- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
StreamErase combines effect-aware removal with causal distillation and a rolling KV cache for streaming video erasing. It reports 26.06 FPS on an H200 and evaluates long-video performance on 30-second clips.
Critical strengths
The speedup is useful in practice. Table 4 supports the guidance and effect-supervision modules, and Figure 5/Table 5 show that the sink and window choices affect stability.
Critical weaknesses
-
I learned little beyond how to put the existing pieces together. Causal distillation, attention sinks, and rolling caches are established ideas. The guidance and loss improve removal quality, but the paper leaves me unclear about what new insight comes from combining them with streaming inference. The comparisons do not resolve this either. VideoPainter is cited but is missing from the long-video experiments; Object-WIPER is directly relevant to removing associated effects. RT-Remover and SVOR also deserve discussion, as do the streaming designs in LiveEdit and EditCtrl. I would not require experiments against unpublished or contemporaneous work, but a clearer account of the differences would help establish what this paper adds.
-
The evidence for long-video erasing is too limited for the claims. The teaser says “Infinite-length generated video,” yet the quantitative long-video tests cover only 30 seconds. Figure 5 does show quality over time, and Table 5 includes a sliding-window comparison. Still, a fixed-size cache says little about whether removal stays correct minutes into a video, especially with the scene-change limitations acknowledged in Appendix F. Table 2 has no other method in its 30-second section, so the advantage over existing long-video methods is also unclear. LongErase's ground-truth construction and alignment are not explained, which further limits how much I can conclude from these results.
Questions for authors
- What is the main insight beyond combining the existing streaming machinery with effect-aware removal? A focused comparison with the closest applicable method would be more useful than additional component ablations.
- Is there evidence that removal remains reliable well beyond 30 seconds? Please clarify how LongErase ground truth was obtained and aligned. Without further evidence, the claims about infinite streaming with preserved quality should be narrowed.