- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces PCE as a new directional measure for comparing persistence diagrams. It constructs an induced probability distribution using kernel-based similarity and persistence weighting, derives stability properties, and evaluates the measure on synthetic topological examples.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a potentially useful problem of comparing persistence diagrams with different numbers of features. The proposed construction is mathematically explicit, and the use of PCE as a differentiable topology-related loss is potentially interesting.
Critical weaknesses
My main hesitation is limited novelty and questionable conceptual foundation.
-
The proposed PCE essentially reduces to a persistence-weighted squared difference between kernel-smoothed diagram representations. The KL-divergence identity and stability results largely follow from the chosen construction and standard Lipschitz arguments, rather than establishing a fundamentally new information-theoretic principle.
-
The induced probability is constructed by reweighting the reference distribution rather than directly comparing the two persistence-based distributions. Its interpretation as cross entropy is therefore somewhat artificial. More seriously, PCE can be zero for distinct persistence diagrams, so it does not necessarily capture meaningful topological discrepancies.
-
Also, the paper seems to make unjustified causal interpretation. The asymmetry of PCE does not imply causal directionality. Differences between its forward and reverse values can arise solely from persistence magnitudes or diagram structure, without any causal relationship. The paper provides no theoretical identification argument connecting this asymmetry to causality.
-
Most theoretical properties characterize the behavior of the specifically engineered measure rather than establish its superiority over existing diagram distances, kernels, or other topological discrepancies.
Questions for authors
Please address my concerns about both the conceptual justification and methodological contribution as listed in the weakness section.
4 comments
- Also, the paper seems to make unjustified causal interpretation. The asymmetry of PCE does not imply causal directionality. Differences between its forward and reverse values can arise solely from persistence magnitudes or diagram structure, without any causal relationship. The paper provides no theoretical identification argument connecting this asymmetry to causality.
Our motivation follows an established idea in causal inference for coupled deterministic dynamical systems. The response can retain information about the driver, allowing driver states to be reconstructed from response observations. CCM examines this through cross-map reconstruction (Science, 2012), while TC examines the local expansion of mappings between reconstructed state spaces (Physical Review Letters, 2017).
Following the persistent-homology benchmark of Bando et al. (JSIAM Letters, 2022), we investigate this idea through persistence diagrams. In the spring–mass equations, the driver can be recovered from the response and its second derivative. If the response diagram retains geometric structure from the driver, we expect it to explain the driver’s diagram better than the reverse. This is the hypothesis tested in Section 5.2, and we will make its motivation and scope explicit.
- Most theoretical properties characterize the behavior of the specifically engineered measure rather than establish its superiority over existing diagram distances, kernels, or other topological discrepancies.
Our core contribution is the formulation of persistent cross entropy and the proof of its mathematical properties. We establish valid induced probabilities, recovery of persistent entropy under self-comparison, and stability under explicit assumptions. These results give the new concept a rigorous theoretical foundation. Symmetric diagram distances address a different comparison objective. Our experiments are designed to demonstrate the use of PCE in applications requiring ordered comparisons, rather than to establish general superiority over symmetric methods.
Follow-up on zero conditions: Appendix C
We have added Appendix C to clarify the zero conditions. It includes an explicit example where one-directional PCE is zero for distinct diagrams. Proposition 4 further proves that, for nonempty finite diagrams, Gaussian similarity with fixed positive bandwidths, and for every , $ \Delta H_X^Y=\Delta H_Y^X=0 \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad D_X=D_Y, $ including multiplicities. The possibility of a zero value in one direction therefore does not invalidate the two-direction comparison.
The authors' clarifications and the additional result on two-direction separation have addressed some of my conceptual concerns. I thank for that. However, I still remain unconvinced that the proposed construction offers sufficient methodological novelty or demonstrated benefit over existing approaches, which are my main concerns, setting aside all the technical details. The causal interpretation also remains a benchmark-specific hypothesis, which further limits the paper’s persuasiveness.
Response to Reviewer jJg4
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first rigorous formulation of persistent cross entropy (PCE). Our main contribution is to extend persistent entropy to an ordered comparison between persistence diagrams through the induced-probability construction and establish its mathematical properties. We address your questions and concerns below.
Our objective is to formulate a cross-entropy extension of persistent entropy. Although the entropy excess can be written as a persistence-weighted squared difference, this does not make it equivalent to the distance used in persistence-weighted kernel methods.
For example, let X={(0,1)} and Ya={(0,1),(a,1)} for a>0, where each pair gives birth time and lifetime. With fixed Gaussian bandwidths and lifetime weights, the common point cancels in the kernel distance. The remaining point has the same lifetime wherever it is placed, so this distance is unchanged as a varies. PCE instead evaluates the response difference at the point in X. A nearby additional point contributes more to that response and gives a larger PCE, while moving it farther away reduces PCE. Thus, even with X fixed, the kernel distance alone does not determine PCE.
The KL identity follows directly from our induced-probability construction. Proposition 3 also shows why bounded weights are required for our diagram-independent stability bounds. With unbounded weights, the unexplained mass can remain strictly positive even as the 1-Wasserstein distance tends to zero.
The two persistence-based distributions are defined on different event spaces, DX and DY. Applying cross entropy therefore requires an additional construction that places the probabilities on a common event space. This is precisely the role of the induced probability. We use information from DY to construct pXY on DX∪{∂}, and extend pX to the same space by setting pX(∂)=0. We then apply the standard definition of cross entropy to these two probability distributions. The reweighting addresses the event-space mismatch and recovers standard persistent entropy when a diagram is compared with itself.
For clarity, we address the zero condition of the entropy excess. It can indeed vanish for distinct persistence diagrams. However, failure to distinguish every pair of diagrams does not by itself make a topological summary uninformative. Persistent entropy, Betti curves, and persistence silhouettes can also agree for distinct diagrams, giving zero differences between their summaries. Our objective is to extend persistent entropy to an ordered comparison, and we explicitly characterize what zero entropy excess means. As stated in Propositions 1(ii) and 2, ΔHXY=0 holds exactly when the weighted kernel responses of the two diagrams agree at every point of DX, equivalently when pXY=pX. Thus, zero expresses a precisely defined agreement under the chosen comparison. The reverse comparison evaluates the corresponding agreement on DY.