- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PARC-3D, a training-free framework for selecting visual candidates for 3D multimodal models. It combines support-size-based saliency calibration, spatial–semantic redundancy estimation, and adaptive greedy selection. Experiments show improvements across referring segmentation, question answering, and dense captioning, with the largest gains on referring segmentation.
Critical strengths
- Controlled evaluation: Comparisons keep the pretrained checkpoint, candidate pool, scene-state size, and downstream pipeline fixed, isolating the effect of candidate selection.
- Practical utility: PARC-3D requires no additional training and achieves substantial referring-segmentation gains, particularly on Multi3DRefer.
- Complementary analyses: Selection baselines, component ablations, and cross-interface experiments provide useful evidence beyond aggregate performance.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited methodological novelty: The method combines support-based score calibration, spatial–semantic redundancy suppression, and greedy selection. Its distinction from established diversity-aware selectors remains insufficiently demonstrated.
- Incomplete mechanism validation: Support–saliency correlations do not establish harmful bias, and increased spatial dispersion does not directly demonstrate preservation of distinct instances.
- Missing targeted ablations: Multi3DRefer shows the largest improvement, but lacks component ablations and single-/multi-target analyses needed to substantiate the proposed explanation.
- Insufficiently matched baselines: Comparisons do not establish whether MMR or DPP supplied with the same support calibration and spatial–semantic information could achieve similar results.
- Weak statistical evidence: Variability across heavily overlapping evaluation subsets does not establish the significance of paired improvements over competing methods.
Questions for authors
- Can you directly measure whether PARC-3D retains more distinct instances, rather than merely increasing spatial dispersion?
- Can you provide component ablations on Multi3DRefer and separate results for single- and multi-target expressions?
- What evidence distinguishes harmful support-size bias from a legitimate preference for more informative regions?
Clarification of PARC-3D’s Motivation and Contributions
We thank the reviewers for their time and feedback. We would like to clarify two points central to our work.
1. Support-associated representation priority. Our candidate-level audit reveals a systematic association between physical support, upstream saliency, and representation priority. The key distinction lies between candidate-level relevance and scene-level representation requirements: upstream saliency characterizes individual candidates, whereas the shared scene state must organize evidence across different physical scales and spatial locations. Directly inheriting support-associated saliency advantages can therefore leave fine-grained but informative evidence under-represented. VSC addresses this mismatch by calibrating the support-associated saliency advantage while preserving upstream learned relevance.
2. The contribution of scene-state curation. PARC-3D studies how learned perceptual evidence is organized into a shared scene state before downstream reasoning. It addresses two coupled decisions: which evidence receives representation priority and which evidence is considered redundant. VSC calibrates priority, while CSR models redundancy jointly in semantic and physical space, distinguishing semantic similarity from physical redundancy. Residual-utility construction integrates these two signals into the shared scene state. Controlled experiments, component ablations, and cross-interface evaluations support this formulation while keeping the pretrained model and scene-state size fixed within each comparison. These findings highlight scene-state curation as a representation problem complementary to representation learning and cross-modal optimization.
We have decided to withdraw this submission and appreciate the reviewers’ consideration.