acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Piecing It Together: Harmonizing Participant-Grounded Memory in Multi-Party Dialogues

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

As large language model (LLM) agents increasingly participate in large-scale collaborative projects, memory mechanisms for multi-party dialogues have emerged as a new challenge. However, existing works primarily rely on semantic-based retrieval from a two-party tradition, struggling to piece together a holistic view across groups and time. To address this challenge, we propose Pit from a participant-grounded perspective, which reframes multi-party memory retrieval as completing a query-specific puzzle by assembling scattered pieces. Specifically, we first construct an event–participant bipartite graph to derive participant-grounded event representations, which are further consolidated into coherent memory pieces. A query-specific router then explores their underlying dependencies and harmonizes them together into a coherent memory view. Extensive experiments on EverMemBench demonstrate consistent improvements across different LLMs, outperforming the strongest baselines by 6.71%–19.91%. Further analyses show that participant grounding generally improves event representations and retrieval reliability. The code can be available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/PIT-E7F1https://anonymous.4open.science/r/PIT-E7F1.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Agent, memory, LLM, language model

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_MHNBOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

PIT addresses memory retrieval in multi-party conversations through participant-grounded event representations, contextual event consolidation, and LLM-gated multi-hop retrieval. The motivation is compelling, yet substantial discrepancies between the proposed mechanism, implementation, and experimental interpretation weaken the main claims.

Critical strengths

The problem is practically relevant, and using participants to connect fragmented evidence is well motivated. Evaluation across three backbones and multiple task categories is useful. Linking retrieved events to source facts also provides a reasonable foundation for evidence-grounded generation.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The default implementation does not realize the claimed cross-group connectivity. Participant nodes are instantiated separately within each conversation group, and event-neighbor retrieval explicitly enforces same_group_only=True. A minimal construction test confirms that the same participant appearing in two groups produces disconnected nodes. Retrieving seeds from multiple groups does not establish the claimed cross-group graph propagation.

  2. The baseline comparison is confounded. PIT uses Qwen3-Embedding-0.6B, whereas all baselines use All-MiniLM-L6-v2 (Appendix C.1). Evidence budgets and LLM inference costs are also not controlled. This undermines the empirical foundation of the method.

  3. The ablations do not isolate component contributions. Appendix D describes “w/o Event Consolidation” as removing LLM gating and randomly selecting neighbors, while “w/o Multi-Hop Router” removes consolidation but retains multi-hop retrieval. These descriptions do not match the variant names, undermining component contribution. Appendix E.1 additionally acknowledges that its representation analysis compares separately generated pipelines rather than isolating propagation with fixed initial embeddings.

Questions for authors
  1. How does PIT achieve cross-group propagation when participant nodes are group-specific and retrieval enforces same_group_only=True? Does the experimental implementation differ from the released code?

  2. Can you compare PIT and the baselines using the same embedding model and matched evidence/token budgets, while reporting LLM inference costs, to isolate architectural gains?

  3. Can you clarify the apparent mismatch between the ablation names and removed components in Appendix D, and provide controlled ablations that vary one component at a time while keeping extracted events and initial embeddings fixed?

Reviewer_BuNXOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This work investigates memory for multi-party dialogues, where the evidence for a question is scattered across different participants, groups, and points in time. To address it, the authors proposed PIT, which extracts events and facts from the dialogue stream, learns participant-grounded event representations by propagating over an event–participant graph, consolidates neighbouring events into compact memory pieces, and answers by routing from query-relevant seed events through those pieces with an LLM-gated multi-hop expansion. Different from existing work that focuses on similarity-based retrieval, which cannot tell apart topically similar events involving different participants, PIT grounds retrieval in who did what and assembles the answer context as a query-specific puzzle. Experimental results verify its effectiveness and superiority: on EverMemBench (2,400 multi-party questions), PIT achieves the best average accuracy on all three backbones — 48.96 vs. 43.31 for the strongest baseline on GPT-4.1-mini, 53.66 vs. 50.73 on Qwen-3.5-Flash, and 57.75 vs. 48.16 on GLM-4.

Critical strengths
  • Best overall average on every backbone tested, against five memory systems and Full Context: 48.96 vs. 43.31 (A-Mem) on GPT-4.1-mini, 53.66 vs. 50.73 (MemoBase) on Qwen-3.5-Flash, and 57.75 vs. 48.16 (MemOS) on GLM-4, also beating Full Context where it runs (Table 2).
  • Ablation Study is solid and thorough
  • The mechanism analyses are consistent across backbones. Participant grounding reduces gold-evidence dispersion substantially on all three (e.g., 0.8689 → 0.6523 on GPT-4.1-mini) with a win rate above 99.5% of queries, and gold-evidence coverage grows with routing depth (Table 4).
Critical weaknesses
  • The ablation definitions in Appendix D appear interchanged, which undermines the central ablation conclusion. "W/o Event Consolidation" is defined as removing the LLM-based gate — but the gate belongs to the router, while consolidation is clustering with no LLM gate — and "w/o Multi-Hop Router" is defined as removing consolidation. The swap is corroborated numerically: the α = 0 rows match the "w/o Multi-Hop Router" rows exactly on every subtask. So the conclusion that consolidation is the central component may attribute the largest drop to the wrong component (Appendix D; Tables 7–9, 13–15).
  • Table 2 contains a duplicated baseline row. The GLM-4 REMem row is numerically identical to the Qwen-3.5-Flash REMem row on all nine subtasks and the average (38.62), with only the delta to PIT differing. Two different backbones cannot plausibly produce identical scores on every subtask, so at least one row is wrong (Table 2).
  • The headline improvement range does not follow from Table 2. The claimed 6.71%–19.91% over the strongest baselines reproduces at the upper bound (GLM-4), but on Qwen-3.5-Flash the gain over MemoBase is +2.93 points, ≈5.8% relative — below the claimed 6.71% minimum under any natural reading of "strongest baseline."
  • The contradiction-rate result contradicts its own text claim. The text says participant grounding reduces cross-participant conflicts, yet CR∗ increases with grounding on all three backbones (e.g., 0.29% → 0.42% on GPT-4.1-mini); and under the appendix definition CR∗ = 1 − CR, the tabulated sub-1% values are impossible, so the column appears to report CR itself — meaning contradictions rise, not fall (Table 5).
  • The baseline comparison is confounded by the embedding model. All baselines use All-MiniLM-L6-v2 embeddings, whereas PIT uses Qwen3-Embedding-0.6B, a substantially newer and stronger embedder. Part of PIT's margin may come from the embedder rather than participant grounding, consolidation, or routing, and no same-embedder control is reported.
Questions for authors
  • How exactly is the "6.71%–19.91%" improvement range computed? From Table 2, the Qwen-3.5-Flash gain over the strongest baseline (MemoBase, 50.73 → 53.66) is ≈5.8% relative — which baseline and which numbers yield 6.71%?
  • Is the GLM-4 REMem row in Table 2 a copy of the Qwen-3.5-Flash row? All nine subtask scores and the average (38.62) match exactly; please provide the correct GLM-4 REMem numbers.
  • Why are the participant-free retrieval results for GPT-4.1-mini and Qwen-3.5-Flash numerically identical — all of Table 5's participant-free metrics and the coverage at all five hops — while the GLM-4 participant-free results differ? Is the participant-free pipeline shared across backbones, and if event extraction is shared, why do the participant-grounded rows then differ?
Reviewer_J9RoOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies agent memory for multi-party dialogue. The authors observe that existing memory systems retrieve historical interactions by semantic relevance, inherited from a two-party tradition, and that this assumption is poorly suited to multi-party settings where relevant information is highly scattered: different participants engage across multiple groups, and the same topic recurs at different points in time. Reconstructing the complete context for a query therefore requires harmonizing fragmented pieces, with participants serving as anchors for tracing relevant evidence. The proposed method, PIT, reframes multi-party memory retrieval as completing a query-specific puzzle by assembling scattered pieces. It first constructs an event–participant bipartite graph to derive participant-grounded event representations, consolidates these into coherent memory pieces, and then applies a query-specific router that explores their dependencies and harmonizes them into a single memory view. Experiments are conducted on EverMemBench, described as the only publicly available and formally published benchmark for agent memory in this setting, across three backbone LLMs. The authors report consistent improvements over the strongest baselines, and further analyses arguing that participant grounding improves event representations and retrieval reliability.

Critical strengths
  1. The setting is a reasonable one to target. Multi-party dialogue differs from the two-party case in ways that plausibly break similarity-based retrieval, and the paper identifies this gap clearly.
  2. Using participants as the organizing anchor is a sensible idea. When two events are described in nearly identical language and differ mainly in who was involved, participant information is the natural signal for telling them apart, and the qualitative example in Figure 5 illustrates this well.
  3. The paper reports several results that do not favor its method, including the style-understanding subtask, the mixed retrieval outcomes in Table 5, and the caveat in Appendix E.1 that the representation comparison is system-level rather than a controlled ablation.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The experimental section contains inconsistencies that prevent it from being read as written, one of which inverts a central conclusion. In Appendix D, the descriptions of two ablations appear to be swapped: the entry labeled “w/o Event Consolidation” describes removing the LLM gate and selecting neighbors randomly, which is the router, while the entry labeled “w/o Multi-Hop Router” describes removing consolidation and retrieving the top-k most similar events directly. Section 4.3 draws its main conclusion from these rows, namely that event consolidation is the dominant component. If the labels are swapped, that conclusion reverses and the dominant component becomes the LLM gate rather than the consolidation mechanism the paper’s framing rests on.
  2. The headline gains are not explained by the paper’s own retrieval evidence, and the most likely alternative explanation is untested. Table 5 shows that participant grounding improves Any Hit@5 by 0.5 to 1.3 points and MRR by a few thousandths, with source precision slightly worse for GLM-4 and support rate worse for Qwen-3.5-Flash. The authors describe these correctly as small and model-dependent. But the end-task improvements in Table 2 are 6 to 20 percent, and nothing bridges that gap.
  3. The method cannot be reproduced, and the main configuration does not appear in the paper’s own sensitivity analysis. The number of LightGCN propagation layers is never given, although it governs the strength of the mechanism the paper is named for, and whether LightGCN is trained or used as fixed propagation is never stated. The consolidation coefficient α\alpha and maximum routing depth HH have no stated defaults.
Questions for authors
  1. Are the descriptions of “w/o Event Consolidation” and “w/o Multi-Hop Router” in Appendix D swapped? If so, Section 4.3’s conclusion about which component dominates reverses and should be restated. Please also report at least three runs on one backbone with means and standard deviations, since several ablation differences are below one point and no variance is reported anywhere in the paper.
  2. Please report the number of evidence tokens supplied to the answering LLM per query for PIT and each baseline, and add a budget-matched comparison. As configured, baselines are capped at ten or twenty items or 3K tokens while PIT has no cap. A gain that survives matching would substantiate the retrieval claim; a gain that shrinks would indicate that evidence volume, not participant grounding, drives Table 2, which is the reading most consistent with the small deltas in Table 5.
  3. Please state the default values of α\alpha, the maximum routing depth, and the number of LightGCN propagation layers, clarify whether LightGCN is trained or used as a fixed operator, and explain why the PIT row in Table 6 matches no swept configuration. Please also report sensitivity to the number of propagation layers.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.