acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Train for Many, Update with One: Improving Multi-Sample Reasoning via Fenchel-Bregman Posterior Learning

Abstract

Multi-sample reasoning measures *candidate coverage*, the probability that at least one of candidates is correct. However, minimizing the average loss of individual attempts does not directly optimize candidate coverage. We therefore formulate *finite- posterior learning*, which trains a distribution over solver parameters to reduce the probability that all independently generated candidates fail. To optimize this objective efficiently, we propose a Fenchel-Bregman (FB) approach that requires only one posterior draw per update, rather than the used by direct Monte Carlo optimization. FB first uses an exact Fenchel reformulation to separate problem-specific weights from the posterior update, enabling one-draw posterior updates. It then applies a closed-form Bregman update to track these weights through an exponential running average of observed failures, reusing the same draw. We instantiate FB with IVON, a variational optimizer for Gaussian posteriors over solver parameters, yielding **Fenchel-Bregman IVON (FBI)**. Across diverse recursive and autoregressive reasoning tasks, FBI improves candidate coverage. In a matched comparison, it also achieves comparable Pass@10 while using only 6.8% of the direct Monte Carlo baseline's measured training time per update.

Primary area:
probabilistic methods (Bayesian methods, variational inference, sampling, UQ, etc.)
Keywords:
Multi-sample reasoning, Finite-K posterior learning, Test-time scaling, Variational inference, Fenchel–Bregman optimization

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 4%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.33 over 3 reviews, above 96% of the others.
Reviewer_Rq3BOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper formulates finite-(K) posterior learning by minimizing the probability that all (K) independently sampled solvers fail. It derives an exact Fenchel reformulation and uses Bregman/EMA tracking of problem-specific weights, allowing IVON posterior updates with one parameter draw. Experiments on recursive reasoning and Qwen3-4B report improved Pass@(K) and substantially lower per-update cost than Direct-(K).

Critical strengths
  1. The finite-(K) objective directly matches candidate coverage, and the Fenchel derivation clearly exposes the problem-specific weighting.
  2. The method is evaluated on recursive and autoregressive models. The matched comparison with Direct-10 shows comparable coverage with substantially lower measured update time and FLOPs.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Several central differences are small, for example, the average language-model gain over DMPO is 0.84 points, and the Qwen experiment uses one training seed. Error bars and matched multi-seed comparisons are needed to determine whether these gains are robust.

  2. The gains in the paper are not clearly tied to finite-K weighting. On MATH, λ = 1 on the first visit and each problem is seen about 1.28 times. On Sudoku, the EMA barely moves from its initial value. On Maze, K_train = 1 already reaches 90.8 Pass@10. Maybe a constant-weight IVON baseline is needed?

  3. Most margins are within seed noise. The same Maze run gives 91.7 for one seed and 91.3 averaged over three seeds. Key comparisons differ by only 0.1–0.6 points. The LLM result is from a single seed, and the average lead comes mostly from AIME25 with only 30 problems.

Questions for authors

See the weakness above.

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Responses

Thank you for recognizing the finite-KK objective's direct connection to candidate coverage and the efficiency of the matched Direct-10 comparison. Your comments helped us strengthen the evidence on training variability, isolate the contribution of finite-KK weighting, and clarify the scope of the LLM gains. Below, we summarize these additions and their main findings. We will provide detailed answers to each concern in separate responses (Responses 1–3), including the supporting results and theoretical analysis.

  • 1. Repeated training and paired tests support the reported gains.

    • We now report mean ± SE over three independent training runs for the recursive benchmarks and LLM comparison (Tables 1–2; Response 1).
    • The 0.70-point training-target gain and 0.60-point problem-weighting gain on Maze-Hard are significant in two-sided paired t-tests (p=0.003p=0.003 and p=0.018p=0.018, respectively; Appendix C.1, Tables 15–16; Response 3).
    • For the LLM, FBI's average Pass@8 advantage is 1.14 percentage points over Pass@KK Training (p=0.045p=0.045) and 1.72 points over DMPO (p=0.042p=0.042) (Table 2; Response 1).
    • All tests use three matched training runs.
  • 2. Matched controls support a contribution beyond IVON alone.

    • With the same IVON optimizer and matched training settings, FBI improves Maze-Hard Pass@10 by 0.70 percentage points and LLM average Pass@8 by 1.12 points over constant-weight controls (Appendix C.1, Tables 16–17; Response 2).
    • On Maze-Hard, FBI also exceeds hard mining and soft weighting by 0.40 points; in the autoregressive LM, its gain over minibatch-mean weights remains significant under the same limited-revisit schedule (Response 2).
    • On Sudoku-Extreme, FBI achieves 99.55 ± 0.25% Pass@10 versus 98.90 ± 0.30% with EMA frozen at initialization, a 0.65-point gain (p=0.007p=0.007) that supports a tracking benefit despite near-initial failure estimates (Response 2).
  • 3. AIME25 drives the largest gain, with improvements also on MATH500 and AMC23.

    • FBI achieves 33.46 ± 0.12% AIME25 Pass@8, compared with 26.25 ± 2.04% for Pass@KK Training (Table 2; Response 3).
    • FBI also achieves the highest mean Pass@8 on MATH500 (91.48%) and AMC23 (84.46%), leading on three of the five benchmarks (Table 2; Response 3).
    • These results support improved average coverage over the specified five-benchmark suite, with performance varying by benchmark (Section 4.2, Table 2; Response 3).
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response 1: Error Bars and Matched Multi-Seed Comparisons

W1) The small performance differences, including the 0.84-point average LLM gain over DMPO from one training seed, need error bars and matched multi-seed comparisons to establish robustness.


Thank you for pointing out that the missing error bars and single-seed LLM comparison made the gains difficult to assess. The repeated LLM results retain FBI's average Pass@8 advantage, and we now report the spread of the recursive benchmark results.

Repeated results are mean ± SE across three independent training runs per method. P-values use two-sided paired t-tests on matched runs. At p<0.05p<0.05, O denotes a significant FBI advantage and X a significant comparator advantage; △ denotes no significant difference.


1. Matched LLM comparisons across training seeds

We repeated training for FBI and all five trained baselines in the autoregressive LM setting with the same five-benchmark evaluation protocol. Each benchmark column reports Pass@8 (%), and Avg. is the unweighted mean across the five benchmarks, computed within each run before aggregation.

MethodMATH500OlymMATHAMC23AIME24AIME25Avg.p vs. FBI (Avg.)
Base87.8053.5775.1834.1521.5654.45N/A
GRPO89.44 ± 0.5560.72 ± 0.7279.38 ± 0.4728.37 ± 0.3626.12 ± 1.5556.81 ± 0.16<0.001 (O)
Pass@KK Training91.30 ± 0.3561.91 ± 0.9983.49 ± 0.5232.34 ± 0.5426.25 ± 2.0459.06 ± 0.430.045 (O)
DMPO90.40 ± 0.5161.45 ± 0.2081.43 ± 1.1731.54 ± 0.9827.61 ± 0.9258.48 ± 0.550.042 (O)
MaxRL91.08 ± 0.2962.88 ± 0.8283.79 ± 1.1330.25 ± 0.8826.24 ± 1.3758.85 ± 0.470.067 (△)
MMPO90.78 ± 0.4360.80 ± 0.9678.98 ± 1.5128.57 ± 1.5425.32 ± 1.2256.89 ± 0.680.026 (O)
FBI91.48 ± 0.0860.45 ± 0.3084.46 ± 0.4231.19 ± 0.2433.46 ± 0.1260.20 ± 0.18—

The submitted 0.84-point lead over DMPO was from a single training seed. Across the repeated runs, the average lead is 1.72 percentage points over DMPO (p=0.042p=0.042) and 1.14 points over Pass@KK Training (p=0.045p=0.045), the strongest baseline by repeated-run average. FBI's mean exceeds MaxRL's by 1.35 percentage points, but the paired comparison is not significant (p=0.067p=0.067).

The advantage is aggregate: MaxRL leads on OlymMATH, while Pass@KK Training and DMPO remain higher on AIME24. Table 2 of the revised manuscript now includes the full repeated-run results. For AIME25's contribution to the overall average, see Response 3.


2. Recursive benchmark comparisons with uncertainty estimates

The following table summarizes candidate coverage using the TRM backbone. All performance entries are percentages.

BenchmarkMetricPTRMW-PTRMFBIp vs. PTRMp vs. W-PTRM
Sudoku-ExtremePass@1097.38 ± 0.2598.84 ± 0.2999.55 ± 0.25<0.001 (O)0.004 (O)
Maze-HardPass@1088.40 ± 0.1689.80 ± 0.3491.30 ± 0.210.002 (O)0.009 (O)
ARC-AGI-1Pass@10060.25 ± 1.0661.25 ± 1.1664.25 ± 0.900.005 (O)0.011 (O)
ARC-AGI-2Pass@10011.94 ± 0.6610.69 ± 1.0612.78 ± 0.720.016 (O)0.027 (O)

FBI's coverage improvements over PTRM and W-PTRM have p<0.05p<0.05 on all four benchmarks. With the FPRM backbone on Maze-Hard, FBI also improves Pass@10 from W-FPRM's 88.70 ± 0.24% to 94.80 ± 0.62% (p=0.005p=0.005). The revised manuscript reports the recursive results with SEs in Table 1 and the additional FPRM comparison in Figure 3(a).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response 2: Contribution of Finite- Weighting beyond IVON and Simpler Controls (1/2)

W2) The contribution of finite-KK weighting is unclear: MATH starts with λ=1\lambda=1 and averages only about 1.28 visits per problem, Sudoku's EMA stays near its initial value, and Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=1 already reaches 90.8% Pass@10 on Maze-Hard. A constant-weight IVON baseline is needed to isolate the weighting contribution.


Thank you for highlighting the need to separate posterior learning from the contribution of finite-KK weighting. Matched controls show that finite-KK weighting adds coverage gains beyond constant-weight IVON on Maze-Hard and the autoregressive LM, including under the latter's limited-revisit schedule. On Sudoku-Extreme, updating the EMA also improves coverage over freezing it at initialization, directly addressing the near-initial-estimate concern.

Within each weighting ablation, we keep IVON, initialization, loss processing, KL regularization, and the training budget fixed. We compare the following weighting rules:

  • Constant weights: λ=1\lambda=1, retaining posterior learning without problem-specific weights.
  • Minibatch-mean weights: one shared weight per minibatch, preserving its mean FBI weight while removing differences between problems.
  • OHEM-style EMA hard mining [1]: retain the hardest 50% of problems by their EMA failure estimates, including cutoff ties.
  • Rank-based EMA soft weighting [2]: use positive exponential weights based on EMA difficulty ranks, with selection pressure 100.

Hard mining and soft weighting adapt the cited methods to EMA-based loss weighting and match the mean FBI weight computed from each control's own estimates. These controls distinguish the finite-KK weight mapping from posterior learning, a shared weight scale, and simpler uses of the same difficulty estimates. P-values use two-sided paired t-tests over three matched training runs. At p<0.05p<0.05, O denotes a significant FBI advantage and X a significant comparator advantage; △ denotes no significant difference.


1. Maze-Hard: gains beyond a strong posterior learner

The weighting ablation in Appendix C.1, Table 16 retains Ktrain=10K_{\mathrm{train}}=10 and one posterior draw per update.

WeightingPass@10 (mean ± SE, %)p vs. FBI
Constant-weight (λ=1\lambda=1)90.60 ± 0.220.003 (O)
Minibatch-mean weights90.70 ± 0.190.018 (O)
OHEM-style EMA hard mining90.90 ± 0.170.037 (O)
Rank-based EMA soft weighting90.90 ± 0.140.046 (O)
FBI91.30 ± 0.21—

FBI improves Pass@10 by 0.70 percentage points over constant-weight IVON and 0.60 points over minibatch-mean weights. It also exceeds both hard mining and soft weighting by 0.40 points, with p=0.037p=0.037 and p=0.046p=0.046, respectively. Together, these comparisons support a contribution from the finite-KK problem-specific mapping beyond a shared weight scale or difficulty ranking alone (Appendix C.1, Table 16).

The Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=1 control has λ=1\lambda=1, so its Pass@10 result is also 90.60 ± 0.22%. We use this same control result and paired comparison (p=0.003p=0.003) in the training-target and weighting ablations (Appendix C.1, Tables 15–16).


2. Autoregressive LM: contribution under limited revisits

At Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=1, the weight Ktrainf^Ktrain−1K_{\mathrm{train}}\widehat f^{K_{\mathrm{train}}-1} equals one, so constant-weight IVON also serves as the Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=1 control in this ablation. All conditions retain eight responses per prompt, and FBI uses Ktrain=8K_{\mathrm{train}}=8. The controls use the same short training schedule, so the limited opportunity for revisits applies to all conditions.

WeightingAvg. Pass@8 (mean ± SE, %)p vs. FBI
Constant-weight IVON (Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=1)59.08 ± 0.270.015 (O)
Minibatch-mean weights58.96 ± 0.290.009 (O)
OHEM-style EMA hard mining59.39 ± 0.470.113 (△)
FBI (Ktrain=8K_{\mathrm{train}}=8)60.20 ± 0.18—

Avg. is the unweighted mean across the five mathematical-reasoning benchmarks. FBI improves average Pass@8 by 1.12 percentage points over constant-weight IVON (p=0.015p=0.015) and 1.24 points over minibatch-mean weights (p=0.009p=0.009). Its 0.81-point average advantage over hard mining is not statistically significant (p=0.113p=0.113; Appendix C.1, Table 17).

At the same limited-revisit budget, the significant gains over constant and minibatch-mean weights support a measurable contribution from problem-specific reweighting. Thus, infrequent revisits do not make FBI equivalent to constant-weight IVON in the evaluated autoregressive LM setting.

Reviewer_5tKYOpenReview ↗
Rating
4(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper trains a distribution over solver parameters to improve the chance that at least one of a fixed number of candidates is correct. It rewrites the all-fail objective using a separate weight for each problem. This allows a posterior update from one new parameter draw, while a Bregman update tracks the weights using a running failure estimate. The implementation uses IVON. Experiments cover recursive puzzle solvers and a language model, with comparisons to direct multi-draw training and ablations of the training budget and problem-specific weights.

Critical strengths
  1. The problem in the Introduction has a clear basis: minimizing one-attempt failure and minimizing the chance that all independent attempts fail are different objectives. Equations 1 to 3 make the distinction precise. The exact Fenchel identity and the closed-form Bregman update are derived clearly in Appendix A, including the independence assumption and the limited meaning of fixed-weight unbiasedness. I did not find an obvious algebraic error in those derivations.

  2. The controlled Maze-Hard comparison directly tests whether the method addresses the proposed training cost problem. FBI keeps similar reported Pass@10 while using one rather than ten new posterior draws. The study also compares different training budgets, removes problem-specific weighting while preserving its average scale, and varies the failure-estimate smoothing and KL strength. Gains appear with two recursive backbones and in mathematical reasoning. The review formatting and equations look normal, although some labels in Figures 2 to 4 are small.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The evidence for the smaller accuracy gains needs uncertainty estimates. The paper reports means over three training runs for the recursive results, but does not show their spread. The central objective and weighting ablations improve Maze-Hard Pass@10 by only 0.5 and 0.6 percentage points, respectively. It is unclear whether those differences are stable. The language-model result uses one stated training seed, and its mean Pass@8 gain over DMPO is 0.84 points. The per-dataset results also include losses, such as 31.00 versus 34.65 on AIME24. Repeated-run variation would help separate a consistent improvement from sensitivity to training or sampling.

  2. The exact derivation and the implemented training objective need a clearer connection. Appendix A.3 correctly says that a fixed-weight gradient matches the finite-budget gradient only at the optimal weight. The actual weight is a nonlinear function of a noisy, potentially outdated running estimate. In the recursive experiments, the failure score is also a transformed task loss rather than the binary failure event. The algebra alone therefore does not show that practical updates follow the exact coverage objective. The existing ablations help, but the main budget and weighting tests are concentrated on Maze-Hard. Directly checking tracked weights against multi-draw failure estimates, and giving any existing corresponding language-model ablations, would better support the claim that each main component solves the stated mismatch.

Questions for authors
  1. Could you report the spread across the three recursive training runs, particularly for the training-budget and problem-weight ablations? Are repeated language-model training results available for the 0.84-point average Pass@8 gain?

  2. Have the running failure estimates or their induced weights been compared with failure rates from several fresh posterior draws? This would clarify the gap between the exact reformulation and the implemented update.

  3. Are the training-budget, problem-weight, or tracking ablations also available for the language-model experiment? Please distinguish existing results from suggested future experiments.

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Responses

Thank you for recognizing the finite-KK motivation, the derivations, and the controlled efficiency comparison. Your comments helped us identify where the submission needed stronger evidence on training variability, practical failure tracking, and component contributions beyond Maze-Hard. Below, we summarize these additions and their main findings. We will provide detailed answers to each concern in separate responses (Responses 1–3), including the supporting results and theoretical analysis.

  • 1. Repeated training supports the reported gains.

    • We added SEs for the recursive benchmarks and Maze-Hard ablations (Table 1 and Tables 15–16; Response 1).
    • Across three independent LLM training runs, FBI retains the highest average Pass@8 at 60.20 ± 0.18%, compared with 59.06 ± 0.43% for the strongest baseline, Pass@KK Training (Table 2; Response 1).
  • 2. Comparisons using independent posterior draws quantify the EMA tracking gap.

    • We directly compare running failure estimates and induced weights with references estimated from independent posterior draws in both model settings.
    • Relative weight gaps are 8.82% for the recursive model and 9.16% for the autoregressive LM (Appendix B.7, Table 14(b); Response 2).
    • We also added bounds characterizing surrogate-score mismatch and EMA tracking error (Appendices A.5–A.6).
  • 3. LLM ablations support a contribution from finite-KK weighting.

    • New three-run comparisons include constant-weight IVON (Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=1), minibatch-mean weights, and hard mining, while retaining eight responses per prompt.
    • FBI improves average Pass@8 by 1.12 percentage points over constant-weight IVON (Appendix C.1, Table 17; Response 3).
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response 1: Variability across Training Runs (1/2)

W1) The small gains need uncertainty estimates: the recursive results omit run-to-run variation, the Maze-Hard training-target and weighting ablations improve Pass@10 by only 0.5–0.6 percentage points, and the single-seed LLM comparison shows a 0.84-point average gain over DMPO with losses on some benchmarks.

Q1) Please report the spread across the three recursive training runs, especially for the training-target and problem-weight ablations, and provide repeated LLM training results.


Thank you for highlighting the missing uncertainty estimates. The repeated comparisons retain the Maze-Hard ablation gains and FBI's average autoregressive LM advantage. All p-values use two-sided paired t-tests on three matched training runs. O indicates a significant advantage for FBI (or the matched training target) at p<0.05p<0.05, and △ indicates no significant difference.


1. Recursive benchmark results

Acc. is selected accuracy and Pass@KK is coverage among KK candidates, with performance entries in percent. Tests compare with FBI (TRM), except that W-FPRM is compared with FBI (FPRM), using the coverage metric specified in each p-value column.

Sudoku-Extreme

MethodAcc. (%)Pass@10 (%)p vs. FBI (Pass@10)
FPRM94.33 ± 0.13—N/A
TRM87.28 ± 0.16—N/A
PTRM97.36 ± 0.2697.38 ± 0.25<0.001 (O)
W-PTRM98.83 ± 0.2898.84 ± 0.290.004 (O)
FBI (TRM)99.53 ± 0.2599.55 ± 0.25—

Maze-Hard

MethodAcc. (%)Pass@10 (%)p vs. FBI (Pass@10)
FPRM86.60 ± 0.16—N/A
TRM87.00 ± 0.12—N/A
PTRM87.70 ± 0.1488.40 ± 0.160.002 (O)
W-PTRM87.50 ± 0.1389.80 ± 0.340.009 (O)
FBI (TRM)88.00 ± 0.1791.30 ± 0.21—
W-FPRM86.90 ± 0.1188.70 ± 0.240.005 (O)
FBI (FPRM)87.70 ± 0.1594.80 ± 0.62—

ARC-AGI-1

MethodPass@1 (%)Pass@2 (%)Pass@100 (%)p vs. FBI (Pass@100)
FPRM—47.50 ± 0.73—N/A
TRM40.00 ± 0.5444.38 ± 0.2959.50 ± 0.620.006 (O)
PTRM40.50 ± 0.7344.88 ± 0.5960.25 ± 1.060.005 (O)
W-PTRM40.37 ± 0.8745.25 ± 0.7761.25 ± 1.160.011 (O)
FBI (TRM)40.63 ± 0.4447.50 ± 0.4764.25 ± 0.90—

ARC-AGI-2

MethodPass@1 (%)Pass@2 (%)Pass@100 (%)p vs. FBI (Pass@100)
FPRM—6.20 ± 0.00—N/A
TRM5.00 ± 0.007.50 ± 0.4311.53 ± 0.430.048 (O)
PTRM5.00 ± 0.637.50 ± 0.5111.94 ± 0.660.016 (O)
W-PTRM5.00 ± 0.637.08 ± 0.3110.69 ± 1.060.027 (O)
FBI (TRM)5.42 ± 0.548.19 ± 0.2212.78 ± 0.72—

FBI retains higher multi-candidate coverage than PTRM and W-PTRM on all four benchmarks (p<0.05p<0.05; Table 1). The additional FPRM backbone comparison is included in the Maze-Hard table above and Figure 3(a).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response 1: Variability across Training Runs (2/2)

2. Maze-Hard training-target and weighting ablations

Training target

We vary KtrainK_{\mathrm{train}} while retaining one posterior draw per update.

Training targetPass@1 (%)Pass@2 (%)Pass@5 (%)Pass@10 (%)
Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=187.8 ± 0.1388.8 ± 0.1090.5 ± 0.1290.60 ± 0.22
Ktrain=2K_{\mathrm{train}}=287.7 ± 0.1589.1 ± 0.1490.5 ± 0.1991.0 ± 0.29
Ktrain=5K_{\mathrm{train}}=587.6 ± 0.1189.1 ± 0.1290.8 ± 0.1591.1 ± 0.24
Ktrain=10K_{\mathrm{train}}=1087.7 ± 0.1489.0 ± 0.1590.6 ± 0.1991.3 ± 0.21
Pairwise t-test (p; result)—0.026 (O)0.014 (O)0.003 (O)

The p-value row compares Ktrain=KK_{\mathrm{train}}=K with Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=1 within each column. The Pass@10 gain over the constant-weight Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=1 control is 0.70 percentage points (p=0.003p=0.003; Appendix C.1, Table 15).

Problem-specific weighting

All conditions use IVON at Ktrain=10K_{\mathrm{train}}=10 with matched training settings. Constant weights use λ=1\lambda=1, while minibatch-mean weights share one value across problems. We adapt online hard example mining (OHEM) [1] and exponential rank-based selection [2] to EMA failure estimates. Hard mining keeps the hardest 50%, including cutoff ties, and assigns zero weight to the rest. Soft weighting assigns exponentially decreasing weights from hardest to easiest (selection pressure 100). Both controls preserve the mean FBI weight computed from their own EMA estimates.

WeightingPass@1 (%)Pass@2 (%)Pass@5 (%)Pass@10 (%)p vs. FBI (Pass@10)
Constant-weight (λ=1\lambda=1)87.2 ± 0.1388.3 ± 0.1890.1 ± 0.1690.6 ± 0.220.003 (O)
OHEM-style EMA hard mining [1]87.6 ± 0.0988.7 ± 0.1790.2 ± 0.1990.9 ± 0.170.037 (O)
Rank-based EMA soft weighting [2]87.6 ± 0.1188.8 ± 0.1290.2 ± 0.1290.9 ± 0.140.046 (O)
Minibatch-mean weights87.5 ± 0.0888.7 ± 0.1690.0 ± 0.1890.7 ± 0.190.018 (O)
FBI87.7 ± 0.1489.0 ± 0.1590.6 ± 0.1991.3 ± 0.21—

FBI improves Maze-Hard Pass@10 by 0.60 percentage points over minibatch-mean weights (p=0.018p=0.018; Appendix C.1, Table 16).


3. Repeated autoregressive LM training

The repeated autoregressive LM comparison reports Pass@8 (%) for FBI and all five trained baselines, with Base as a reference. Avg. is the unweighted mean across the five benchmarks, computed within each run before aggregation.

MethodMATH500OlymMATHAMC23AIME24AIME25Avg.p vs. FBI (Avg.)
Base87.8053.5775.1834.1521.5654.45N/A
GRPO89.44 ± 0.5560.72 ± 0.7279.38 ± 0.4728.37 ± 0.3626.12 ± 1.5556.81 ± 0.16<0.001 (O)
Pass@KK Training91.30 ± 0.3561.91 ± 0.9983.49 ± 0.5232.34 ± 0.5426.25 ± 2.0459.06 ± 0.430.045 (O)
DMPO90.40 ± 0.5161.45 ± 0.2081.43 ± 1.1731.54 ± 0.9827.61 ± 0.9258.48 ± 0.550.042 (O)
MaxRL91.08 ± 0.2962.88 ± 0.8283.79 ± 1.1330.25 ± 0.8826.24 ± 1.3758.85 ± 0.470.067 (△)
MMPO90.78 ± 0.4360.80 ± 0.9678.98 ± 1.5128.57 ± 1.5425.32 ± 1.2256.89 ± 0.680.026 (O)
FBI91.48 ± 0.0860.45 ± 0.3084.46 ± 0.4231.19 ± 0.2433.46 ± 0.1260.20 ± 0.18—

FBI exceeds Pass@KK Training, the strongest baseline by repeated-run average, by 1.14 percentage points (p=0.045p=0.045), and DMPO by 1.72 points (p=0.042p=0.042; Table 2). FBI's mean exceeds MaxRL's by 1.35 percentage points, but the paired comparison is not significant (p=0.067p=0.067). Pass@KK Training and DMPO remain higher on AIME24, while MaxRL leads on OlymMATH.


References:

[1] Abhinav Shrivastava, Abhinav Gupta, and Ross Girshick, 2016, Training Region-Based Object Detectors With Online Hard Example Mining, CVPR.

[2] Ilya Loshchilov and Frank Hutter, 2016, Online Batch Selection for Faster Training of Neural Networks, ICLR Workshop, arXiv:1511.06343.

Reviewer_zES8OpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how to improve Pass@K performance by learning a distribution over model parameters rather than optimizing a single model. The proposed FBI method uses Fenchel duality and Bregman-based tracking to transform the multi-sample objective into weighted single-sample updates, reducing the number of parameter samples required during training. Experiments on structured reasoning tasks and mathematical reasoning benchmarks demonstrate improvements in Pass@K and computational efficiency over existing methods.

Critical strengths
  • Optimizing Pass@K is a meaningful objective for reasoning tasks where multiple candidate solutions can be generated at inference time. The paper identifies a practical difficulty in directly optimizing this objective, as sampling multiple parameter configurations for each training update can be computationally expensive. 
  • The Fenchel–Bregman formulation provides an interesting perspective on this problem. By using estimated failure probabilities to weight individual training updates, the method connects a multi-sample objective with a more efficient optimization procedure. The mathematical analysis helps explain the motivation behind this formulation. 
  • The experiments cover both controlled reasoning environments and larger language-model settings. FBI achieves substantial reductions in parameter-sampling overhead in the controlled experiments, and the reported improvements on mathematical reasoning benchmarks suggest that the approach can extend beyond synthetic tasks.
Critical weaknesses
  • The main optimization procedure relies on tracking problem-level failure probabilities and using them to reweight subsequent updates. Although the Fenchel–Bregman formulation provides a mathematical interpretation, the resulting algorithm resembles a form of difficulty-aware sample reweighting combined with an existing posterior optimizer. It is not entirely clear whether the proposed formulation provides a substantial advantage over a simpler reweighting baseline using the same optimizer and training setup. Such a comparison would help establish the methodological novelty more clearly. 
  • The theoretical analysis mainly supports the reformulation of the idealized Pass@K objective. In practice, however, the failure probabilities are estimated through moving averages, and optimization relies on surrogate updates rather than exact objective gradients. The effect of these approximations is not sufficiently characterized, leaving a gap between the theoretical formulation and the actual training procedure. 
  • While the controlled experiments show clear computational benefits, the improvements on larger language models are relatively modest. The average Pass@8 score across the mathematical reasoning benchmarks increases from 59.60 for DMPO to 60.44 for FBI, and FBI does not consistently outperform DMPO on every benchmark. Given the relatively small margin and the lack of reported variability across independent training runs, it is difficult to determine whether these improvements are statistically reliable. 
  • The efficiency evaluation focuses heavily on reducing the number of parameter samples per update. However, the method still requires estimating and maintaining failure-probability weights, and fewer parameter samples do not necessarily imply proportional reductions in total training cost. More explicit end-to-end computational comparisons under matched training budgets would make the practical efficiency claims more convincing.
Questions for authors
  1. How does FBI compare with a simpler difficulty-aware reweighting baseline using the same posterior optimizer and training setup? What additional benefits come from the Fenchel–Bregman formulation? 
  2. How do the moving estimates of failure probabilities and surrogate updates affect the theoretical properties of the original Pass@K objective? 
  3. Given the relatively small improvements on mathematical reasoning benchmarks, could the authors provide evidence of their statistical reliability across independent training runs? 
  4. How does FBI compare with existing methods in terms of total training cost under matched computational budgets, rather than only the number of parameter samples per update?
8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Responses

Thank you for recognizing the motivation for finite-KK coverage, the Fenchel–Bregman formulation, and its computational benefits. Your comments helped us strengthen the evidence for the weighting mechanism, characterize the practical approximations, and evaluate reliability and total training cost. Below, we summarize these additions and their main findings. We will provide detailed answers to each concern in separate responses (Responses 1–4), including the supporting results and theoretical analysis.

  • 1. Finite-KK weighting improves over simpler controls.

    • Under matched IVON and training settings on Maze-Hard, FBI achieves 91.30 ± 0.21% Pass@10, compared with 90.60 ± 0.22% for constant weights and 90.90% for both hard mining and soft weighting.
    • The autoregressive LM comparison also shows a 1.12-percentage-point improvement over constant-weight IVON (Appendix C.1, Tables 16–17; Response 1).
  • 2. Bounds and diagnostics characterize the approximation gap.

    • We bound surrogate-induced differences in finite-KK values and weights, and analyze how EMA tracking error affects weights and the fixed-weight data gradient (Appendices A.5–A.6; Response 2).
    • The diagnostics show a limited surrogate-value gap: 3.06 percentage points in the practical recursive comparison and below one percentage point (0.92) with matched terminal outputs (Appendix B.7, Table 14(a); Response 2).
    • EMA-weighted data gradients remain closely aligned with references estimated from independent posterior draws, with cosine similarities of 98.13% for the recursive model and 96.52% for the autoregressive LM (Appendix B.7, Table 14; Response 2).
  • 3. Repeated training supports the average LLM advantage.

    • Across three independent training runs, FBI achieves the highest average Pass@8 at 60.20 ± 0.18%, compared with 59.06 ± 0.43% for Pass@KK Training and 58.48 ± 0.55% for DMPO.
    • These average gains are statistically significant in two-sided paired t-tests over the three matched runs: p=0.045p=0.045 against Pass@KK Training and p=0.042p=0.042 against DMPO (Table 2; Response 3).
  • 4. The coverage advantage persists at comparable measured training cost.

    • Our expanded accounting includes failure tracking, posterior sampling, and model transfer.
    • At approximately 26 GPU-hours on the same eight-GB200 setup, FBI exceeds Pass@KK Training and DMPO by 1.85 and 2.17 percentage points in average Pass@8, respectively (Appendix B.6, Tables 11–12; Response 4).
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response 1: Comparison with Simpler Reweighting Baselines

W1) FBI resembles difficulty-aware reweighting combined with an existing posterior optimizer, and its advantage over simpler weighting rules under the same training setup is unclear.

Q1) How does FBI compare with simpler difficulty-aware reweighting using the same optimizer and training setup, and what additional benefits come from the Fenchel–Bregman formulation?


Thank you for pointing out the need for this direct comparison. We have added matched IVON controls and observe additional coverage gains with FBI in both recursive and autoregressive models.


1. What the Fenchel–Bregman formulation adds

For a problem with mean failure score fˉϕ(x)\bar f_\phi(x), differentiating the finite-KK term fˉϕ(x)K\bar f_\phi(x)^K gives the gradient weight Kfˉϕ(x)K−1K\bar f_\phi(x)^{K-1}. The Fenchel reformulation separates this weight from the posterior update, and the Bregman update reduces to EMA tracking, yielding the practical weight λx,t=Kf^x,tK−1\lambda_{x,t}=K\widehat f_{x,t}^{K-1}, where f^x,t\widehat f_{x,t} is the running failure estimate. Thus, the formulation provides a weighting and tracking rule derived from the target candidate budget KK, with one posterior draw per update (Section 3).


2. Matched weighting controls

Within each model setting, we compare diverse weighting rules.

  • Constant weights: λ=1\lambda=1, retaining posterior learning without problem-specific weighting.
  • Minibatch-mean weights: every problem in the minibatch receives the same mean FBI weight, removing within-batch differences while preserving their average scale.
  • OHEM-style EMA hard mining: inspired by online hard example mining in Shrivastava et al. (2016), we retain the hardest 50% of problems according to their EMA failure estimates, including ties at the cutoff.
  • Rank-based EMA soft weighting: we adapt the exponential rank-based sampling of Loshchilov and Hutter (2016) into loss weights, assigning larger weights to harder EMA-ranked problems while retaining positive weights for all problems, with selection pressure 100.

Both hard and soft controls preserve the mean scale of the FBI weights computed from each control's own EMA estimates. This tests the finite-KK weight mapping against alternative uses of the same difficulty information. P-values below use two-sided paired t-tests over three matched training runs. O indicates a significant FBI advantage at p<0.05p<0.05, and △ indicates no significant difference.

2-1. Recursive model

On Maze-Hard, all conditions use Ktrain=10K_{\mathrm{train}}=10 and one posterior draw per update.

WeightingPass@10 (mean ± SE, %)p vs. FBI
Constant-weight (λ=1\lambda=1)90.60 ± 0.220.003 (O)
Minibatch-mean weights90.70 ± 0.190.018 (O)
OHEM-style EMA hard mining90.90 ± 0.170.037 (O)
Rank-based EMA soft weighting90.90 ± 0.140.046 (O)
FBI91.30 ± 0.21—

FBI improves Pass@10 by 0.70 percentage points over constant weights and by 0.40 points over both hard mining and soft weighting. These gains support a contribution beyond IVON alone, a shared weight scale, or difficulty ranking alone (Appendix C.1, Table 16).

2-2. Autoregressive LM

All conditions retain eight responses per prompt, and FBI uses Ktrain=8K_{\mathrm{train}}=8. Constant-weight IVON also serves as the Ktrain=1K_{\mathrm{train}}=1 control, where the weight equals one. Avg. Pass@8 is the average across the five mathematical-reasoning benchmarks.

WeightingAvg. Pass@8 (mean ± SE, %)p vs. FBI
Constant-weight IVON59.08 ± 0.270.015 (O)
Minibatch-mean weights58.96 ± 0.290.009 (O)
OHEM-style EMA hard mining59.39 ± 0.470.113 (△)
FBI60.20 ± 0.18—

FBI improves average Pass@8 by 1.12 percentage points over constant-weight IVON and by 1.24 points over minibatch-mean weights. Its average gain over hard mining is 0.81 points, although this comparison is not statistically significant across the three runs (p=0.113p=0.113). Together, the controls support a benefit from finite-KK problem-specific weighting beyond posterior learning and a shared weight scale in both recursive and autoregressive models (Appendix C.1, Table 17).


References

[1] Shrivastava et al., 2016, Training Region-Based Object Detectors With Online Hard Example Mining, CVPR.

[2] Loshchilov and Hutter, 2016, Online Batch Selection for Faster Training of Neural Networks, ICLR Workshop Track.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response 2: Effects of Surrogate Scores and EMA Tracking (1/2)

W2) The theory supports the idealized Pass@KK reformulation, but the effects of moving failure estimates and surrogate updates on practical optimization are insufficiently characterized.

Q2) How do the moving estimates of failure probabilities and surrogate updates affect the theoretical properties of the original Pass@KK objective?


Thank you for highlighting the gap between the ideal formulation and practical updates. We now quantify surrogate-score mismatch and EMA tracking error with explicit bounds and measurements of the resulting value, weight, and data-gradient differences.


1. Surrogate failure scores

1-1. Theoretical effect

For a fixed problem, let Fˉ\bar F denote its binary failure probability and fˉ\bar f its mean training failure score. For fˉ,Fˉ∈[0,1]\bar f,\bar F\in[0,1] and K≥2K\geq2,

|(1-\bar f^K)-(1-\bar F^K)| &\leq K|\bar f-\bar F|,\\ |K\bar f^{K-1}-K\bar F^{K-1}| &\leq K(K-1)|\bar f-\bar F|. \end{aligned}$$ Thus, the discrepancy between the two mean failure scores bounds **both the coverage-value difference and the change in the optimal weight**. The Fenchel reformulation expresses $\bar f^K$ **exactly** as a maximization of a weighted mean failure score minus a convex penalty on the weight. This equality holds for either bounded score mean, and the common KL term is unchanged. Appendix A.5 provides the derivation. **1-2. Empirical validation** For the recursive model on Maze-Hard at $K=10$, we compare training scores with binary failure at fixed checkpoints. We also include a matched-output control that recomputes the score at the same terminal output and observation point used for binary evaluation. | Comparison (mean ± SE) | Failure-score gap (pp) | Coverage-value gap (pp) | Relative weight gap (%) | | --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | | Training score | 4.31 ± 0.71 | 3.06 ± 0.28 | 7.22 ± 1.20 | | Matched-output score | 2.07 ± 0.18 | 0.92 ± 0.05 | 4.02 ± 0.59 | Failure-score and coverage-value gaps are mean absolute differences across problems. The relative weight gap is the summed absolute weight difference divided by the summed reference weights, expressed as a percentage; here, the reference uses binary failure probabilities. The practical comparison, which includes differences between training and final-output observations, has a coverage-value gap of **3.06 percentage points**. With terminal outputs matched, this falls **below one percentage point**, with a **relative weight gap of 4.02%** (Appendix B.7, Table 14(a)). These diagnostics indicate a **limited effect of the surrogate approximation** on finite-$K$ values and induced weights at the evaluated checkpoints.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

We sincerely appreciate the reviewers' careful reading and constructive feedback. The reviews recognize the motivation for finite-KK candidate coverage and the efficient one-draw formulation, while identifying gaps in empirical reliability, evidence for the weighting mechanism, approximation analysis, and total-cost evaluation. Their suggestions helped us strengthen the evidence and clarify the scope of our claims. We summarize the main advances below.


1. Repeated training supports the average coverage gains. (zES8, 5tKY, Rq3B)

The repeated LLM comparison retains FBI's lead in average Pass@8, addressing concerns about dependence on a single training seed.

  • We now report mean ± SE over three independent training runs for the recursive benchmark results (Table 1; 5tKY, Response 1) and the training-target and weighting ablations (Tables 15–16; 5tKY, Response 1).
  • For autoregressive LM, FBI achieves 60.20 ± 0.18% average Pass@8, compared with 59.06 ± 0.43% for Pass@K Training and 58.48 ± 0.55% for DMPO (Table 2; zES8, Response 3; 5tKY, Response 1; Rq3B, Response 1).

2. Finite-KK weighting contributes beyond posterior learning alone. (zES8, 5tKY, Rq3B)

The matched controls we added show that finite-KK weighting improves coverage beyond posterior learning alone, addressing requests for simpler weighting baselines and LLM ablations.

  • Using the same IVON optimizer and matched training settings, FBI improves Maze-Hard Pass@10 by 0.7 percentage points over constant weights and by 0.4 points over both hard mining and rank-based soft weighting (Table 16; zES8, Response 1; Rq3B, Response 2).
  • The LLM weighting ablation also shows a 1.12-point gain in average Pass@8 over constant-weight IVON (Table 17; 5tKY, Response 3).

3. Approximation analysis quantifies the practical gap and shows close gradient alignment. (zES8, 5tKY)

New theoretical bounds and empirical diagnostics together characterize the approximation gap, with closely aligned mean data gradients in both tested model settings.

  • Theoretical analysis.

    • We bound the effects of surrogate-score mismatch on finite-KK values and weights (Appendix A.5; zES8, Response 2).
    • We also bound EMA tracking error and its effects on weights and the fixed-weight data gradient under the stated assumptions (Appendix A.6; zES8, Response 2).
  • Empirical validation.

    • The mean absolute surrogate-versus-binary coverage-value gap is 3.06 percentage points in the practical recursive comparison and 0.92 points with matched terminal outputs (Table 14(a); zES8, Response 2).
    • Diagnostics using independent posterior draws quantify EMA estimate and weight errors (Table 14(b); 5tKY, Response 2), while mean data gradients have cosine similarities of 0.9813 for the recursive model and 0.9652 for the LLM (Table 14(c); zES8, Response 2).

4. FBI's coverage advantage persists at comparable measured training cost. (zES8)

The added comparisons show that FBI achieves higher average coverage at comparable measured training cost, accounting for weight tracking, posterior sampling, and model transfer.

  • FBI's average Pass@8 exceeds Pass@K Training by 1.85 percentage points and DMPO by 2.17 points at comparable measured budgets (Table 12; zES8, Response 4).
  • At the selected training endpoints, FBI also uses less cumulative GPU time, with 300 updates versus 500 for the baselines (Table 11; zES8, Response 4).
  • FBI retains its per-update cost advantage after removing Direct-10's probe/replay recomputation (Appendix B.6, Table 9; zES8, Response 4).

5. Additional studies pursued independently of reviewer requests.

We pursued these additional comparisons and refined the resource measurements on our own initiative to strengthen the study.

  • Following up on the submission's future-work direction of richer posteriors, we added Bayesian comparisons and applied FB to EVON's structured Gaussian posterior, improving coverage over EVON alone (Section 4.3, Figure 3(b), and Appendix B.5).

  • We further explored latent-space Direct-10 as an alternative way of generating candidate diversity, with FBI achieving higher coverage in the comparison (Appendix B.6, Table 13).

  • We also remeasured the one-GPU training costs using a smaller matched data batch and a Direct-10 implementation without probe/replay recomputation. FBI uses 12.3% of Direct-10's time per update in this revised benchmark, compared with the previously reported 6.8% (Appendix B.6, Table 9).

We thank the reviewers again for helping us strengthen the evidence and clarify the scope of our claims.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.