- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies how the support of sparse gradients forms a distinct "label channel" in split learning, separate from the values of those coordinates.
Critical strengths
This paper is hard to read, and I can't find any strengths.
Critical weaknesses
This paper is extremely difficult to read and understand. The presentation is unclear throughout, making it challenging to follow the motivation, methodology, and experimental evaluation. I am curious whether any human was involved in writing this paper.
The overall structure is confusing, and essential background information is largely missing. Many equations are presented without adequately defining the notation. For example, in Equation (1), symbols such as "Comp", "supp", and "U" are introduced without any definition or explanation, making the formulation difficult to understand.
The experimental design is extremely unclear. The paper states that "Breast Cancer, Iris, Wine, Digits, and Synthetic-10 use disjoint 60/20/20 model-training, auxiliary, and test partitions and seeds {1, 7, 19, 31, 43}", yet these datasets are neither properly introduced nor cited. Without sufficient background knowledge or domain expertise, readers may not even recognize that these names refer to datasets. The description of the model architectures is also difficult to interpret. For example, the statement "Nonlinear tails, a three-cut convolutional Digits model, residual/TinyViT controls, and LFW test architectural boundaries" does not clearly specify the architectures or experimental settings. Moreover, essential information regarding the baselines, evaluation metrics, and implementation details is missing.
Overall, the paper requires substantial restructuring and clarification. The authors should provide sufficient background, clearly define all notation, systematically describe the methodology, and present complete experimental settings to make the paper understandable.
Questions for authors
Refer to weaknesses.