- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies few-shot class-incremental learning (FSCIL), where base classes are learned from abundant data and novel classes are subsequently introduced with only a few labeled examples, with evaluation over all seen classes. The authors propose BASIL, which addresses the joint use of learned base-class prototypes and support-estimated novel-class prototypes. Following base-session VPT adaptation, the method freezes the representation and applies concentration-weighted attentive calibration to base prototypes and expansive calibration to novel-class scores using real support features and tangent references. Experiments on CUB-200, CIFAR-100, and mini-ImageNet show competitive performance, with additional evaluations on FGVC-Aircraft and iNF200.
Critical strengths
- Reasonable methodological motivation. The proposed method explicitly accounts for the different estimation conditions of base and novel prototypes. Applying centroid alignment to learned base prototypes and local-reference scoring to few-shot novel classes is a coherent design that reflects the statistical imbalance in FSCIL.
- Evaluation across multiple benchmarks. The method is evaluated on five FSCIL benchmarks, including CUB-200, CIFAR-100, mini-ImageNet, FGVC-Aircraft, and iNF200. The additional evaluations beyond the three main benchmarks broaden the empirical validation and help demonstrate the applicability of the approach across different datasets.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited methodological novelty. The proposed method combines concentration-weighted centroid alignment with interpolation between mean-prototype and local-reference scores. While the integration is reasonable and well motivated, the overall methodological novelty appears limited and mainly lies in combining these calibration mechanisms.
- Limited comparison with simpler calibration baselines. Although the paper includes component ablations, the additional benefit of the proposed calibration designs over simpler baselines remains somewhat unclear. Comparisons with simple weight–centroid interpolation and local scoring using only the mean prototype and real support features would strengthen the evaluation.
Questions for authors
- Base-prototype calibration. How does the proposed alignment compare with simpler alternatives, such as interpolation between learned base-class weights and empirical centroids?
- Contribution of tangent references. Could the authors compare against a local-reference set containing only the mean prototype and real support features, without tangent references?
- Concentration-dependent weighting. Does concentration-weighted alignment still outperform uniform alignment when the regularization strength is tuned separately for each variant?