- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses active view selection for 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) under few-view budgets, where the underlying primitive set evolves due to densification/pruning, destabilizing per-primitive acquisition states across rounds. The authors propose DC-DLO, which decouples reconstruction-dependent local repair from pose diversity. World-Space Local Repair rebuilds a per-round repair state on fixed voxel cells, storing a 3×3 directional support matrix per occupied cell and scoring candidates by marginal log-determinant gain aggregated via an Adaptive Top-K scheme; Pose-Only Discovery enforces pose novelty through a pool-relative rank gate independent of the repair utility.
Critical strengths
-
Explicitly frames spatial indexing of acquisition evidence as a first-class design choice for sequential 3DGS and demonstrates a robust alternative to per-primitive indexing via fixed world-space cells.
-
Proposes a simple, effective Adaptive Top-K aggregation to prevent candidates from winning via many tiny local gains.
Critical weaknesses
-
The world-space discretization introduces dependencies on voxel size, grid orientation, and scene scale that may affect stability across scenes
-
The coarse visibility and normal-estimation steps rely on current 3DGS geometry and ad hoc thresholds; failure modes early in reconstruction (or under severe occlusion) are not deeply analyzed.
Questions for authors
What is the exact definition and range of the facing/visibility weight αℓ(j), and how is the coarse visibility test implemented (z-buffer resolution, depth tolerance)? How do these choices affect early-round stability?
8 comments
2. Response to Weakness 2 and Question 2: Parameter Sensitivity at Early and Late Acquisition Stages
To examine how facing-based filtering and coarse-visibility tests affect view selection at different reconstruction stages, we froze rounds 1–4 and 13–16 from 18 reference trajectories (9 scenes × 2 seeds), yielding 144 states. For each frozen model and candidate pool, we perturbed the facing threshold and depth tolerance by ±20% relative to their default values and compared the resulting Top-1 views with those selected under the default settings.
| Table 1. Top-1 view change rates under perturbations of the facing threshold and depth tolerance | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Parameter | Default | Perturbed | Early-stage change rate | Late-stage change rate |
| Facing threshold | 0.10 | 0.08 | 15.28% | 8.33% |
| Facing threshold | 0.10 | 0.12 | 13.89% | 11.11% |
| Depth tolerance | 0.010 | 0.008 | 2.78% | 15.28% |
| Depth tolerance | 0.010 | 0.012 | 1.39% | 16.67% |
The default Top-1 view was retained in 515 of 576 comparisons (89.4%). Of the 61 changed selections, 47 (77.0%) occurred when the score difference between the default top two candidates was no greater than 1%. Thus, under these local parameter perturbations, the selected view usually remained unchanged, and changes occurred mainly when candidate scores were close. The early- and late-stage groups each contain 72 states.
The stage-wise results further show that perturbing the facing threshold changes the selected view in 13.89%–15.28% of early-stage states and 8.33%–11.11% of late-stage states. Perturbing the depth tolerance changes the selected view in 1.39%–2.78% of early-stage states and 15.28%–16.67% of late-stage states. Facing-based filtering therefore has a greater effect on early-stage candidate ranking, whereas the depth-occlusion boundary is more influential at later stages.
3. Response to Weakness 1 and Question 3: Sensitivity to Grid Scale, Rotation, and Translation
The voxel-width experiment shows that the spatial aggregation scale affects reconstruction quality. On the three-scene subset, reducing the default width from 0.25 to 0.125 changes PSNR by −0.040 dB, whereas increasing it to 0.5 reduces PSNR by −0.755 dB. The larger loss with the coarser grid indicates that spatial scoring units need to preserve sufficient local discrimination.
To examine the effect of grid placement and orientation on candidate selection, we tested 10 fixed grid-rotation and translation configurations on 144 frozen states from 9 scenes and 2 seeds, giving 1,440 comparisons. The Top-1 view changed in 521 comparisons (36.18%); 242 of these changes (46.45%) occurred in near-tie states, where the relative score difference between the default top two candidates was no greater than 1%. The median relative repair cost of changed selections was 2.02%, and the 95th percentile was 9.06%. These results quantify the effect of grid placement and orientation on candidate ranking and the repair cost of changed selections.
| Table 2. Selection changes and repair costs under grid-rotation and translation perturbations | |
|---|---|
| Diagnostic | Result |
| Frozen states and perturbation configurations | 144 states; 10 grid perturbations; 1,440 comparisons |
| Top-1 selection changes | 521/1,440 (36.18%) |
| Changed selections in near-tie states | 242/521 (46.45%) |
| Relative repair cost of changed selections | Median 2.02%; 95th percentile 9.06% |
Note: A near-tie is defined as a relative score difference of no more than 1% between the default top two candidates.
Response to Reviewer 3NoL
Thank you for your specific questions about facing weights, coarse visibility, and the reliability of early geometry. We have clarified the implementation of facing weights and visibility, and conducted frozen-state perturbation experiments to quantify how these geometric tests and grid configurations affect candidate selection. We report the experimental setup, results, and implications below.
1. Response to Weakness 2 and Question 1: Facing Weights, Normal Estimation, and Coarse Visibility
Let rt,l,j denote the unit direction from the cell representative to camera j, and let nt,l denote the oriented unit normal. The front-facing quality is
Qt,l(j)=max(0,nt,l⊤rt,l,j).
The visibility-gated facing weight is defined as
Zt,l(j)=Zt,l(j)⋅1[Qt,l(j)≥qmin],
αt,l(j)=Zt,l(j)Qt,l(j).
Here, Zt,l(j) is the binary result of the coarse z-buffer visibility test, and Zt,l(j) combines this visibility result with the front-facing threshold, where qmin=0.1. Consequently, αt,l(j)∈{0}∪[0.1,1]. The visibility and facing tests determine whether an observation contributes support, while αt,l(j) determines its continuous facing weight.
Normals are estimated by PCA over the KNN-30 neighborhood of each current cell representative, using the eigenvector associated with the smallest eigenvalue. They are oriented according to the aggregate viewing direction of the acquired supporting cameras.
Coarse visibility uses a point z-buffer. Image width and height are reduced to one quarter of their original resolution, with camera intrinsics scaled accordingly. Each projected point updates the minimum axial depth within a disk of radius 3 pixels. A candidate point is classified as occluded when zcandidate>zbuffer+0.01,where the tolerance is in native scene units. This test uses only the current reconstruction and candidate pose; candidate RGB is not accessed.