acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Unpacking Evolving Dynamics Through The Representation Pathway

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Neural networks transform representations along computational pathways, via stacked layers or iterative processes such as diffusion sampling. How these representations evolve and how their evolution relates to model behavior, provides a complementary perspective to analyzing final representations alone. To this end, we introduce Representation Pathway Consistency (REPAC), an image-level analytical metric that quantifies how well relational structure among an image's patch tokens is preserved between successive pathway states and aggregates these local consistencies across the pathway. Using REPAC, we find that higher pathway consistency is generally associated with better performance across discriminative and generative tasks. In generative models, generated images with more consistent pathways tend to lie closer to class-conditional prototypes in representation space, providing a geometric perspective on this association. Moreover, REPAC computed from an initial segment of a generative pathway is predictive of final sample quality. Leveraging this signal, we develop a plug-and-play early-selection strategy that ranks partially generated candidates using REPAC and continues only the highest-ranked ones to completion. This reduces sampling cost while improving the quality of retained samples, without external reward signals or additional training. Together, these findings reveal regularities in representation pathway dynamics and their relationship to downstream behavior, while demonstrating the utility of pathway consistency for quality-aware and efficient selective generation.

Primary area:
unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords:
Visual Representation Learning, Representation Dynamics, Diffusion models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_a9nsOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The author measure relational geometry of the representation across different layer, and diffusion steps for image generative model. In particular, for latent state at each layer, the author construct the gram matrix and measure the cosine similarity between two layer’s gram matrix, and sum over across all layer and diffusion steps.

Critical strengths

The problem the author attempts to study is important: understand how representation of latent state evolve in the network or diffusion process. The result of high consistency leads to generation result with high inception score is interesting, but more analysis is needed, see weakness.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The writing is terrible. I felt like the whole piece is an AI generated report. Starting from the abstract, the author kept mentioning technical terms that doesn’t appear to be in any other literature, like “pathway” or “pathway consistency.” This is really tiring. Because of this, I recommend rejection of the paper. I think the author should withdraw this paper and rewrite the paper. And I do not think the rebuttal will change my decision.
  2. High pathway consistency result in higher inception score is an interesting phenomena. However, I don’t think this implies higher generation quality claimed by the author. High inception score just means the image generated by model can be more easily classified as a particular class, and this definition is consistent with the author’s visualization: high consistency pathway result in an imagenet like bird, while low consistency result in a bird with complicated background. Why is complicated background is a bad thing? I felt high inception score is kinda a bad thing because it reduce generation diversity. I think the author should frame their result as challenging the inception score as a generation quality metric, not that they improve the generation performance.
  3. More mechanistic analysis of low pathway consistency example is necesssary. What happened when the model generate a low pathway consistency? It means the representation keeps changing in the network, I think that actually means the network put in more effort to generate/refine that example, so what happened in the network, is it that the network start with proposal, and then refuse it in later layer, like the network start with parrot, and background of ocean, then change the ocean to sky because its not consistent with parrot. I think the low pathway consistency will be the interesting part for analyssi.
Questions for authors

N/A

Reviewer_oDc9OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Representation Pathway Consistency (REPAC), a training-free image quality assessment using generation trajectories. The proposed image quality metric (i.e., REPAC) aligns and normalizes spatial features, compares their Gram matrices between adjacent layers or sampling steps, and aggregates these similarities along the pathway. Experiments demonstrates correlations with classification accuracy, class-conditional DiT generation, and proximity to generated class prototypes. For text-to-image generation, REPAC ranks partial SD3.5-M/L trajectories and completes four of 20 candidates.

Critical strengths
  • REPAC requires no labels, trained evaluator, or external reference set at scoring time. The same formulation supports both layer-wise and temporal analysis.

  • Experiments on pretrained diffusion models demonstrate REPAC's applicability across representative image-generation tasks (e.g., class-conditional and text-to-image generation) without additional training. For example, REPAC (LD) improves overall DPG-Bench scores from 84.30 to 85.60 on SD3.5-M when selection occurs after 20% of sampling.

Critical weaknesses
  • [W1] Weak Novelty. TRACE [A] already analyzes changes between consecutive self-attention maps and uses peak KL divergence to locate instance-aware states. Although its downstream task is segmentation and REPAC uses a different metric, the motivation for interpreting the evolution of internal relations overlaps. This connection is not discussed, leaving it unclear whether the contribution extends beyond application novelty. Equations 3/4/5 also combine familiar Gram representations, normalized alignment, and pathway averaging. Please explain what new insight the proposed metric provides beyond these components and the existing observation, and compare alternative temporal-change signals (e.g., KL) on matched pathways. Changing the metric alone does not demonstrate a conceptual advance in understanding diffusion dynamics.

  • [W2] Limited Comparisons for Early Quality Assessment. InitNO [B] evaluates initial noise using attention scores, Self-Cross [C] combines self-/cross-attention to reduce subject mixing, and ISAC [D] performs training-free dynamics-aware latent selection using internal attention signals (i.e., without an external reward model). These prompt-aware signals are relevant because REPAC measures structural consistency without explicitly evaluating prompt-image alignment. Therefore, a meaningful comparison requires the same candidates and sampling steps available at assessment, with adaptations from guidance to ranking and from ISAC's full-trajectory selection clearly described. Paired uncertainty and within-prompt ranking reliability, alongside counting/attribute-binding tests beyond DPG-Bench, are needed to assess the stability of REPAC's selection gains. Probe-Select (L136) and early hallucination detectors [E] provide further comparisons.

  • [W3] Insufficient Justification of the Quality Signal. High consistency can also arise from uninformative features, e.g., identical features at every spatial location yield perfect alignment in Equations 3/4. Please explain why REPAC reflects useful structure rather than such stable patterns, and test centered/off-diagonal alternatives and sensitivity to spatial resampling. Figure 5's tightly clustered early scores also require evidence that small differences remain informative under these choices. Figure 7 measures similarity to high-CFG prototypes from the same generator in Inception-v3 space, which also underlies IS. This supports class typicality but does not independently demonstrate fidelity or diversity. Please evaluate quality and diversity separately, including valid compositions with clutter, occlusion, or multiple instances.

  • [W4] Unclear Computational Cost and Scalability. Please report total latency, peak memory, and quality at a matched compute budget. Explicitly constructed Gram matrices require memory that grows quadratically with token count, so report the scoring resolution and any pooling or memory-saving implementation. Section 3.2 already aligns different token grids, and the representation analysis includes SDXL-Turbo (i.e., using the U-Net architecture). However, early selection is tested only on SD3.5-M/L. This application should therefore be evaluated on a U-Net and a different transformer design (e.g., FLUX/Qwen-Image), with feature extraction, alignment, and scoring costs included.

References:

[A] TRACE: Your Diffusion Model is Secretly an Instance Edge Detector, ICLR 2026.

[B] InitNO: Boosting Text-to-Image Diffusion Models via Initial Noise Optimization, CVPR 2024.

[C] Self-Cross Diffusion Guidance for Text-to-Image Synthesis of Similar Subjects, CVPR 2025.

[D] ISAC: Training-Free Instance-to-Semantic Attention Control for Multi-Instance Generation, ECCV 2026.

[E] Hallucination Early Detection in Diffusion Models, IJCV 2026.

Questions for authors

Please refer to the Critical Weaknesses section for details.

  • Q1. [W1] What new insight does REPAC offer beyond exploiting diffusion dynamics in TRACE [A]? How does REPAC compare quantitatively against alternative temporal-change signals (e.g., KL divergence) on matched pathways?

  • Q2. [W2] When evaluated with identical candidates and early timesteps, how does REPAC perform against attention-based selection and guidance baselines (InitNO [B], Self-Cross [C], ISAC [D], Probe-Select, and early hallucination detectors [E])? Given the lack of explicit image-text (i.e., image-prompt) alignment, how stable is its ranking on most generation tasks (e.g., counting and attribute-binding)?

  • Q3. [W3] Since uninformative identical spatial features trivially achieve perfect alignment in Eqs. 3/4, how does REPAC perform with centered/off-diagonal formulations and spatial resampling? Furthermore, instead of Inception-v3 prototype typicality in Fig. 7, can the authors report decoupled quality and diversity metrics on complex scenes (e.g., clutter, occlusion, multi-instance)?

  • Q4. [W4] What are the total latency, peak memory, and scoring image/latent resolution (including any pooling/memory-saving techniques) for the quadratic Gram matrices? Under a matched compute budget, can the early selection framework be evaluated on a U-Net backbone (e.g., SDXL-Turbo) and an alternative transformer (e.g., FLUX or Qwen-Image)?

Reviewer_w6J2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces RePaC (Representation Pathway Consistency), which is a metric that measures per-image consistency by examining how relational structure between image's patch token is preserved during successive states. The paper correlates with pathway consistency with performance across both discriminative and generative tasks. For generative models, the paper also shows that higher RePaC result in images that lie closer to class-conditional prototypes and that it can be used in the initial generative pathway to predict final sample quality and retain samples with higher-likelihood of better quality.

RePaC is a training-free method that leverages token-level Gram matrix at each state, compare the matrices, and aggregate local transitions along the pathway to capture relational consistency.

  • pathway = collection of saptial tokens for one sample, look across network depth and diffusion sampling time
  • look at pathway while keeping sampling time constant + looking only at layer, or layer constant while looking across sampling time
Critical strengths
  • RePaC is a simple and elegant training-free, reference-free metric that uses patch-level consistency to score individual images. The results show convincing relationships with classification performance, Inception Score and class-prototype similarity, and through qualitative results it also suggests that the metric is able to identify differences between canonical and less conventional samples.
  • The paper connects the motivation, empirical analysis, and downstream application well. The analysis of representation dynamics motivates the metric, experiments across multiple backbones show correlations to classification and generation, and early candidate selection provides a natural application. This gives the work breadth with the goal of showing practical value beyond the analysis
Critical weaknesses
  • The improvement over ASD is not very convincing, with the gap being < 1% DPG-Bench metric at the early assessment checkpoints, and improvement is not consistent at later checkpoints for SD3.5-Large against other baselines. There are no reported uncertainty estimates or boostraped/repeat run statistics, so it is difficult to determine whether these gains are statistically significant.
  • Although the metric is well motivated, its main components are not sufficiently isolated experimentally. The appendix ablates weighting schemes and feature depth, but does not compare Gram-matrix consistency against direct feature similarity (after standardizing dimensionality) or whether averaging consistency across all observed sampling steps improves selection compared with measuring consistency only between the two most recent steps, which are potentially simpler alternatives
Questions for authors

Clarifications:

  • Why does assessing candidates later sometimes reduce final DPG-Bench performance, particularly for SD3.5-Large, despite having access to more trajectory information? Are these differences statistically significant?
  • What guided the selection of the four discriminative encoders? DINOv2, DINOv3, and DistillDIFT are related (all DINO-family or DINO-initialized) and all four encoders are 12-block ViT-Bs.

Additional experiments:

  • Can you report uncertainty estimates for the classification trends and early-selection results, particularly Figures 4 and 6 and Table 1? For the comparison against ASD, paired confidence intervals across prompts and results across independent candidate-generation seeds would help establish whether the gains are reliable.
  • Can you compare against direct patch-feature cosine similarity? You can do this across sampling steps at a fixed block, where feature dimensions already match, or across blocks after standardizing dimensionality as you already have with the Gram matrix? Can you also compare against using only the latest adjacent Gram-matrix comparison? Keeping the candidates, assessment points, feature block, and weighting otherwise fixed would help ablate the benefit of the proposed design.
  • Does the association hold for a more distinct encoder objective, such as CLIP, or for classification data beyond ImageNet-1K? It would help determine how broadly the findings generalize beyond the current encoder families and limited classification benchmark.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.