- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Qwen-Image-Omni with a pretrained VLM and Diffusion Transformer (DiT) through structured skill calls and a shared history for complex visual programming without external reasoner.
A multi-turn adaptation method is introduced to construct dependency-preserving histories from single-turn skills and trains visual execution and prompt expansion in 2 stages.
Qwen-Image-Omni achieves strong performance on public benchmarks.
Critical strengths
1, The idea of supporting complex visual programs by combining shared visual history, structured natural-language calls, and two-stage adaptation is interesting and makes sense.
2, Qwen-Image-Omni demonstrates strong performance on 4 benchmarks such as UEval, RISEBench, GenEval 2, and GEdit-Bench, outperforming open unified multimodal baselines.
3, Ablation studies are conducted to support the multi-turn capability of Qwen-Image-Omni on ComplexEval by task family.
Critical weaknesses
1, Qwen-Image-Omni seems only for visual-language multi-turn understanding and generation. For Qwen-Image-Omni, I expect it will also support multimodality beyond image and text.
2, Lack the experimental results for inference efficiency comparison. For example, in Table 1, Qwen-Image-Omni is showing performance improvement over baselines such as BAGEL/Emu3.5. It is also good to show latency comparison.
3, Qwen-Image-Omni is doing better than Gemini-2.5-Flash-Image on reasoning-informed editing in Table 2, and image generation and editing in Table 3. The paper did not share why Qwen-Image-Omni outperformed Gemini-2.5-Flash-Image and provided qualitative comparison. Take Fig.4 examples for qualitative comparison.
4, Many details are missing in this paper. It is hard to understand why the performance is improving, such as training data, training cost, and training recipe for reproducing the performance.
5, Some symbols are not fully explained, for example, what is and in Eq. 1. Why AR and FM have unit coefficients. Will it change if architecture is changing, or batch size is changing.
6, Not much explanation for Table 4, for example, the Coarse interface is doing better than the Full model on the Interleaved task.
7, FM convergence is very fast in Fig. 5. Why is this happening and why do we need to train 10k steps?
Questions for authors
See Weakness. I will change my rating based on the rebuttal.