- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper describes a model of the ocean carbon-physics system. For a non-expert in this area like me, it is incomprehensible. A lot of terms like “monthly surface fields”, “natural forecasting”, “physical edits”, and “localized pulses” are unexplained when used in the introduction. How should I understand a sentence like “In an environment with paired true futures, we separate the response error introduced by encoding and readout from the error added by the rollout, which gives a lower bound on response skill”, when terms like “paired true futures”, “response skill”, etc., are undefined in the context? The next part of the text is about “source-grounded event familes”, which leaves me clueless. The paper continues to be incomprehensible in the description of the model. For instance, I know what an action is in world models for robotics, but I need an explanation of what is meant in ocean modelling. I could have used AI to help me understand this paper, but then we end up with AI-written papers that only AI can read, so I have not done that. It is my impression that the authors have done a good job of testing their model against other models and so on, but in its present form, the paper would fit only in a very specialized journal or conference.
Critical strengths
Unknown
Critical weaknesses
Almost impossible to read if you do not have detailed knowledge of the narrow field of study
Questions for authors
Have you considered that the audience of general machine-learning scientists at ICLR should be able to at least understand the basic ideas in the paper?