- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses the observable-closure problem in finite-dimensional Koopman modeling for nonlinear dynamical systems. Instead of relying on state-dependent Koopman operators to absorb unresolved nonlinearities, it proposes CompKoop, which learns a compact set of product observables while keeping the projected dynamics time-invariant. The method only requires accurate prediction of the physical-state observables, leading to a projected-closure formulation for multi-step forecasting. The paper further shows that certain state-dependent projected mappings can be interpreted as fixed operators acting on product-expanded observables, linking adaptive Koopman models to observable completion. Experiments on Lorenz63, Duffing, and reduced Navier–Stokes systems show that the learned product expansion captures important nonlinear interactions and enables strong long-horizon prediction with a compact parameterization.
Critical strengths
The motivation is very well posed, and the problem formulation is clear and easy to follow. Overall, the paper is written with strong clarity and communicates its main ideas effectively.
The progression from theory to experiments is particularly intuitive and well motivated. The experimental design feels genuinely theory-inspired rather than merely empirical, which strengthens the overall narrative.
Critical weaknesses
The scope of both the analysis and the experiments currently feels somewhat limited. If the theoretical development is made more concrete and comprehensive, the current experimental scale may be sufficient. Otherwise, I think the empirical evaluation would need to be expanded substantially. See the questions below for more specific suggestions.
Questions for authors
Q1. Subsection 4.2 seems to be the core methodological component of the paper, but I found the discussion around this design somewhat underdeveloped. In particular, it is not yet clear why the proposed product structure should be expected to work. The gating term is straightforward, and the structure is intuitive as a compact way to introduce multiplicative interactions. However, the paper would benefit from a more explicit explanation of how this construction relates to, or approximates, the preceding -type terms. Why is this the right structural surrogate, and under what assumptions should it be expressive enough?
Q2. More concretely, each learned observable has the form which can be interpreted as a learned quadratic/product feature that captures interactions among components of . This suggests that explicitly modeling interaction terms is an important source of the method's empirical gain. However, it is not yet clear why these interactions are the relevant missing structure for observable completion. I think the paper would be substantially strengthened by either a theoretical argument or a more targeted empirical analysis explaining why this particular interaction structure is an appropriate inductive bias.