- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GeoPI-LNODE, which combines latent neural ODEs, geometry-conditioned reconstruction, and physics-informed regularization for long-horizon prediction of PDE-governed systems. The method evolves a low-dimensional latent state and reconstructs physical fields through a coordinate-based decoder.
The authors evaluate the method on three problems: fluid and scalar transport, nonlinear hyperelastic dynamics, and three-dimensional aneurysm flow. The results show improved prediction accuracy over several baselines, as well as better flow-rate balance in the aneurysm experiment.
Critical strengths
-
Combining latent dynamics with geometry-conditioned reconstruction and physics-informed regularization is a reasonable approach for long-horizon surrogate modeling. The method also supports field reconstruction on unstructured spatial discretizations.
-
The experiments cover different physical systems, including a complex three-dimensional aneurysm geometry. I also appreciate that the authors evaluate flow-rate imbalance rather than relying only on pointwise prediction errors.
Critical weaknesses
1. Concerns about baseline fairness and experimental reliability.
I am concerned about the baseline results in Table 2. FNO and DeepONet show extremely large errors or even diverge in some experiments, but the paper provides little explanation. Since these experiments mainly involve temporal extrapolation within fixed geometries, I would like to see stronger evidence that the baselines were properly tuned and trained.
The definition of Baseline LNODE is also confusing. Section 4.1 states that only the physics-based losses are removed, but Table 3 seems to indicate that geometry conditioning is also removed. This makes the reported performance differences difficult to interpret.
In addition, all datasets are generated by the authors, and the three-dimensional experiment lacks comparisons with some relevant methods, such as GINO or Transolver. Evaluation on a public benchmark would make the results more convincing.
2. Concerns about physical consistency, statistical results, and reproducibility.
Some RMSE means and standard deviations in Tables F.2 and F.3 appear mathematically inconsistent with the reported numbers of test cases.
The physics-informed loss also uses stopgrad to ignore spatial derivatives of geometry features. Therefore, the calculated residuals are not the full PDE residuals of the reconstructed fields. It remains unclear whether the method improves satisfaction of the original governing equations.
Furthermore, the enforcement of boundary conditions and the treatment of derivative scaling after normalization are not sufficiently explained. Important numerical simulation details, including solver settings and convergence studies, are also missing. These issues make it difficult to assess the reliability and reproducibility of the results.
Questions for authors
-
What is the exact origin of Baseline LNODE? Does it remove both geometry conditioning and physics-informed losses? How does it differ from "w/o physics-informed"? Also, how is the "w/o latent dynamics" ablation implemented?
-
Why do FNO and DeepONet show extremely large errors or diverge in some experiments? Were these baselines sufficiently tuned and trained to convergence? Could the authors provide training curves and consider comparisons with GINO, Transolver, or a public benchmark?
-
Some RMSE statistics in Tables F.2 and F.3 appear mathematically inconsistent. For example, Table F.2 reports 0.00195 ± 0.0173 for GeoPI-LNODE, which violates the standard deviation bound for 24 nonnegative per-case RMSE values. Could the authors clarify the calculations and provide per-case errors or evaluation scripts?
-
Since
stopgradignores the spatial derivatives of geometry features, does the method still reduce the actual PDE residuals when full derivatives are considered? How are boundary conditions enforced and derivative scaling factors handled after normalization? Also, could the authors provide more details on the numerical solvers, convergence studies, and actual inference speedup?
Minor comment: Two author names appear to be incorrect in the references. "Zhongang Zhang" should be "Zhongqiang Zhang" in Lu et al. (2021), and "Mattia Salvador" should be "Matteo Salvador" in Regazzoni et al. (2024).