- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 1(−1)
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the approximation capabilities, regularity preservation, and statistical properties in nonparametric regression of finite-precision Transformers. Building on existing Kuhn triangulation and ReLU MLP constructions, the authors first construct a single-head Transformer with one self-attention layer to approximate matrix-valued Hölder functions, with hidden weights restricted to a finite discrete set. They then apply fixed-point quantization to the output coefficients and introduce coefficient contraction before quantization to preserve the prescribed -Hölder regularity bound while controlling approximation error, together with asymptotic bounds on parameter count and storage bit complexity. Finally, the authors construct a finite-precision Transformer hypothesis class and show, through finite-class complexity analysis, that exact empirical risk minimization under sub-Gaussian noise achieves the classical minimax convergence exponent for Hölder nonparametric regression, up to logarithmic factors. The paper is primarily theoretical, providing mathematical derivations and proofs without numerical experiments or practical quantization deployment evaluations.
Critical strengths
Strength 1: The paper jointly investigates the approximation accuracy, finite-precision parameter storage complexity, and regularity preservation of Transformers. The relationships among these properties are of theoretical interest. In particular, the authors explicitly distinguish parameter count from the number of bits required to represent the parameters and incorporate storage precision into the theoretical analysis.
Strength 2: The paper provides an explicit network construction and parameter characterization, together with an analysis of how coefficient perturbations affect the Hölder seminorm. By introducing coefficient contraction, the authors preserve the prescribed regularity bound while establishing corresponding asymptotic complexity guarantees. The detailed proofs also facilitate verification of the theoretical claims.
Critical weaknesses
Weakness 1: I have substantial concerns regarding the theoretical novelty of this work. The main approximation construction builds directly upon the regularity-preserving Kuhn-triangulation ReLU MLP developed by Hong and Kratsios [1]. Moreover, the conversion of feedforward approximation constructions into Transformer architectures and the establishment of nonparametric regression guarantees for Transformers have already been investigated in prior work [2, 3]. The primary additional steps in this paper involve combining these existing constructions with fixed-point truncation and coefficient contraction to control perturbations of the output coefficients. While these operations are mathematically reasonable, the paper does not sufficiently establish which aspects constitute a substantial theoretical advance beyond existing results and standard perturbation analysis. In particular, the query and key projection matrices are explicitly set to zero, reducing the self-attention mechanism to input-independent uniform averaging. Consequently, the main approximation capability is inherited from the existing ReLU MLP construction rather than arising from any nontrivial attention mechanism. This further weakens the Transformer-specific novelty of the proposed theoretical results.
Weakness 2: The paper motivates its investigation through the practical deployment of low-bit Transformers. However, its main guarantees concern only the storage precision of parameters in a specially constructed network, while forward evaluation is assumed to use exact real arithmetic. The analysis does not account for finite-precision softmax computation, activation rounding, intermediate numerical errors, or input-dependent attention. Furthermore, it does not establish whether the prescribed regularity bound remains valid under realistic finite-precision inference. Therefore, although the results characterize a particular form of finite-precision parameter representation, they do not directly address the numerical behavior of practically deployed quantized Transformers. This substantially limits the practical implications of the theoretical guarantees.
Weakness 3: The regularity-preservation results are established using the -Hölder seminorm, whereas the original Hölder regularity of the target functions is defined using the distance. Consequently, preserving the same bound under the metric does not necessarily imply preservation of the original bound under the metric. More importantly, the nonparametric regression theorem guarantees only prediction risk and does not ensure that the learned empirical risk minimizer satisfies the same regularity constraint. As the authors acknowledge in Remark 6.2, the regularity-preservation guarantee applies to the explicitly constructed approximant rather than to the general estimator selected by empirical risk minimization. Although some of these limitations are acknowledged in the manuscript, the paper does not establish a unified guarantee of approximation accuracy, regularity preservation, and statistical generalization for the learned finite-precision Transformer. Given the already restrictive theoretical setting, the current results provide limited evidence that the proposed analysis offers new insights or practical guidance for real-world Transformer quantization.
[1] Ruiyang Hong and Anastasis Kratsios. "Bridging the Gap Between Approximation and Learning via Optimal Approximation by ReLU MLPs of Maximal Regularity." arXiv preprint arXiv:2409.12335, 2024. https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.12335
[2] Yanming Lai and Defeng Sun. "Standard Transformers Achieve the Minimax Rate in Nonparametric Regression with Targets." arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.20555, 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.20555
[3] Jerry Yao-Chieh Hu, Mingcheng Lu, Yi-Chen Lee, and Han Liu. "Transformer Approximations from ReLUs." arXiv preprint arXiv:2604.24878, 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.24878
Questions for authors
Q1: Could the authors clarify the specific novel technical contributions of Theorem 4.1, Theorem 5.2, Corollary 5.4, and Theorem 6.1? In particular, compared with the regularity-preserving MLP construction of Hong and Kratsios [1] and the Transformer approximation and regression guarantees established by Lai and Sun [2], which results in this paper cannot be directly derived from existing constructions and standard fixed-point perturbation analysis? A rigorous theorem-level comparison with these prior works would help clarify the originality and significance of the proposed theoretical contributions.
Q2: In the proposed construction, the query and key projection matrices are set to zero (), reducing the attention mechanism to input-independent uniform averaging. Under this setting, what new Transformer-specific theoretical insights does the proposed framework provide beyond applying finite-precision parameterization to an existing ReLU MLP construction? Furthermore, would the approximation and regularity-preservation guarantees remain valid if the architecture incorporated nontrivial input-dependent attention?
Q3: Corollary 5.4 establishes the prescribed -Hölder regularity bound for a specifically constructed approximant, whereas the empirical risk minimizer in Theorem 6.1 is not guaranteed to satisfy the same regularity constraint. Is it possible to impose an explicit regularity constraint on the learned estimator while preserving the same statistical convergence exponent? Additionally, to what extent does establishing the final guarantee under the metric, rather than the metric used in the original definition of the target function's Hölder regularity, limit the significance and applicability of the regularity-preservation result?
[1] Ruiyang Hong and Anastasis Kratsios. "Bridging the Gap Between Approximation and Learning via Optimal Approximation by ReLU MLPs of Maximal Regularity." arXiv preprint arXiv:2409.12335, 2024. https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.12335
[2] Yanming Lai and Defeng Sun. "Standard Transformers Achieve the Minimax Rate in Nonparametric Regression with Targets." arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.20555, 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.20555
4 comments
Response to Reviewer cxJN (2/2)
W2 (Practical scope). We agree that our guarantees concern parameter storage under exact forward evaluation, not finite-precision inference. The abstract and Secs. 1–2 state this scope explicitly. In our approximation construction, all non-output parameters are exactly represented and counted in the common fixed-point format (Thm. 5.2(2)), so parameter-truncation error is confined to the output coefficients. This storage/evaluation separation also appears in the dyadic-parameter Transformer approximation of [1].
The regularity bound is not guaranteed under rounded evaluation. Rounding in softmax, activations, or intermediate arithmetic can introduce jumps, as illustrated by the runtime diagnostics in our response to v4x1. These are not deployment guarantees, and a rigorous inference-level analysis is not attempted here. A concrete takeaway for our construction under exact evaluation is that coefficient contraction plus roughly twice the fractional bits of the accuracy-only schedule suffices to retain accuracy and the componentwise -Hölder bound , at unchanged storage upper-bound order (Cor. 5.4).
W3 & Q3 (Regularity of the learned estimator). Yes. Under the same assumptions as Thm. 6.1, new Prop. 6.2 (App. E.4) restricts to the subclass satisfying the componentwise -Hölder and sup-norm bounds on . This links Sec. 6 to Cor. 5.4's regularity bound while keeping Thm. 6.1 as an unconstrained baseline. Measurable exact ERM over attains the same expected squared prediction-risk upper-bound order, (). Hong and Kratsios [1, Sec. 4.2] likewise constrain their network class by a Lipschitz bound.
The key idea is to preserve the approximation–complexity balance of the finite-class bound (Thm. E.1). By Lem. 5.1, contracting the output coefficients reserves a margin that absorbs quantization when . Prop. 6.2 ensures this by doubling the coefficient of in Thm. 6.1's precision schedule and adding an -independent offset. For fixed , the precision remains . With the constructive hidden configuration, this gives a comparison approximant in with uniform error , while retains the same upper-bound order. Thm. E.1 then gives the stated risk bound. Exact ERM ranges over the full constrained class, not only contracted approximants. Efficient constrained optimization is not established here.
W3 & Q3 (cont.: versus Euclidean metric). We thank the reviewer for highlighting this metric distinction. Both the approximant in Cor. 5.4 and the constrained estimator in Prop. 6.2 retain Hölder exponent . The metric distinction concerns the guaranteed constant. Writing for the Euclidean seminorm in Eq. (1), we have . Our Euclidean target assumption implies the bound , which the HK interpolant preserves and our quantization analysis retains. In Euclidean distance, the resulting guarantee is at most .
For fixed , this metric conversion leaves the approximation and statistical convergence exponents established here unchanged. It does not certify the original Euclidean constant . The explicit factor becomes more consequential as input dimension or sequence length grows, so applications requiring that exact Euclidean bound are outside the guarantee. We state this limitation explicitly in Rem. 6.3.
[1] Furuya, de Hoop & Peyré. "Universality and Generalization of Causal Transformers Across Context Lengths." arXiv:2609.35055v1, https://arxiv.org/html/2609.35055v1
We welcome any remaining questions.
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal. The newly introduced Proposition 6.2 substantially addresses my concern regarding regularity preservation for the learned estimator. However, my main concern about limited theoretical novelty remains. Overall, I believe a rating of 2 (Weak Rejection) is fair.
Thank you for taking the time to read our rebuttal and reconsider your assessment. We appreciate your acknowledgment that Proposition 6.2 substantially addresses your concern about regularity preservation for the learned estimator. Your feedback helped us strengthen the connection between our approximation and statistical results. Please let us know if you have any further questions, and thank you again for your helpful feedback.
Response to Reviewer cxJN (1/2)
W1 & Q1 (Contribution beyond existing results). We agree that the construction builds on [1, 2] and uses elementary perturbation and contraction arguments. We do not claim new proof techniques. Our contribution is a joint guarantee that, to our knowledge, is not established in [1–3]. Under exact forward evaluation, Transformers with all parameters stored in one explicit fixed-point format approximate every target in the stated λ-Hölder ball to accuracy ε, preserve the prescribed componentwise ℓ1-Hölder bound L, and admit complete encodings within a logarithmic factor of the worst-case encoding lower bound. Write D=dn.
Accuracy-only quantization does not guarantee preservation of L, and direct truncation can exceed it (see our response to v4x1). At grid resolution N, Lem. 5.1 bounds the seminorm perturbation by 2δNλ for coefficient errors bounded by δ. This upper bound need not vanish under our accuracy-only schedule. Contracting coefficients by 1−ρ reserves a margin ρL, and Cor. 5.4 chooses finer precision so that 2δNλ≤ρL. This sufficient schedule uses 2log2(1/ε)+O(1) fractional bits, twice the leading term of our accuracy-only schedule, with unchanged parameter-count and storage upper-bound orders.
W1 & Q2 (Role of attention and scope of the result). Kajitsuka and Sato [7, Thm. 2] and He et al. [8, Lem. 4.10] use softmax attention to construct contextual mappings that distinguish tokens across contexts on suitable finite input sets. We use the gathering route of Lai and Sun [2, Lem. 8], , in which uniform attention (WQ=WK=0) gives each token a scaled copy of the complete ordered input, with its position code carried alongside. Our post-attention HK block computes the outputs and uses positional gating to select column q for token q (Lems. C.4–C.5). This makes each token's output depend on its context and position, using the full input rather than attention-generated context ids.
We choose this exact realization for its precision structure,, since it's attention/embedding entries lie in {0,1}, and HK hidden feature weights use small discrete alphabets. Structural integers and output coefficients are also covered by the common fixed-point budget (Thm. 5.2(2)). Our focus is the joint approximation, storage, and componentwise ℓ1-Hölder guarantee of Cor. 5.4, not a new account of attention's approximation power.
The same joint guarantee for nontrivial input-dependent attention remains open here (Sec. 7).
[1] R. Hong and A. Kratsios. Bridging the Gap between Approximation and Learning via Optimal Approximation by ReLU MLPs of Maximal Regularity. arXiv:2409.12335, 2024.
[2] Y. Lai and D. Sun. Standard Transformers Achieve the Minimax Rate in Nonparametric Regression with Cs,λ Targets. arXiv:2602.20555, 2026.
[3] J. Y.-C. Hu, M. Lu, Y.-C. Lee, and H. Liu. Transformer Approximations from ReLUs. arXiv:2604.24878, 2026.
[4] W. Ou, P. Schenkel, and H. Bölcskei. Three Quantization Regimes for ReLU Networks. arXiv:2405.01952, 2024.
[5] T. Mao and J. Xu. Do Neural Networks Really Beat the Curse of Dimensionality? A Bit-Complexity View. arXiv:2608.01357, 2026.
[6] A. N. Kolmogorov and V. M. Tikhomirov. ε-entropy and ε-capacity of sets in function spaces. Uspekhi Matematicheskikh Nauk, 14(2):3–86, 1959.
[7] T. Kajitsuka and I. Sato. Are Transformers with One Layer Self-Attention Using Low-Rank Weight Matrices Universal Approximators? In ICLR, 2024 (arXiv:2307.14023v3).
[8] X. He, Y. Jiao, X. Lu, and J. Z. Yang. Approximation Error Upper and Lower Bounds for Hölder Class with Transformers. In ICML, 2026 (arXiv:2605.07463v2).