- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper asks how does the properties of the reservoir representation change with synaptic and membrane time constants of LIF neurons in a liquid-state reservoir model. The properties of the reservoir that are of interest are the reliability and the dimensionality of representations. Results suggest that longer timescales might increase the reliability while they decrease the dimensionality. The effect on the decoder performance depends on the readout model and the fitting procedure. The intervention on time constants is constrained about the firing rates, enforcing the same firing rates when time constants are varied.
Critical strengths
The question that is addressed is of interest, in particular to neuroscience, even though the question is rather narrow and is not of great significance. Some of the methodology appears appropriate to address the question.
Critical weaknesses
- The text is cryptic and very machine-like. As far as I can tell, the question of the paper is relatively simple, but the presentation makes it sound very complicated. Instead of simply explaining what they are doing in a comprehensive way, the text is full of overly complicated expressions that makes the understanding of the text unnecessarily challenging. \
From the beginning, the main question and the motivation are not very clear. Can the authors motivate the question addressed more clearly from the beginning? I suggest to form one or two sentences that make it very clear what is the question addressed, at the cost of some simplification, if necessary, as details can be added later. Further, I suggest to use some space to explain why is it relevant.
The paragraph starting with line 110 reads as a list of techniques that are relevant to the methods of the paper. I instead suggest to have something less list-like, where sentences connect to each other logically and have a coherent flow of meaning.
A variable Ap is described in line 152, but this variable appears only later, in Eq. 4.
-
Authors perform a number of analyses, but the motivation for each analysis is poorly explained and the link between these analyses is essentially missing. The paper seems to be a set of results without drawing much connections between them. Again, this reads machine-like.
-
Synaptic and membrane time constants of LIF neurons change together. These time constants control difference aspects of temporal processing of the network. The synaptic time constant determines the temporal profile of the signal that is than integrated by the membrane time constant. Therefore, clearly, the effect of changing the synaptic and membrane time constants are not independent, and changing both at the same time confounds their effect.
Further, from the biological plausibility point of view, the time constants used in this study are longer than typical time constants in biological neurons. Already for Fast neurons, 8 ms is out of range for AMPA synapses (which are within 2-5 ms). All time constants of slow neurons are outside of biologically plausible ranges.
Questions for authors
(1) What are variables p and n in Eq. 2? Why do we have a division with a minimum? (2) What is the subscript tr in line 161 about? (3) Eq. 4: is H(Y) the Entropy? What is CE? (4) How is spike count Wasserstein distance defined? (5) Why are synaptic and membrane time constants of LIF neurons varied together? (6) Why did authors choose the time constants ranges which are mostly outside of biologically plausible ranges? (7) Can authors comment on a hypothesis about what is causing the main observed effects, e.g., the dimensionality reduction and reliability increase with longer time scales? Reliability might increase almost trivially as longer time constants imply more integration of the signal and more discounting of the noise by temporal averaging. (8) Why are firing rates matched? I am not sure that this is actually useful or helpful in this setting.