- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper argues that target speaker extraction (TSE) suffers when the enrollment and target utterances differ in emotion. It manually labels emotions for 2,332 enrollment utterances of REAL-TSE and builds the CE-TSE dataset by mixing emotional speech corpora and REAL-TSE with room impulse responses and noise. It proposes an emotion-disentanglement module with shared encoder, speaker and emotion latents, reconstruction, classification and adversarial losses, while only the speaker latent is used at inference.
Critical strengths
Targets a real and under-studied factor and contributes manual emotion annotations for a real-recording TSE corpus, and Tte module is backbone-agnostic and yields consistent gains in the reported setting.
Critical weaknesses
The dataset and experiments are under-specified since no number or hours of mixtures, splits, speaker disjointness, or fraction and construction of cross-emotion pairs. There is no breakdown of matched vs mismatched emotion, so the motivating problem and the benefit of the module are never directly demonstrated. The evaluation is even only on the authors' own synthetic data. Moreover, the gain is not attributed to emotion disentanglement because L_spk and L_emo share one weight, with no speaker-only multitask control, and some claims are overstated.
Questions for authors
Which is the training/evaluation target, dry or reverberant? How are references selected, and how many annotators labeled the data? Why is CETSE-Net the same performance as USEF-TSE + CE? why the SepFormer is missing in tab 2