- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 3(+1)
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Ada-BFM, a framework for adapting pretrained behavior foundation models to humanoid scene interaction. The method freezes the pretrained ScaleBFM and introduces depth-conditioned adapters trained with reinforcement learning. It enables the robot to perform various terrain and object interaction tasks while largely preserving its original motion-tracking capabilities.
Critical strengths
See "Questions For Authors".
Critical weaknesses
See "Questions For Authors".
Questions for authors
- The proposed method is evaluated exclusively on ScaleBFM, and its adapter design is closely tied to the Transformer's architecture. Although the authors position Ada-BFM as a general framework for adapting BFMs, it remains unclear whether the approach can be effectively transferred to other BFM architectures, such as SONIC. Evaluating Ada-BFM on an additional pretrained BFM would provide stronger evidence for its claimed generality.
- If I understand correctly, Ada-BFM still relies on reference motions as control inputs for terrain interaction tasks such as stair climbing and obstacle traversal. Why is this design adopted? If the actual terrain differs from the reference motion (e.g., different stair heights or obstacle positions), how well can the model adapt to these variations? I believe this input design has certain limitations, and it would be more practical if the robot could perform these tasks using simple directional commands, such as moving forward, backward, left, and right.
- After watching the provided videos, I was particularly interested in the G1's ability to pick up various objects. However, the paper provides limited details about how many different objects were used during training, whether the test objects were seen during training, and what the reference motions look like. Since the method still relies on reference motions to perform these tasks, I consider this dependency a significant limitation. Therefore, I am more inclined to view this work as primarily focusing on sim-to-real transfer rather than learning generalizable object manipulation capabilities.
- I did not find any experiments investigating how changing the reference motions affects the results. I believe this is an important aspect that should be evaluated.
Dear Reviewers,
As the discussion period is coming to a close, please take a moment to review the authors’ responses and revised manuscript. Kindly assess whether your concerns have been adequately addressed or if any questions remain, and update your scores accordingly, if necessary.
Thank you for your time and thoughtful evaluations.
Best regards, AC