acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

When Mismatches Overlap: Concurrent Verification for Speculative Decoding

Abstract

Speculative decoding (SD) accelerates large language model inference by verifying multiple draft tokens in a single target-model pass. Strict verification stops at the first mismatch and discards all remaining drafts, even though the target model has already computed predictions for later positions. Deferred verification addresses this waste by treating subsequent target outputs as evidence: instead of rejecting a mismatch immediately, the verifier continues and resolves it based on what follows. However, a later mismatch can arise before an earlier one is resolved, leaving multiple verification decisions pending simultaneously. Existing methods focus on the earliest pending mismatch: a later mismatch triggers rejection instead of becoming an independent verification decision, limiting draft reuse. We introduce PEND, a concurrent verifier that maintains a separate state for each pending mismatch while sharing subsequent target predictions across them. PEND adapts evidence requirements to target-relative support, weights subsequent observations by target confidence, and commits a draft segment only after all pending mismatches resolve. Using only cached target outputs from the current verification pass, PEND improves throughput by 46.6-70.3% (57.2% on average across the evaluated settings) relative to vanilla SD across two model families and four benchmarks, while keeping task quality close to strict verification and achieving better quality-efficiency trade-offs than recent deferred-verification baselines.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Large Language Models, Speculative Decoding, Continuation Verification

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_7AGqOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes PEND, a relaxed verifier for speculative decoding that maintains separate decisions for overlapping draft–target mismatches. Later target predictions contribute confidence-weighted evidence to each pending mismatch, and a segment is committed only when all pending mismatches have resolved. Local target support controls mismatch admission and the required evidence mass. The method reuses predictions from the existing target-model pass. Experiments cover two draft–target model pairs and four benchmarks, with throughput improvements of 46.6–70.3% over vanilla speculative decoding and generally small changes in measured task quality. The appendix establishes properties of the verifier under cached draft-prefix distributions; these are not guarantees of exact target-distribution preservation or downstream correctness.

Critical strengths
  1. Treating overlapping mismatches as separate pending decisions is a useful extension of deferred verification. Joint commitment addresses the case where evidence resolves the first mismatch but leaves a later one unresolved. The first-mismatch-only ablation and the evidence-sharing ablation support the importance of this distinction.

  2. The implementation uses target outputs that have already been computed, and the measured throughput gains are substantial across both model pairs and all four tasks. Reporting task quality alongside speed is appropriate for a method that deliberately relaxes exact verification. The manuscript also clearly limits its theoretical claims to the cached draft trajectory.

Critical weaknesses
  1. PEND and the baselines are tuned differently. Appendix C.2 and Table 4 use task-specific two-parameter grids for PEND, centered on development-selected settings, but task-shared threshold grids for the baselines. The speed gain over vanilla speculative decoding is still clear. However, the comparison with other relaxed verifiers would be more convincing if all methods were tuned on the same development data with comparable search budgets.

  2. The quality results need more detail. Throughput variability is reported, but the quality differences lack paired uncertainty estimates, and the paper does not state how much degradation would be acceptable. For example, Qwen HumanEval+ changes from 87.80 to 86.59 pass@1, while Llama MT-Bench changes from 7.04 to 6.94. Since later evidence is conditioned on the draft continuation, the appendix’s local regret bounds cannot establish that these changes remain small on new inputs.

Questions for authors
  1. What development examples and selection objective were used for each benchmark? Do PEND’s quality–throughput advantages remain when the competing relaxed verifiers receive task-specific tuning with comparable search budgets?

  2. Can you report paired outcome changes for HumanEval+ and GSM8K, and uncertainty for the reported quality differences? In particular, how many examples become incorrect versus become correct relative to strict verification?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer(Part 1 of 3)

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful evaluation and constructive suggestions. In response, we conduct task-specific baseline calibration under a matched search budget. We also provide paired quality analyses and uncertainty estimates to quantify the effects of relaxed verification. Furthermore, we clarify the quality–throughput objective, parameter-selection criteria, and scope of PEND's theoretical guarantees, providing a more comprehensive assessment of PEND's effectiveness and limitations.

1. Response to Paired Quality Changes and Uncertainty.

Strict verification may reject plausible draft candidates, limiting effective draft-token utilization. Prior studies, including Judge Decoding (ICLR 2025), MARS (Findings of ACL 2026), and FLy (ICLR 2026), have explored relaxed verification to improve decoding efficiency while maintaining task quality.

PEND likewise adopts relaxed verification rather than aiming to preserve exact agreement with the target model's output. It further improves draft utilization through concurrent verification and evidence accumulation across multiple mismatch positions, seeking higher decoding throughput while controlling task-quality degradation. Accordingly, we focus on the task-quality–throughput tradeoff rather than exact token-level equivalence with Vanilla SD.

To quantify the impact of relaxed verification on task quality, we conduct paired comparisons between Vanilla SD and PEND on HumanEval+ and GSM8K, estimating 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for quality differences using paired bootstrap resampling. Quality differences are defined as the change in task accuracy of PEND relative to Vanilla SD.

Table R1. Paired quality changes and throughput comparison.

DatasetBoth CorrectC→II→CBoth WrongΔ Quality (pp)95% CI (pp)Vanilla SD (tok/s)PEND (tok/s)Gain
HumanEval+1359713−1.22[−6.10, +3.66]23.7039.13+65.1%
GSM8K1244191640−0.23[−1.14, +0.68]26.0640.91+57.0%
Note: C→I indicates correct under Vanilla SD but incorrect under PEND; I→C indicates the reverse.

The results reveal bidirectional sample-level quality changes, including both improvements and degradations. PEND exhibits observed accuracy reductions of 1.22 and 0.23 percentage points on HumanEval+ and GSM8K, respectively, while improving throughput over Vanilla SD by 65.1% and 57.0%. These findings demonstrate substantial decoding-throughput gains with relatively small observed aggregate quality reductions on both benchmarks, consistent with PEND's objective of improving the task-quality–throughput tradeoff.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer(Part 2 of 3)

2. Response to Fairness of Baseline Calibration.

In the original main performance comparisons, we primarily adopt the configurations recommended in the respective baseline papers or official implementations, ensuring fidelity to their established settings and reproducibility. In Appendix C.2, we also conduct controlled parameter sweeps to examine their quality and throughput under different configurations.

To further assess whether benchmark-specific calibration affects the comparison, we conduct benchmark-specific tuning experiments.

The calibration protocol is summarized as follows:

  1. Development sets. For HumanEval+, we use 128 fixed tasks sampled from MBPP+. For GSM8K, we use 256 fixed samples from its training set, excluding the 800 samples previously used for SelfJudge training and threshold-candidate construction.
  2. Search budget. For each of FLy, LinguaSpec, MARS, and SelfJudge, we evaluate 5 coarse-search configurations followed by 5 local-refinement configurations on each task, using the same task-specific development data.
  3. Selection criterion. Configurations are required to incur no more than a 2-percentage-point quality reduction relative to Vanilla SD on the development set. Among qualifying configurations, we prioritize throughput. When a configuration achieves at least 99% of the highest qualifying throughput, we prefer the configuration with higher task quality.
  4. Final evaluation. Final parameters are selected exclusively using development-set results and frozen before evaluation on the complete test sets.

Table R2. Task-specific calibration results.

DatasetMethodCorrectPass@1 / EMMATThroughput (tok/s)Speedup
HumanEval+Vanilla SD144/16487.80%9.1323.701.50×
SelfJudge127/16477.44%15.1940.392.56×
MARS132/16480.49%12.9036.712.33×
FLy142/16486.59%12.0034.102.17×
LinguaSpec140/16485.37%11.6833.342.12×
PEND142/16486.59%13.8539.132.48×
GSM8KVanilla SD1263/131995.75%9.7626.061.60×
SelfJudge1209/131991.66%14.8839.402.41×
MARS1249/131994.69%13.3240.962.51×
FLy1243/131994.24%12.8838.982.39×
LinguaSpec1257/131995.30%12.4437.602.30×
PEND1260/131995.53%13.1940.912.51×

The results in Table R2 support the following statements:

  1. Higher throughput while maintaining task quality on HumanEval+. PEND achieves 86.59% Pass@1 and 39.13 tok/s, delivering 14.8% higher throughput than the tuned FLy at identical task quality. Although SelfJudge achieves slightly higher throughput, it incurs substantially greater quality degradation. These results indicate that PEND improves decoding efficiency without relying on substantial task-quality degradation, even when competing methods are independently calibrated.

  2. Stronger quality preservation at competitive throughput on GSM8K. PEND achieves 95.53% EM and 40.91 tok/s, maintaining nearly identical throughput to the tuned MARS while improving EM by 0.84 percentage points. It also achieves higher quality and throughput than FLy and LinguaSpec. These results suggest that PEND can sustain high decoding throughput while better preserving task quality, rather than obtaining efficiency gains primarily through more permissive verification.

  3. Robustness to task-specific baseline calibration. Across both benchmarks, PEND remains competitive after each baseline is independently tuned under the same search budget and quality-constrained selection protocol. Importantly, its favorable quality–throughput performance persists beyond comparisons against recommended baseline configurations, indicating that the observed advantages are not solely attributable to differences in baseline parameterization.

Overall, these results strengthen the evidence that PEND's concurrent multi-mismatch verification provides an effective mechanism for improving draft utilization while controlling task-quality degradation, with its benefits remaining evident under task-specific baseline calibration.

We have incorporated the task-specific calibration protocol and corresponding results into Appendix C.2 (Table 6) of the revised manuscript, with all additions highlighted in blue for ease of reference.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer(Part 3 of 3)

3. Response to Quality–Throughput Tradeoff and Scope of Theoretical Guarantees.

(1) Quality–Throughput Objective and Quality Tolerances

Our quality–throughput objective is to maximize decoding throughput while controlling task-quality changes. Given the different scales of evaluation metrics, we adopt corresponding quality tolerances: at most 2 percentage points in Pass@1/EM for HumanEval+ and GSM8K, 0.02 in average answer F1 for HotpotQA, and 0.2 points in average score for MT-Bench. These thresholds represent approximately comparable numerical tolerances on their respective metric scales, providing a consistent principle for quality control across tasks.

  • Parameter selection. During parameter selection, we prioritize throughput among configurations satisfying the development-set quality tolerances. For candidates achieving at least 99% of the highest qualifying throughput, we prefer those with higher task quality. Final configurations are selected using development data and frozen before testing.

  • Quality assessment. Actual quality changes and their uncertainty are further quantified through paired outcome analyses and confidence intervals.

(2) Counterfactual Continuation and Scope of Theoretical Guarantees.

We acknowledge that subsequent target-model predictions are conditioned on the original draft prefixes and therefore do not represent the counterfactual continuation that would arise after correcting an earlier mismatch under strict verification. Explicitly obtaining such counterfactual predictions would require additional target-model computation along the corrected prefixes, potentially involving repeated forward passes and substantial computational overhead, particularly when multiple mismatches are involved.

  • PEND's verification objective. PEND instead aims to determine whether mismatched draft tokens can be accepted under relaxed verification conditions, rather than reconstructing the strict target model's generation trajectory. To this end, PEND leverages target-model predictions already cached during a single verification pass, combining target-model support at each mismatch position with confidence-weighted subsequent evidence and evidence accumulation to assess whether each mismatch satisfies its acceptance conditions. This enables concurrent resolution of multiple mismatches without additional target-model forward passes.

  • Relationship to prior work. This design shares a common principle with continuation-based relaxed verification methods such as FLy (ICLR 2026), which also leverage subsequent predictions along the draft trajectory to assess the acceptability of earlier mismatches, rather than explicitly computing counterfactual continuations. PEND further incorporates mismatch-specific target-model support and confidence-weighted evidence accumulation to establish separate acceptance conditions for multiple mismatches and coordinate their resolution.

  • Theoretical scope and limitations. These conditions do not guarantee equivalence to strict target-model outputs or task quality on unseen inputs. As discussed in Appendix B.6, PEND's local regret bounds and subsequent evidence constraints are defined over the draft-conditioned distributions cached within the current verification round.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comment by Authors

Dear Reviewer 7AGq,

We would like to kindly follow up on our previous response. We would greatly appreciate it if you could let us know whether our clarifications and revisions have adequately addressed your concerns. If any questions or concerns remain, we would be happy to provide further explanations.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Reviewer_FAsXOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes PEND, a concurrent verification framework for speculative decoding that independently tracks multiple overlapping pending mismatches while sharing subsequent target-model evidence. It combines target-support-adaptive admission, confidence-weighted evidence accumulation, and joint segment commitment. Experiments on two model families and four benchmarks demonstrate substantial throughput improvements over vanilla speculative decoding while largely preserving task quality.

Critical strengths
  • Well-motivated problem and meaningful contribution. The paper identifies overlapping pending mismatches as an underexplored limitation of deferred verification. The mismatch-specific state tracking and shared evidence mechanism provide a coherent solution.
  • Strong empirical results. PEND achieves an average throughput improvement of 57.2% over vanilla SD across eight settings, with relatively small task-quality changes. The ablation studies further support the effectiveness of the proposed components.
Critical weaknesses
  • Insufficient justification of heuristic verification rules. PEND relies on hand-designed evidence weighting and mismatch-specific thresholds. While ablations demonstrate their effectiveness, the paper does not sufficiently justify these design choices or establish whether continuation agreement reliably indicates the acceptability of earlier mismatches.
  • Limited characterization of concurrent verification benefits. While the First-Mismatch-Only ablation demonstrates quality improvements, the paper does not clearly isolate the contribution of concurrent mismatch handling to overall efficiency. A more detailed analysis of performance across different concurrency levels would better substantiate the central contribution.
Questions for authors
  • Scalability to larger batch sizes: All experiments are conducted with batch size one. How well does PEND generalize to larger batch sizes, particularly in terms of throughput gains and verification overhead?
  • Contribution of concurrent verification: How much of PEND's improvement is specifically attributable to concurrent mismatch handling? A breakdown of performance by the maximum number of simultaneously pending mismatches would help clarify this contribution.
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer(Part 1 of 3)

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the constructive comments and insightful suggestions. In response, we extend PEND's evaluation to larger batch sizes, examining throughput, task quality, and verification-logic overhead. We also conduct concurrency-capacity ablations and concurrency-level analyses to isolate the contribution of concurrent mismatch handling. Finally, we clarify the motivation, theoretical scope, and empirical support for PEND's verification rules, further substantiating its effectiveness and scalability.

1. Response to Scalability to Larger Batch Sizes.

PEND focuses on concurrent multi-mismatch verification using cached predictions from a single target-model verification pass. The original evaluation uses batch size 1, a common setting in speculative verification studies, to minimize interference from variations in sequence lengths, request scheduling, and hardware resource utilization, ensuring controlled comparisons. However, PEND is not restricted to single-request inference. Pending mismatch states are maintained independently across requests, and concurrent verification decisions rely on cached target-model predictions without additional target-model forward passes.

To evaluate scalability, we conduct additional experiments on HumanEval+ with batch sizes of 2, 4, 8, and 16, comparing Target-only, Vanilla SD, and PEND under identical settings.

Table R1. Task quality and throughput across batch sizes.

BatchTarget Pass@1SD Pass@1PEND Pass@1Target (token/s)SD (token/s)PEND (token/s)SD / TargetPEND / TargetPEND / SD
286.59%86.59%84.76%25.4540.2060.651.58×2.38×1.51×
486.59%86.59%84.76%44.8972.63109.161.62×2.43×1.50×
886.59%86.59%84.76%81.79129.79195.821.59×2.39×1.51×
1686.59%86.59%84.76%150.54227.39338.221.51×2.25×1.49×

Task quality and throughput. As shown in Table R1:

  • Stable task quality. PEND maintains 84.76% Pass@1 across all batch sizes, with identical outputs for each task across batch sizes, indicating no additional quality degradation as batch size increases.
  • Sustained throughput advantage. PEND consistently outperforms Vanilla SD in throughput, achieving 48.7%–50.9% improvements. At batch size 16, PEND reaches 338.22 token/s, corresponding to 2.25× and 1.49× the throughput of Target-only and Vanilla SD, respectively.
  • Scalability of verification benefits. Although its speedup over Target-only decreases at larger batch sizes, PEND consistently maintains approximately 1.5× throughput over Vanilla SD, demonstrating sustained benefits from its verification mechanism.

Table R2. Generation time and verification-logic overhead across batch sizes.

BatchTarget (min)Vanilla SD (min)PEND (min)Avg. Logic Time (ms/round)Total Logic Time (s)Logic Overhead (%)
239.9225.2717.380.4761.2480.120%
422.6313.999.660.6260.9130.157%
812.427.835.380.8350.6760.210%
166.754.473.121.1210.5110.273%

Verification overhead. As shown in Table R2:

  • Limited verification overhead. The average per-round verification-logic time increases from 0.476 ms to 1.121 ms as batch size grows. Nevertheless, its cumulative overhead accounts for only 0.120%–0.273% of total generation time, indicating limited additional computation for concurrent mismatch verification.
  • End-to-end efficiency gains. At batch size 16, PEND completes all 164 tasks in 3.12 minutes, compared with 4.47 minutes for Vanilla SD, reducing total generation time by 30.2%. This confirms that throughput improvements translate into reduced end-to-end generation time.

Overall, PEND maintains approximately 1.5× throughput over Vanilla SD at larger batch sizes, with verification-logic overhead below 0.3% and no additional quality degradation as batch size increases. These results demonstrate PEND's applicability and scalability in batched inference.

We have incorporated the batch-size scalability experiments and corresponding analyses into Section 5.5 (Table 4) and Appendix C.6 of the revised manuscript, with all additions highlighted in blue for ease of reference.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer(Part 2 of 3)

2. Response to Contribution of Concurrent Verification.

We conduct concurrency-capacity ablations and concurrency-level analyses to quantify the independent contribution and runtime behavior of concurrent mismatch handling.

(1) Concurrency-Capacity Ablation.

On HumanEval+ and GSM8K, we compare C1 (at most one pending mismatch), C2 (at most two), and Full PEND, varying only concurrency capacity to isolate its effects on task quality, draft utilization, and throughput.

Table R3. Quality and efficiency under different concurrency capacities.

DatasetMethodQuality (%)MATTotal Verification RoundsThroughput (tok/s)TPOT (ms)
HumanEval+Vanilla SD87.809.13672824.3841.02
C185.3712.52497733.7129.67
C285.9813.64462738.7225.83
Full PEND86.5913.85456939.4125.38
GSM8KVanilla SD95.759.763503525.6738.95
C195.1512.642631336.2927.55
C295.5313.132537040.1124.93
Full PEND95.5313.192529340.5724.65

Note: Total verification rounds denotes the number of draft-generation–target-verification iterations over the complete dataset. Each round involves one target-model verification forward pass, excluding prefill.

The results in Table R3 support the following observations:

  • Independent contribution of concurrent verification. Compared with C1, Full PEND improves throughput by 16.91% and 11.79%, and MAT by 10.62% and 4.35% on HumanEval+ and GSM8K, respectively, while increasing task quality by 1.22 and 0.38 percentage points.
  • Improved draft utilization and fewer verification rounds. Furthermore, Full PEND reduces verification rounds by 408 and 1,020, corresponding to 9.62% and 4.19% fewer rounds per 1,000 generated tokens, respectively. These results provide direct evidence that concurrent mismatch handling improves draft utilization per target-model verification pass, thereby reducing verification rounds per generated token and improving throughput.
  • Diminishing marginal gains at higher concurrency capacity. Compared with C2, Full PEND further improves throughput by 1.78% and 1.15%, respectively, with smaller marginal gains consistent with the lower frequency of higher concurrency levels (Table R4).

(2) Performance Analysis Across Concurrency Levels.

We group Full PEND's verification rounds by the maximum number of simultaneously pending mismatches (0, 1, 2, and ≥3) and measure the proportion and efficiency of each group.

Table R4. Performance by maximum number of simultaneously pending mismatches.

DatasetMax. PendingRoundsRound ShareMATThroughput (tok/s)
HumanEval+0244353.47%14.0743.08
1142931.28%14.2637.00
252111.40%12.9232.21
≥31763.85%10.2924.95
GSM8K01681666.48%12.6338.76
1716228.32%14.3640.13
211414.51%14.1933.89
≥31740.69%13.2437.53

The results in Table R4 provide further insights into the runtime behavior of concurrent verification:

  • Distribution of concurrent mismatches. Rounds with at least two pending mismatches account for 15.25% and 5.20% on HumanEval+ and GSM8K, respectively, while those with at least three account for only 3.85% and 0.69%. This distribution confirms the occurrence of concurrent mismatches and is consistent with the larger gains from C1 to C2 than from C2 to Full.
  • Per-round efficiency under concurrent verification. Per-round efficiency depends on PEND's verification conditions. More pending mismatches imply more unresolved acceptance conditions. Although each mismatch can independently accumulate subsequent evidence, draft segments are committed only when all relevant conditions are satisfied; otherwise, rejection limits committed tokens. Thus, higher concurrency does not necessarily yield higher per-round MAT or throughput.
  • End-to-end benefits of concurrent verification. Concurrency gains arise from fewer target-model verification rounds over complete generations. Unlike C1, Full PEND can continue verifying additional mismatches and retain more draft tokens upon satisfying their acceptance conditions, reducing subsequent verification rounds. Hence, despite lower efficiency in some high-concurrency rounds, concurrent verification improves end-to-end throughput through greater draft utilization and fewer target-model forward passes, consistent with Table R3.

Overall, the capacity ablation and concurrency-level analysis confirm the independent contribution of concurrent mismatch handling to task quality and decoding efficiency, supported by higher throughput, improved quality, and fewer target-model verification rounds.

We have incorporated the concurrency-capacity ablation experiments and corresponding analyses into Section 5.4 (Table 3) of the revised manuscript, with all additions highlighted in blue for ease of reference.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer(Part 3 of 3)

3. Response to Justification of Heuristic Verification Rules.

Our design is motivated by three considerations.

  1. First, mismatches differ in their target-model support and should not be treated equally. Strict verification rejects any draft token that differs from the target model's Top-1 prediction, even when the draft token has relatively high target-model probability. We therefore use target-relative disagreement to distinguish mismatches with different levels of target support. A mismatch with weaker support is less suitable for relaxed acceptance and should require stronger subsequent evidence. This motivates both the local admission rule and the mismatch-specific evidence requirement, which increases with local disagreement.

  2. Second, subsequent target-model predictions differ in their informativeness. A prediction with a larger separation between the target model's Top-1 and Top-2 probabilities reflects a more decisive local preference than one with nearly tied alternatives. Accordingly, PEND uses the normalized Top-2 probability margin to weight subsequent observations, while accounting for their disagreement with the draft tokens. Evidence accumulation therefore considers both the amount of available evidence and its consistency with the draft continuation, rather than relying solely on the number of subsequent matches.

  3. Third, continuation agreement provides supporting evidence for relaxed acceptance, rather than a guarantee of correctness. Subsequent target-model predictions are conditioned on the original draft prefixes, so their agreement with draft tokens does not establish that an earlier mismatch would also be accepted along the strict target-model continuation. Instead, PEND uses these cached predictions to assess whether a mismatch satisfies explicitly defined relaxed verification conditions. Requiring sufficient confidence-weighted evidence mass and bounded continuation disagreement prevents acceptance based solely on a few potentially ambiguous observations. When multiple mismatches remain pending, these conditions are evaluated independently for each mismatch before the corresponding draft segment is jointly committed.

These choices are supported by both theoretical characterization and empirical ablations. Appendix B.1–B.3 establishes target-relative local-regret control, confidence-weighted continuation certificates, and mismatch-specific accumulator separability under the cached draft-conditioned distributions. Moreover, Table 2 of the manuscript shows that replacing adaptive evidence requirements with a constant requirement or using uniform evidence weights reduces task quality on both HumanEval+ and GSM8K. These findings support the proposed design choices, although they do not establish a universal probabilistic guarantee that continuation agreement implies the correctness of an earlier mismatch.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comment by Authors

Dear Reviewer FAsX,

We would like to kindly follow up on our previous response. We would greatly appreciate it if you could let us know whether our clarifications and revisions have adequately addressed your concerns. If any questions or concerns remain, we would be happy to provide further explanations.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

Reviewer_UNxmOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes PEND, a concurrent verifier for speculative decoding that handles multiple overlapping draft–target mismatches at once. It tracks each mismatch separately and reuses later cached target predictions as shared evidence to resolve them. Target-relative support determines which mismatches can remain pending and how much evidence they require, while later observations are weighted by confidence. Experiments across two model families and four benchmarks report an average throughput gain of 57.2% over vanilla speculative decoding. Task scores generally remain close to strict verification, with better quality–throughput trade-offs than the deferred-verification baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. Concurrent handling of overlapping mismatches. The paper identifies overlapping pending mismatches as a limitation of deferred verification and tracks each mismatch separately while sharing evidence from the continuation. The First-Mismatch-Only and cross-mismatch-sharing ablations help isolate the benefit of concurrent resolution from the effect of relaxing verification.

  2. Throughput gains across models and tasks. PEND is compared with strict, local-evidence, and continuation-evidence verifiers across two model families and four benchmarks. It reports a 57.2% average throughput gain over vanilla speculative decoding. The matched-quality comparisons and component ablations also support the reported quality–throughput trade-off.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Output fidelity is assessed mainly through task scores. PEND relaxes exact verification, and later target predictions remain conditioned on the original draft prefixes even after an earlier mismatch. The deterministic continuation certificates therefore do not establish agreement with the target model's counterfactual continuation (§3; Appendix B.6). Aggregate task scores remain close to strict verification, but the paper does not directly measure token-level divergence or examine the effects of committing mismatched segments. The evaluation also covers only greedy decoding.

  2. Baseline tuning may be unequal. Appendix C.1 selects PEND's operating points separately for each benchmark using held-out development data, while Appendix C.2 uses task-shared threshold grids for the other methods. This may give PEND more benchmark-specific tuning and affect the quality–throughput comparisons. The paper needs to clarify whether the baselines received comparable tuning, since the main performance claim depends on this trade-off.

Questions for authors
  1. Output divergence. Using the existing paired generations from PEND and vanilla speculative decoding, how often do their output trajectories diverge? For example, can you report the first divergence position or sequence-level similarity, and whether divergence correlates with changes in task quality? This would help show how the continuation certificates relate to the observed effects of relaxed verification.

  2. Baseline calibration. Appendix C.1–C.2 describes benchmark-specific parameters selected on development data for PEND, but task-shared threshold grids for the other verifiers. Were the baselines independently tuned on comparable held-out data? If not, how sensitive are the matched-quality gains to this difference? Existing results or a limited comparison with matched tuning would help answer this.

  3. Relation to other verifiers. How does PEND differ from or complement other speculative verification approaches, including VIA-SD (Xian et al., ICML 2026), MARS (Song et al., Findings of ACL 2026), and FLy (Li et al., ICLR 2026)? In particular, please explain how concurrent mismatch resolution differs from confidence-guided verification routing, margin-based local relaxation, and continuation-based deferred verification. A brief discussion would help clarify the methodological novelty and positioning of the proposed approach.

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer(Part 1 of 4)

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback and insightful suggestions. In response, we provide paired quality and output-divergence analyses to clarify the effects of relaxed verification, and conduct task-specific baseline calibration to strengthen comparison fairness. We further clarify PEND's methodological distinctions, greedy-decoding evaluation scope, and draft-conditioned theoretical guarantees, highlighting its core contribution to concurrent multi-mismatch verification.

1. Response to Output Divergence.

Strict verification may reject plausible draft candidates, limiting draft-token utilization. Prior studies, including Judge Decoding (ICLR 2025), MARS (ACL 2026), and FLy (ICLR 2026), have explored relaxed verification to improve decoding efficiency while maintaining task quality.

PEND follows this line of relaxed verification and further improves draft utilization through concurrent mismatch verification and evidence accumulation, seeking higher throughput while controlling quality degradation. Accordingly, we focus on the task quality–throughput tradeoff rather than exact output equivalence with Vanilla SD.

(1) Paired Quality Changes and Uncertainty Estimation.

To quantify the impact of relaxed verification on task quality, we compare paired Vanilla SD and PEND results on HumanEval+ and GSM8K, estimating 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for quality differences using paired bootstrap resampling.

Table R1. Paired quality and throughput comparison.

DatasetBoth CorrectC→II→CBoth WrongΔ Quality (pp)95% CI (pp)Vanilla SD (tok/s)PEND (tok/s)Gain
HumanEval+1359713−1.22[−6.10, +3.66]23.7039.13+65.1%
GSM8K1244191640−0.23[−1.14, +0.68]26.0640.91+57.0%

Note: C→I denotes a transition from correct under Vanilla SD to incorrect under PEND; I→C denotes the reverse transition.

The results reveal bidirectional sample-level quality changes, with both improvements and degradations. PEND exhibits observed accuracy reductions of 1.22 and 0.23 percentage points on HumanEval+ and GSM8K, respectively, while improving throughput by 65.1% and 57.0% over Vanilla SD.

(2) Output Trajectory Divergence Analysis.

We compare paired PEND and Vanilla SD generations at the token level, measuring first divergence positions and ROUGE-L F1 similarity.

Table R2. Output trajectory divergence.

DatasetDivergence RateMedian First Divergence PositionFirst Divergence RangeMean ROUGE-L F1
HumanEval+100%91–1070.6550
GSM8K100%91–2860.6648

Note: For HumanEval+, the mean ROUGE-L F1 computed on the extracted evaluation code is 0.8068.

These observations indicate that PEND's relaxed acceptance can lead to generation trajectories that differ from those produced by strict verification. This behavior is consistent with the design of relaxed verification; however, changes in output sequences do not necessarily imply degradation in final task quality.

(3) Relationship Between Output Divergence and Task Quality.

To further investigate whether output divergence is associated with changes in task correctness, we compute Spearman correlations between token-level ROUGE-L F1 similarity and correctness flips, conditional degradations, and conditional improvements.

Table R3. Output similarity and quality correlations.

DatasetCorrectness Flipsρ (Flip)ρ (Degradation)ρ (Improvement)
HumanEval+16/164−0.2644−0.2378−0.0818
GSM8K35/1319−0.1379−0.1045−0.2030

Note: A correctness flip occurs when Vanilla SD and PEND produce different correctness outcomes.

The results show a weak negative correlation between output similarity and correctness flips, suggesting that greater divergence is associated with correctness changes, but does not necessarily imply quality degradation. Indeed, only 9.76% of HumanEval+ samples and 2.65% of GSM8K samples exhibit correctness flips, comprising 9 degradations and 7 improvements on HumanEval+, and 19 degradations and 16 improvements on GSM8K. These findings suggest that token-level divergence is not a reliable indicator of task-quality degradation, supporting the evaluation of relaxed verification through task-level outcomes rather than exact output agreement.

Overall, these analyses show that output divergence does not necessarily imply task-quality degradation. PEND achieves substantial throughput gains with limited observed quality reductions on both benchmarks, supporting its effectiveness in balancing task quality and decoding efficiency.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer(Part 2 of 4)

2. Response to Baseline Calibration.

In the original main performance comparisons, we primarily adopt the configurations recommended in the respective baseline papers or official implementations, ensuring fidelity to their established settings and reproducibility. In Appendix C.2, we also conduct controlled parameter sweeps to examine their quality and throughput under different configurations.

To further assess whether benchmark-specific calibration affects the comparison, we conduct benchmark-specific tuning experiments.

The calibration protocol is summarized as follows:

  1. Development sets. For HumanEval+, we use 128 fixed tasks sampled from MBPP+. For GSM8K, we use 256 fixed samples from its training set, excluding the 800 samples previously used for SelfJudge training and threshold-candidate construction.
  2. Search budget. For each of FLy, LinguaSpec, MARS, and SelfJudge, we evaluate 5 coarse-search configurations followed by 5 local-refinement configurations on each task, using the same task-specific development data.
  3. Selection criterion. Configurations are required to incur no more than a 2-percentage-point quality reduction relative to Vanilla SD on the development set. Among qualifying configurations, we prioritize throughput. When a configuration achieves at least 99% of the highest qualifying throughput, we prefer the configuration with higher task quality.
  4. Final evaluation. Final parameters are selected exclusively using development-set results and frozen before evaluation on the complete test sets.

Table R4. Task-specific calibration results.

DatasetMethodCorrectPass@1 / EMMATThroughput (tok/s)Speedup
HumanEval+Vanilla SD144/16487.80%9.1323.701.50×
SelfJudge127/16477.44%15.1940.392.56×
MARS132/16480.49%12.9036.712.33×
FLy142/16486.59%12.0034.102.17×
LinguaSpec140/16485.37%11.6833.342.12×
PEND142/16486.59%13.8539.132.48×
GSM8KVanilla SD1263/131995.75%9.7626.061.60×
SelfJudge1209/131991.66%14.8839.402.41×
MARS1249/131994.69%13.3240.962.51×
FLy1243/131994.24%12.8838.982.39×
LinguaSpec1257/131995.30%12.4437.602.30×
PEND1260/131995.53%13.1940.912.51×

The results in Table R4 support the following statements:

  1. Higher throughput while maintaining task quality on HumanEval+. PEND achieves 86.59% Pass@1 and 39.13 tok/s, delivering 14.8% higher throughput than the tuned FLy at identical task quality. Although SelfJudge achieves slightly higher throughput, it incurs substantially greater quality degradation. These results indicate that PEND improves decoding efficiency without relying on substantial task-quality degradation, even when competing methods are independently calibrated.

  2. Stronger quality preservation at competitive throughput on GSM8K. PEND achieves 95.53% EM and 40.91 tok/s, maintaining nearly identical throughput to the tuned MARS while improving EM by 0.84 percentage points. It also achieves higher quality and throughput than FLy and LinguaSpec. These results suggest that PEND can sustain high decoding throughput while better preserving task quality, rather than obtaining efficiency gains primarily through more permissive verification.

  3. Robustness to task-specific baseline calibration. Across both benchmarks, PEND remains competitive after each baseline is independently tuned under the same search budget and quality-constrained selection protocol. Importantly, its favorable quality–throughput performance persists beyond comparisons against recommended baseline configurations, indicating that the observed advantages are not solely attributable to differences in baseline parameterization.

Overall, these results strengthen the evidence that PEND's concurrent multi-mismatch verification provides an effective mechanism for improving draft utilization while controlling task-quality degradation, with its benefits remaining evident under task-specific baseline calibration.

We have incorporated the task-specific calibration protocol and corresponding results into Appendix C.2 (Table 6) of the revised manuscript, with all additions highlighted in blue for ease of reference.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer(Part 3 of 4)

3. Response to Relation to Other Verifiers.

Existing approaches such as VIA-SD, MARS, and FLy primarily investigate how to route verification, when to relax local acceptance conditions, or how to use subsequent predictions to validate an individual mismatch. In contrast, PEND addresses the overlapping verification decisions arising from multiple mismatches, allowing each mismatch to maintain an independent verification state while reusing shared target-model evidence and coordinating their final resolution.

The key distinctions are as follows:

  1. VIA-SD (ICML 2026): Confidence-Guided Verification Routing.

    VIA-SD routes candidate tokens among direct acceptance, lightweight verification, and full target-model verification according to their verification requirements, thereby reducing verification costs. In contrast, PEND does not introduce additional verifier tiers. Instead, it reuses information cached from a single target-model verification pass to concurrently process multiple pending mismatches. Thus, VIA-SD primarily optimizes verification-resource allocation, whereas PEND focuses on resolving multiple mismatch decisions using existing target-model evidence. These approaches address different, potentially complementary optimization dimensions.

  2. MARS (Findings of ACL 2026): Margin-Based Local Relaxation.

    MARS uses the target model's Top-2 logit margin to estimate local decision stability and relaxes acceptance of Top-2 draft candidates when the margin is sufficiently small. In contrast, PEND combines local target-model support with subsequent evidence accumulation. A mismatch is first assessed according to the relative target-model support for its draft token and must then satisfy its evidence-accumulation requirement. Unlike a purely local acceptance decision, PEND incorporates both local support and subsequent evidence, with independent verification conditions for different mismatches.

  3. FLy (ICLR 2026): Continuation-Based Deferred Verification.

    FLy uses entropy gating to identify mismatches eligible for deferred verification and requires no additional mismatch to occur within a fixed subsequent window; otherwise, the earlier candidate is rejected. PEND also leverages subsequent evidence, but allows newly encountered mismatches to enter independent pending states rather than treating them as automatic failures of previous deferred decisions.

    Specifically, PEND maintains a separate evidence-accumulation state for each pending mismatch, determines its evidence requirement according to target-model support, and updates it using confidence-weighted subsequent cached predictions. A draft segment is committed jointly only when the relevant pending mismatches satisfy their respective completion conditions. Therefore, PEND extends deferred verification from an individual mismatch to independent and concurrent resolution of multiple overlapping mismatches.

In summary, PEND's core contribution is not the isolated use of local confidence or subsequent verification evidence, but a concurrent multi-mismatch decision mechanism built upon shared cached target-model evidence. Compared with verification routing, local relaxation, and conventional deferred verification, PEND enables independent evidence accumulation and coordinated commitment for multiple simultaneously pending mismatches without additional target-model forward passes.

We have refined the taxonomy of relaxed verification and clarified PEND's methodological distinctions from existing approaches in Section 2 (Related Work) of the revised manuscript, with all revisions highlighted in blue for ease of reference.

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to all reviewers

We sincerely thank all reviewers for their careful evaluations and constructive feedback. Their comments have helped us clarify PEND's methodological contributions, strengthen the experimental evaluation, and improve the rigor and presentation of the paper. In response, we conducted additional experiments and analyses, provided detailed clarifications, and revised the manuscript accordingly.

1. Additional Experiments, Analyses, and Clarifications

In response to the reviewers' feedback, we conduct additional experiments and analyses to further substantiate PEND's core contribution: efficient concurrent resolution of multiple draft–target mismatches using cached predictions from a single target-model verification pass. These investigations provide additional evidence of the effectiveness of concurrent mismatch handling, its impact on task quality and decoding efficiency, and its scalability to larger batch sizes. We also clarify PEND's methodological distinctions, theoretical scope, and evaluation protocol, as summarized below.

  1. Fairness of Baseline Calibration. We conduct task-specific calibration of all relaxed-verification baselines on HumanEval+ and GSM8K under a matched 10-configuration search budget, using held-out development data and a unified quality-constrained selection protocol. The results confirm that PEND maintains competitive quality–throughput performance after baseline recalibration.
  2. Output Divergence and Quality Uncertainty. We provide paired correctness changes, 95% confidence intervals, token-level output divergence statistics, and correlations between output similarity and task-quality changes. These analyses further characterize the effects of relaxed verification on generation quality.
  3. Independent Contribution of Concurrent Verification. We conduct concurrency-capacity ablations (C1, C2, and Full PEND) and analyze performance across different numbers of simultaneously pending mismatches. These results further substantiate the independent contribution of concurrent mismatch handling to draft utilization and decoding efficiency.
  4. Batch-Size Scalability. We extend the evaluation to batch sizes of 2, 4, 8, and 16, examining task-quality consistency, throughput gains, and verification-logic overhead. The results demonstrate that PEND maintains its throughput advantage over Vanilla SD with limited verification overhead under batched inference.
  5. Methodological Distinctions and Theoretical Scope. We clarify PEND's differences from VIA-SD, MARS, and FLy, explain the motivation for its verification rules, and discuss the scope of its draft-conditioned theoretical guarantees. We also clarify the rationale for evaluating PEND under greedy decoding.

2. Revisions to the Manuscript

We have incorporated the following improvements into the updated manuscript, with all revisions highlighted in blue for ease of reference:

  1. Related Work (Section 2). Refined the taxonomy of relaxed verification and clarified PEND's distinction from local-evidence and continuation-evidence methods, including VIA-SD.
  2. Concurrency-Capacity Ablation (Section 5.4, Table 3). Added controlled comparisons of C1, C2, and Full PEND to quantify the contribution of concurrent mismatch handling to task quality, draft utilization, and decoding efficiency.
  3. Batch-Size Scalability (Section 5.5, Table 4; Appendix C.6). Added experiments with batch sizes of 2, 4, 8, and 16, including throughput comparisons, task-quality consistency, and verification-logic overhead measurements.
  4. Task-Specific Baseline Calibration (Appendix C.2, Table 6). Added the unified calibration protocol and corresponding evaluation results to strengthen the fairness of comparisons against competing relaxed verifiers.
  5. Conclusion (Section 6). Updated the conclusions to reflect the additional evidence on concurrent verification and batch-size scalability.

Please refer to our detailed responses under each review for the complete experimental results and clarifications. We sincerely appreciate the reviewers' feedback and welcome any further questions or suggestions.

We sincerely thank the Area Chair for overseeing the review process and all reviewers for their thoughtful and constructive feedback.

Throughout the rebuttal process, we have carefully addressed the reviewers' comments with detailed explanations, additional experimental evaluations, and further analyses where appropriate. All corresponding revisions have been incorporated into the updated manuscript, with changes highlighted in blue for ease of reference.

Thank you again for your time and consideration.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.