- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors introduce CLEF a novel closed-loop formulation for music editing. This approach is novel in music editing as it is distinct from single-pass or training free methods. The authors evaluated based on objective evaluation metrics, in terms of various aspects distributional fidelity and source preservation. The objective and subjective (w/ 25 participants) evaluation results demonstrate improvements over baselines.
Critical strengths
- The approach is distinct from existing ones, which primarily have focused on single-pass or training-free approaches.
- The approach shows improvements in terms of objective and subjective evaluations, over existing approaches.
Critical weaknesses
- The authors did not provide demo, and this is a critical weakness, considering the instability of generative audio evaluation metrics.
- The presentation can be significantly improved. For example, it is not immediately clear which musical aspects the model edited. In addition, Line 322 (We use ... CLAP ....) is not clear. It is not clear what the CLAP metric means by reading the sentence alone. (The readers must refer to Section 4 for the context.)
- The paper can better contextualize their core idea relative to iterative self-refinement frameworks in other modalities. (However, music/audio editing baselines are well-covered)
- Inference cost is high, as the authors suggested.
Overall, given the instability of generative audio evaluation metrics, it is difficult to validate the authors' contribution without demo and code.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors provide demo?
- Any reason why the authors cannot release the code?
- Can the authors sharpen novelty claims within the context of self-refinement frameworks in other modalities?