acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Certified Coordinate Adaptation for Finite-Capacity Latent Dynamics Learners

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

A representation can retain sufficient information for prediction yet remain poorly matched to a finite-capacity downstream learner, limiting how effectively that information can be used. To address this mismatch, we introduce Profiled Certified Exact Gauge Adaptation (PCEGA), which learns an invertible coordinate map and refits a dynamics predictor while keeping the encoder and decoder frozen. Invertibility preserves encoded information, and exact inverse compensation preserves the original reconstruction. A computable global bi-Lipschitz bound controls coordinate distortion, while coordinate optimization uses decoded prediction error and accounts for predictor refitting and ridge selection. Theoretically, for any fixed integer , we prove that invertible affine maps are exactly the globally bi-Lipschitz transformations that preserve the full class of polynomial dynamics of degree at most under conjugacy. Experimentally, the complete default global-budget procedure reduces normalized mean squared error by 48.82% and 45.11% on independently trained Lorenz and R\"ossler charts, respectively. On an analytic-chart benchmark covering four dynamical systems, validation-selected maps from a learned coordinate library reduce normalized mean absolute error by 15.39%–71.11% across linear, quadratic polynomial, random-feature, and radial basis function learners. Both comparisons use independently tuned baselines in the original coordinates. Crossed-learner experiments further reveal learner-specific coordinate preferences, supporting adaptation tailored to the downstream learners.

Primary area:
learning on time series and dynamical systems
Keywords:
Latent dynamics prediction,Coordinate adaptation,Finite capacity learners,Invertible transformations

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_LFQxOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

In the paper "Certified Coordinate Adaptation for Finite-Capacity Latent Dynamics Learners," the authors propose learning invertible coordinate transformations to improve prediction with restricted latent dynamics models. The method preserves the original encoder-decoder reconstruction while adapting the coordinates to better suit a given predictor. The authors provide theoretical guarantees on coordinate distortion and characterize transformations that preserve polynomial dynamics classes. They demonstrate improvements across several dynamical systems and downstream learner families.

The proposed approach is interesting, and the authors provide both theoretical and experimental evidence supporting its effectiveness. However, my primary concern is the motivation for the proposed architecture. While the method improves prediction with restricted learners, it is unclear when this approach would be preferable to learning a more expressive nonlinear latent dynamics model directly.

Critical strengths

The mathematical analysis is a strength of the paper. In particular, the authors characterize the globally bi-Lipschitz transformations that preserve polynomial dynamics classes under conjugacy. The invertible construction also provides a structured means of adapting existing representations while preserving their information content and reconstruction.

The experiments are extensive and demonstrate that coordinate adaptation can improve prediction with restricted learners. The learner-dependent results are particularly interesting, as they show that different downstream models can benefit from different coordinate transformations.

Critical weaknesses

My primary concern is that the paper does not adequately motivate retaining a restricted dynamics learner. The authors demonstrate that invertible coordinate transformations improve prediction with simple polynomial models, but why not simply learn a more expressive nonlinear latent dynamics model? A direct nonlinear predictor would also preserve the frozen encoder-decoder interface without requiring the additional coordinate transformations.

There are potentially compelling reasons for this approach, such as computational tractability, interpretability, or sample efficiency. However, the authors do not demonstrate these advantages, and the complete predictor remains nonlinear. In fact, their own experiments show that more expressive predictors generally achieve better accuracy, raising the question of what the proposed structure actually provides beyond improved performance within a restricted learner family.

Questions for authors
  1. What practical considerations motivate retaining a restricted dynamics learner rather than learning a nonlinear latent dynamics model directly? Are there specific applications where the proposed structure is advantageous?

  2. What does invertibility provide beyond preserving the original representation? Does it improve computational efficiency, generalization, or sample efficiency in practice?

  3. Can the authors demonstrate a setting where coordinate adaptation provides an advantage over a more expressive nonlinear predictor, beyond improving the accuracy of a restricted model?

Reviewer_5A2iOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Profiled Certified Exact Gauge Adaptation (PCEGA), which learns an invertible coordinate map in a latent space to improve the performance when learning dynamics in the latent space. Invertibility is emphasized as a means to preserve information. Theoretical results aim to support the validity of the approach and numerical comparison to a baseline without the invertible coordinate indicate empirical advantages.

Critical strengths

The idea of using an invertible coordinate map as a lightweight, reversible adaptation mechanism is appealing. Additionally, the paper surfaces at least one intriguing and non-obvious empirical observation: even deliberately “wrong” coordinates can outperform the identity map. Although currently unexplained, this points to a phenomenon that could motivate valuable follow-up analysis if the authors investigate it rigorously.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Severe clarity and comprehensibility problems throughout. The exposition is extremely difficult to follow, beginning with the abstract itself. after reading half of it, the core contribution remains opaque to me. This is not an isolated issue: it recurs on essentially every page, with numerous passages whose meaning cannot be reconstructed even with effort. The paper needs a comprehensive rewrite focused on readability before the technical content can be fairly evaluated in my opinion.

  2. Core concepts are never formalized. Central terms are used throughout without definition. “Information,” which is invoked repeatedly as the quantity being preserved, is never formalized. This renders the surrounding claims about information preservation largely vacuous. Similarly, “coordinates,” “chart,” “atlas,” “learner,” “prediction class,” “straightener,” “localization,” “risk,” and “distortion” are used as load-bearing concepts but are either undefined or defined long after first use. A reader cannot follow the argument when the vocabulary it depends on is left unspecified.

  3. Inconsistent and undefined notation. Notation is repeatedly introduced without explanation (e.g., it is unclear whether H is a matrix, and its usage appears inconsistent; symbols such as sigma, E, and D appear without clear meaning, and writing functions E and D adjacent to one another is not explained). Several variables are discussed in connection with equations in which they do not appear. The notation needs to be systematically defined and used consistently.

  4. Inadequate related work and missing citations. The related-work discussion does not convey how the many cited methods relate to or differ from one another. More seriously, as far as I know invertible neural-network architectures already exist in the literature, yet no reference is given. I generally find it surprising that section 4 contains no references at all. This makes it very hard to assess the paper's novelty and to situate it against prior results.

  5. Novelty and significance appear limited. Once decoded, much of the method seems to reduce to standard hyperparameter tuning in a latent space using a validation set to select the best model. The bijection appears to be the only genuinely novel element. The procedure is described in an elaborate way that obscures what is ultimately a fairly simple pipeline. The restriction to regularized linear regression is central but is not surfaced early; the method does not even accommodate nonlinear predictors, which limits its scope and should be stated prominently.

  6. Theoretical results seem trivial or disconnected from the claims. Several results are essentially restatements of the definition of an inverse and add little. Others concern abstract properties that appear disconnected from the paper's central claim that the bijection improves performance, and whose practical significance is not established. The claim that invertible affine maps are the globally bi-Lipschitz conjugacies preserving polynomial dynamics also raises a prior question: why polynomial dynamics are the relevant class at all is never motivated.

  7. Experimental fairness and rigor are insufficient. It is unclear whether the baselines without the bijective layer receive the same hyperparameter optimization; if not, the comparison is not fair. Even with matched tuning, the gains appear tied to model flexibility — notably, the MLP results show no improvement, consistent with nonlinearities already providing the flexibility the bijection is meant to add. Only three random seeds are used (something closer to 20 would be appropriate), standard deviations are missing in places, and where intervals are reported the overlap is large, so the NMSE improvements do not look clearly significant. It is also repeatedly unclear which learner produced specific results.

  8. Unexplored and arguably stronger baselines. The rationale for freezing the encoder/decoder is not given; adapting them might yield better results and should at least be included as a baseline. Relatedly, the finding that even “wrong” coordinates outperform the identity map is strange and left unexplained, and it is unclear why a simple maximum over a score (with the identity included) would not achieve the same effect with far less machinery.

  9. Structural and organizational issues. Theoretical material appears in a section nominally devoted to experimental configuration in the appendix. The closing “discussion” is really an extended conclusion rather than a critical discussion. Concepts such as latency and certain claimed connections are asserted but do not appear in the results, and the term “certified” is used without a clear statement of what, precisely, is certified.

Questions for authors
  1. How is “information” precisely defined in the context of the paper and how is it preserved?

  2. Do baselines receive identical hyperparameter optimization?

  3. Why are the encoder/decoder frozen rather than adapted? (d)

  4. Why are polynomial dynamics are a relevant class?

  5. Why is the method restricted to regularized linear regression and how would it extend to nonlinear predictors?

Reviewer_WDUxOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper argues that changing the coodinates of previously learned latent representation can help restricted models to learn underlyding dynamics. Another encoder-decoder structure is added upon the frozen one (previously learned). The new decoder is the inverse of the new encoder, therefore the original reconstruction is preserved. The paper shows that the new encoder has a computable bound on coodinate distortion and gives a specific result for polynomial predictors. Experiments reports improvements over the same predictors trained in the original latent representation.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  1. Significance: the paper argues that changing coordinates can help restricted predictor. I am not convinced that this is an important restriction to solve, and adding an encoder-predictor-decoder structure upon an existing encoder-decoder is not well justified. Moreover, we see in Table 17 that the competitors achieve much lower error than the adapted global quadratic predictor.
  2. For the encoder-decoder part, the theorems show that the new encoder has bound on coodinates distortion. But no result on learnd predictor is established (prediction, stability, efficiency...).
Questions for authors
  1. Could you please explain what realistic constraint motivates your proposed restriction with quadratic head? It's for interpretability or deployment cost ?
  2. see Critical Weaknesses

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.