtained during training, or whether the prediction and reconstruction losses backpropagate through the denoising process. Section 4.1 also leaves the positional encoding, pooling operation, and projection of time embeddings unspecified. In addition, the timestep indexing and final output in Eqs. (9)–(10) should be clarified.
  4. Section 4.2 motivates the diffusion module by arguing that accuracy-based ability estimates are sensitive to sparse interactions. However, this claim is not directly examined in the experiments. Evaluating the full model and the variant without diffusion using different lengths of historical interaction sequences would help determine whether diffusion provides greater benefits when historical evidence is limited.
Reviewer_Zv5TOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes DBSCD, a cognitive diagnosis framework that combines response outcomes and time intervals in a Transformer-based historical behavior representation. It constructs target-relevant local features and uses them to condition a diffusion module that refines a target-aware, concept-level accuracy prior. The model additionally combines exercise ID/text features and concept text/graph features for response prediction. Experiments on XES3G5M, MoocRadar, and a newly constructed Computer examination dataset report improvements over several cognitive diagnosis baselines. The paper also provides component ablations, hyperparameter sensitivity plots, and a class-level analysis.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper is well motivated. Modeling both response outcomes and time intervals, then conditioning ability refinement on target-relevant history, is a sensible formulation for addressing sparsity and response fluctuations in cognitive diagnosis.
  2. Broad empirical coverage. The evaluation includes two established public datasets and an offline examination dataset, together with comparisons against psychometric, neural, graph-based, debiased, and diffusion-based baselines.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper is generally readable, but it contains several grammatical, wording, and formatting issue. The abstract states that the method is evaluated on two real-world educational datasets, whereas the contribution list and experimental section describe experiments on three datasets.
  2. he paper does not precisely state how chronological splits, historical windows, and target interactions are constructed for each dataset, nor how future-information leakage is prevented.
Questions for authors

The evidence for the central diffusion-based refinement claim is limited. The AUC gain of the full model over “w/o diffusion” is small (0.0009 on XES3G5M and 0.0022 on MoocRadar), while the ablation table provides no uncertainty estimates or significance tests.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.