- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TAMP, a Trajectory-Aware Manifold Projection method, to address the insufficient coverage of normal samples in few-shot medical anomaly detection. The method trains multi-layer feature projectors using normal images and synthetic anomalous images, and uses feature recovery trajectories formed through repeated projections as evidence of anomalies to assist anomaly detection. The final anomaly score combines the initial projection residual, trajectory change ratio, and terminal residual. The paper conducts experiments on four medical datasets.
Critical strengths
-
The paper focuses on the problem of insufficient normal sample coverage in few-shot medical image anomaly detection and uses the continued displacement after the initial residual as supplementary evidence. The motivation is clear and directly corresponds to the single-step projection baseline.
-
The paper conducts experiments on four medical benchmarks and includes five random runs, as well as ablation studies on the number of projection steps, trajectory components, training losses, and projector architectures, providing relatively comprehensive experimental results.
-
The initial deviation, trajectory ratio, and terminal residual characterize the initial state, evolution, and convergence state, respectively. The scoring formulation is intuitive, with manageable computational overhead.
Critical weaknesses
-
The projector is trained only with a single-step reconstruction objective, without imposing contraction, idempotence, or fixed-point constraints, nor are multi-step trajectories unrolled during training. Therefore, the persistent displacement observed after repeated applications may arise from the projector's own instability or out-of-distribution iteration errors. Although the paper cites stable manifold theory, it does not verify the Jacobian spectral radius, the convergence region, or the stable fixed-point conditions for normal samples. Thus, the explanation of the core mechanism remains insufficiently supported.
-
The comparison with full-shot medical anomaly detection methods mixes different backbones, training data volumes, and implementation protocols, making it insufficient to support the strong claim that “four-shot outperforms full-shot.” Moreover, pixel-level evaluation is conducted only on RESC.
-
The trajectory ratio uses the initial residual as its denominator, which may lead to amplified values when the initial residual of normal samples is very small. The paper does not provide a stabilization term, a clipping strategy, or a corresponding sensitivity analysis.
Questions for authors
Please report multi-step error curves for normal and anomalous samples, the spectral radius of the projector's Jacobian or Lipschitz estimates, and compare single-step training, unrolled multi-step training, explicit idempotence regularization, and contraction regularization to demonstrate that the trajectory signal originates from lesions rather than iterative instability.