acceptodds
Desk rejected at ICLR 2027

A Theory of Reliable Self-Evolution for Agent Harnesses

Desk rejected at ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

In harness self-evolution, agents modify their own prompts, code, tools, and orchestration while keeping the underlying language model fixed. Recent work has shown that agents can improve themselves in response to task failures and achieve substantial performance gains. However, gains on failed tasks do not automatically ensure that performance on previously successful tasks is preserved, raising concerns about reliable adoption. In this work, we provide a theoretically grounded condition under which a self-evolved harness can be reliably adopted. We then propose a validation rule to make the evolved system satisfy the reliable adoption condition with theoretical guarantees. Consequently, the system can achieve progressive improvement through evolution. This leads to a natural question: Does reliable self-evolution have a performance ceiling, and which factors govern this ceiling? Our theoretical results show that the performance ceiling is determined by the costs of verification and evaluation. On the other hand, self-evolution may stall in practice. In this regard, we show that experimental evidence on agent performance shifts can be used to identify the sources of stagnation. Our work thus establishes a theoretical framework for understanding and advancing reliable harness self-evolution.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM Agent, Agent Self-Improvement, Harness Self-Evolution, Theoretical Analysis

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_y8RDOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4(+2)
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates reliable agent harness self-evolution, where agents modify prompts, tools, code, and workflows while keeping the underlying language model fixed. The authors establish a theoretical relationship between improvements on failed tasks and performance changes on previously successful tasks, derive sufficient conditions for reliable adoption, and propose two confidence-based validation rules, Two-Gate and Measured-Margin. The paper further analyzes candidate reachability, guarantees for progressive improvement, and verification costs, while introducing a framework to distinguish generation bottlenecks from validation bottlenecks. Experiments on DS-1000 illustrate how potentially beneficial modifications may be rejected due to insufficient validation evidence.

Critical strengths

The paper establishes sufficient conditions for reliable adoption by analyzing gains on failed tasks and performance changes on previously successful tasks. It further introduces statistically grounded validation rules and establishes cumulative improvement guarantees across multiple evolution steps.
The paper distinguishes actual improvement potential from performance ceilings imposed by validation rules and uses reachability analysis to identify generation and validation bottlenecks. The DS-1000 experiments also provide empirical evidence that insufficient validation evidence can prevent potentially beneficial modifications from being adopted.

Critical weaknesses

The experiments primarily use a confidence-interval-based screening procedure without directly comparing the proposed Two-Gate and Measured-Margin methods. Consequently, the practical benefits of these rules in actual self-evolution remain unclear.
The proposed validation mechanisms require extensive independent evaluations to control statistical uncertainty, while very few candidate modifications pass validation in the experiments. Although the paper analyzes theoretical verification costs, the practical trade-off between reliability and evaluation efficiency remains insufficiently demonstrated.
The reliable adoption condition requires gains on failed tasks to outweigh potential losses on retained tasks. However, the primary thresholds used in the DS-1000 experiments are not calibrated to this condition. Consequently, candidates meeting the experimental targets do not necessarily guarantee overall performance improvement, weakening the connection between the empirical analysis and the core theoretical framework.

Questions for authors

How does the validation procedure used in the DS-1000 experiments differ from the proposed Two-Gate and Measured-Margin rules? Can the authors clarify whether these rules would lead to different adoption decisions based on the existing experimental results?
Is the low validation acceptance rate primarily caused by large statistical uncertainty or by candidates failing to meet the required conditions? Would increasing the validation budget substantially improve this situation?
Why are the target thresholds in the DS-1000 experiments not directly aligned with the theoretical sufficient condition for reliable adoption? Based on the existing experimental data, would using theoretically calibrated thresholds substantially change the candidate qualification rates and stagnation diagnosis results?

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer y8RD (Part 1/3)

W1 & Q1: How does the validation procedure used in the DS-1000 experiments differ from Two-Gate and Measured-Margin? Would these rules lead to different adoption decisions based on the existing experimental results?

Response 1:

(1) How does the original validation procedure differ from Two-Gate and Measured-margin?

Thank you for pointing out the difference between the validation procedure used in the DS-1000 experiments and our proposed rules. To simplify computation, the original experiments used binary task outcomes to calculate the repair proportion on failed tasks and the loss proportion on retained tasks. The corresponding confidence bounds were then compared with the prespecified targets. Two-Gate additionally requires a strictly positive lower bound on the overall expected-reward gain. Measured-margin directly uses a lower bound on the overall expected-reward gain to decide whether to adopt a candidate.

The DS-1000 experiments focus on understanding the sources of stagnation. We use additional evaluations to determine whether a candidate improves performance, then examine the original validation records to identify why it was not adopted. This simpler screening procedure therefore does not change the conclusion we draw from the example in the paper.

(2) Would these rules lead to different adoption decisions?

Following your suggestion, we also computed adoption decisions under both rules using the existing audit data from three independent runs:

RuleCandidate pass rateAdoption rate
Original procedure2/2882/72
Two-Gate0/2880/72
Measured-margin11/2888/72

These results show that changing the validation rule affects the adoption rate. In particular, no candidate passed Two-Gate validation and was adopted in this experiment. Our analysis shows that this is due to the base agent's limited capacity for self-evolution, rather than overly stringent theoretical requirements. Please see our response to W2 & Q2 for the detailed analysis and supplementary experiments. We will add an explanation of the validation procedure and these comparison results to the final version of the paper.


W2 & Q2: Is the low validation acceptance rate primarily caused by large statistical uncertainty or by candidates failing to meet the required conditions? Would increasing the validation budget substantially improve this situation? What is the practical trade-off between reliability and evaluation efficiency?

Response 2:

Thank you for your suggestion. Our analysis shows that DS-1000's low adoption rate mainly results from limitations in the initial agent's capacity for self-evolution and the modification generation method, rather than overly stringent theoretical requirements. The initial agent in the original experiment used a simple Python harness that made only one model call. The self-evolution process used basic strategies: direct candidate generation or a single revision based on feedback. In the repeated evaluations, 191 of the 286 valid candidates had an estimated failure-task contribution below the original prespecified target.

We have added experiments on Terminal-Bench 2.1 using Terminus-2 as the initial agent and a state-of-the-art method for generating modifications. Please see the Supplementary Experiments section below for the detailed settings and results. At an 80% confidence level, Two-Gate and Measured-margin supported reliable adoption of one and three of the eight candidates, respectively. These results show that the validation rules in our theoretical framework achieve acceptable adoption rates in practice and can support actual updates while meeting the reliability requirements.

Our experiments also show that increasing the validation budget can improve the validation pass rate. In the original DS-1000 experiment, we compared validation budgets of 8 and 48 tasks on the same candidates. The number of candidates passing validation increased from 0 to 2. This observation is consistent with our theoretical analysis: additional evaluation can reduce statistical uncertainty and provide the evidence needed to validate existing improvements. Thus, improving candidate generation and increasing the validation budget affect different stages, and both influence the adoption rate in reliable self-evolution. We will include these experimental results and analyses in the final version of the paper.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer y8RD (Part 2/3)

W3 & Q3: Why are the target thresholds in the DS-1000 experiments not directly aligned with the theoretical sufficient condition for reliable adoption? Based on the existing experimental data, would theoretically calibrated thresholds substantially change candidate qualification rates and stagnation diagnosis results?

Response 3:

Thank you for pointing this out. We have recalculated the experimental results using the theoretical sufficient condition:

Generation processEstimated qualified candidates under the original targetEstimated qualified candidates under the sufficient condition
Independent generation37/968/96
Label-free revision25/964/96
Outcome-feedback revision33/9614/96

The new results show that strictly applying this condition substantially reduces the candidate qualification rate, but they still support our conclusions from the stagnation analysis. We will update the relevant results and explanations in the final version of the paper.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Supplementary Experiments(Part 3/3)

1. Experimental Setup

We use Terminus-2[1] as the initial agent and keep the underlying model, deepseek-v4.1-flash-1017, fixed. We select 30 tasks from Terminal-Bench 2.1[1] and use the uniform distribution over these tasks as the user-task distribution. We use RRSI[2] to generate modifications: each generation batch contains 4 failed task and produces 8 candidate agents. The validation set contains 60 task records drawn independently from this distribution. For each record, the failure label is determined by an independent execution of the current agent; each agent performs 3 additional executions on the corresponding task to measure reward. We set the maximum allowed change on retained tasks to 0.15 and use a grid spacing of 0.005 for the Two-Gate parameters τ,δ\tau,\delta.

2. Experiment 1: Comparison of Validation Rules

Confidence level 1−β1-\betaTwo-GateMeasured-margin
99%0/80/8
95%0/81/8: N1
90%0/81/8: N1
80%1/8: N13/8: N1, N3, N7
70%1/8: N14/8: N1, N3, N4, N7
60%1/8: N15/8: N0, N1, N3, N4, N7
50%1/8: N16/8: N0, N1, N2, N3, N4, N7

As the baseline validation rule, we use a common approach in prior work: selecting candidates directly based on their overall performance on the validation set.

RulePass rateCandidates
Baseline6/8N0, N1, N2, N3, N4, N7

3. Experiment 2: Multi-Step Self-Evolution

We conduct multi-step self-evolution using the Measured-margin validation rule at a confidence level of 1−β=80%1-\beta=80\%.

Agent AkA_kPass ratePer-step gain lower bound (pp)Mean reward (%)
A0A_0——78.89
A1A_13/8+4.16583.33
A2A_21/8+1.80885.56
A3A_31/8+0.27287.78

[1] Terminal-Bench: Benchmarking Agents on Hard, Realistic Tasks in Command Line Interfaces.

[2] RRSI: Regularized Recursive Self-Improvement of Agent Harnesses.

Reviewer_4PWEOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies reliable self-evolution of LLM agent harnesses, where agents modify their prompts, tools, code, or orchestration while keeping the underlying LLM fixed. The authors formulate a sufficient condition for reliable adoption by balancing performance improvements on previously failed tasks against potential regressions on previously successful tasks. Based on this condition, they propose confidence-based validation rules and establish theoretical guarantees for safe adoption and cumulative improvement across evolution steps.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a practical challenge in self-evolving agents: improvements on failed tasks may cause regressions on previously successful tasks. It provides a theoretical framework for reliable adoption and progressive improvement.

The paper analyzes how validation can create performance ceilings and distinguishes between generation and validation bottlenecks. These insights are useful for understanding why self-evolution may stagnate.

Critical weaknesses

Many of the paper's theoretical results formalize relatively intuitive observations, such as balancing improvements against regressions, using statistical confidence to validate modifications, and requiring more evaluations to verify smaller improvements. Although the paper provides additional analysis of performance ceilings and evolution stagnation, it remains unclear what fundamentally new insights or actionable benefits these results offer beyond existing validation approaches. This limits the significance of the overall theoretical contribution.

The experiments are limited to DS-1000, with only 2 out of 288 generated modifications adopted. The paper does not demonstrate sustained improvements through multiple evolution steps, making the practical effectiveness of the framework unclear.

Questions for authors
  1. What are the key novel insights or practical benefits of the proposed theory compared with existing validation methods?

  2. Can the authors provide multi-step self-evolution experiments to demonstrate the practical effectiveness of the framework?

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4PWE (Part 1/3)

W1 & Q1: The main theoretical results appear to formalize relatively intuitive observations. Their key novel insights and practical benefits beyond existing validation approaches remain unclear.

Response 1:

Thank you for carefully reviewing our paper and for your specific questions about its theoretical novelty and practical significance. We respond in three parts.

(1) What are the core theoretical contributions of this work?

We first highlight the current state of harness self-evolution research. Existing work has clearly demonstrated that agents can improve themselves. However, the question of whether these modifications guarantee overall performance improvement and can therefore be reliably adopted still lacks systematic analysis. Against this background, our contributions are as follows:

  1. We give a sufficient condition for reliably adopting a self-evolved modification. We prove that overall expected reward improves when gains on failed tasks and performance changes on retained tasks satisfy this condition.
  2. We provide validation rules with theoretical guarantees for reliable adoption using finite evaluation data.
  3. We prove that the gains guaranteed for adopted updates accumulate throughout evolution, supporting progressive improvement.
  4. We give a theoretical characterization of the performance ceiling of reliable self-evolution and show how the choice of validation rule and evaluation cost limit further improvement.
  5. We show how evidence on candidate performance shifts can diagnose stagnation and provide theoretical guarantees for estimating the probability of generating qualified modifications, helping distinguish generation difficulties from insufficient validation evidence.

We would like to clarify that our main contribution is a systematic theoretical analysis of reliable self-evolution, with corresponding conditions and guarantees, rather than an algorithm for carrying it out. By analyzing its feasibility, requirements, and performance ceiling, we aim to provide insights and a basis for designing future harness self-evolution algorithms.

(2) Do these results merely formalize intuitive observations?

First, we would like to clarify a misunderstanding about our contribution. Our results go beyond the intuitive observations that "improvements must outweigh regressions," "adoption requires statistical evidence," and "small gains are harder to validate." For example, we prove that validation requirements can cause a system to stop updating even when further improvement remains possible, and provide a construction that enables further improvement while preserving guarantees for reliable adoption. This shows how the validation mechanism itself affects progress and helps algorithm designers distinguish a lack of remaining improvement opportunities from a failure to validate further improvement. We further establish uniform guarantees for estimating the probability of generating qualified modifications. Together with validation records, these guarantees help distinguish generation difficulties from insufficient validation evidence. This allows the sources of stagnation to be studied empirically and helps determine whether further effort should focus on candidate generation or on validation and its supporting evidence.

We also emphasize that agreement with intuition should not diminish the value of a theoretical result. We build on these insights to derive explicit constraints, probability guarantees, and lower bounds on the required evaluation cost, and prove that reliable self-evolution is achievable. Intuition can suggest possible relationships, but it cannot establish the conditions under which they hold, the strength of the guarantees, which limitations can be addressed through algorithm design, or which costs are unavoidable. Establishing these conditions and boundaries is necessary to guide algorithm design and analysis. These conclusions require theoretical derivation and proof; they cannot be obtained from intuitive observations alone.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 4PWE (Part 2/3)

Response 1 (continued):

(3) What practical benefits do these theoretical results offer beyond existing validation approaches?

First, we would like to clarify that our focus is theoretical analysis of the conditions, requirements, and performance ceiling of reliable harness self-evolution, rather than a validation algorithm with optimal performance.

Existing harness self-evolution research also primarily focuses on evolution algorithms rather than validation rules. It typically constructs a validation set by sampling tasks and decides whether to adopt a new version directly from overall performance on that set. However, a higher overall validation score does not guarantee that the candidate can be reliably adopted. We analyze the relationship between repair gains on failed tasks and performance changes on retained tasks to derive a lower bound on the required repair gains and constraints on retained-task performance changes. We prove that satisfying these conditions yields a strictly positive lower bound on overall expected-reward gain. Based on this result, we give validation requirements with theoretical guarantees using finite evaluation data, allowing self-evolution algorithms to base adoption on an overall gain lower bound while controlling the risk of unreliable adoption.

Our experimental results show that, among eight generated candidates, six would be adopted if selection relied only on improvements in overall validation performance. In contrast, enhanced Measured-margin supports adoption of only one candidate at 90% confidence; among the confidence levels compared, it accepts all six only when the level is relaxed to 50%. Thus, compared with conventional validation, our rule can identify candidates with high-confidence improvement guarantees that support reliable adoption, providing stronger reliability guarantees for self-evolution updates. Please see the Supplementary Experiments section below for the results.


W2 & Q2: The experiments are limited to DS-1000, with few adopted modifications, and do not demonstrate sustained improvements through multiple evolution steps. The practical effectiveness of the framework remains unclear.

Response 2:

Thank you for your suggestion. We have added systematic end-to-end experiments on Terminal-Bench 2.1 to demonstrate the feasibility of our theoretical framework in practical harness self-evolution. Please see the Supplementary Experiments section below for the detailed settings and results.

As requested, we conducted a complete multi-step self-evolution experiment: after each update, the adopted agent became the current agent for the next round and continued to generate modifications. The per-step gain lower bounds were positive for all three updates and summed to 6.245 percentage points along the actual update sequence. Meanwhile, mean reward over the task population increased progressively from 78.89% to 87.78%. These results demonstrate that reliable adoption can be carried out over successive updates, with per-step gain lower bounds accumulating throughout evolution and overall task performance improving over time, providing end-to-end experimental support for the feasibility of our theoretical framework.

Regarding the low adoption count on DS-1000, our analysis shows that the original experiment used a simple Python harness with a single model call and generated modifications either directly or through one revision based on feedback. We added experiments on Terminal-Bench 2.1 with Terminus-2 as the initial agent and RRSI, a current state-of-the-art modification generation method. As shown in the Supplementary Experiments section below, at an 80% confidence level, Two-Gate and Measured-margin identify one and three reliably adoptable modifications, respectively, among eight candidates. These results show that the validation rules in our theoretical framework achieve acceptable adoption rates in practice and support actual updates while meeting the reliability requirements.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Supplementary Experiments(Part 3/3)

1. Experimental Setup

We use Terminus-2[1] as the initial agent and keep the underlying model, deepseek-v4.1-flash-1017, fixed. We select 30 tasks from Terminal-Bench 2.1[1] and use the uniform distribution over these tasks as the user-task distribution. We use RRSI[2] to generate modifications: each generation batch contains 4 failed tasks and produces 8 candidate agents. The validation set contains 60 task records drawn independently from this distribution. For each record, the failure label is determined by an independent execution of the current agent; each agent performs 3 additional executions on the corresponding task to measure reward. We set the maximum allowed change on retained tasks to 0.15 and use a grid spacing of 0.005 for the Two-Gate parameters τ,δ\tau,\delta.

2. Experiment 1: Comparison of Validation Rules

Confidence level 1−β1-\betaTwo-GateMeasured-margin
99%0/80/8
95%0/81/8: N1
90%0/81/8: N1
80%1/8: N13/8: N1, N3, N7
70%1/8: N14/8: N1, N3, N4, N7
60%1/8: N15/8: N0, N1, N3, N4, N7
50%1/8: N16/8: N0, N1, N2, N3, N4, N7

As the baseline validation rule, we use a common approach in prior work: selecting candidates directly based on their overall performance on the validation set.

RulePass rateCandidates
Baseline6/8N0, N1, N2, N3, N4, N7

3. Experiment 2: Multi-Step Self-Evolution

We conduct multi-step self-evolution using the Measured-margin validation rule at a confidence level of 1−β=80%1-\beta=80\%.

Agent AkA_kPass ratePer-step gain lower bound (pp)Mean reward (%)
A0A_0——78.89
A1A_13/8+4.16583.33
A2A_21/8+1.80885.56
A3A_31/8+0.27287.78

[1] Terminal-Bench: Benchmarking Agents on Hard, Realistic Tasks in Command Line Interfaces.

[2] RRSI: Regularized Recursive Self-Improvement of Agent Harnesses.

Reviewer_Sjc4OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how to verify whether changes to an agent's harness improve performance. The authors propose two validation rules that account for gains on failed tasks and possible losses on previously successful tasks. They analyze improvement over multiple updates and verification cost, and distinguish poor candidate generation from overly conservative validation. Experiments on DS-1000 show how additional evaluation can identify a useful modification that was previously rejected.

Critical strengths
  1. The topic is important, particularly the question of whether an agent update improves failed tasks without harming its other capabilities.
  2. The paper provides detailed theoretical analysis and distinguishes a lack of useful candidate updates from overly conservative validation, which is helpful for understanding why self-evolution stops improving.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The main theoretical results appear somewhat incremental. Theorem 1 subtracts possible losses from gains, while Theorem 4 sums the guaranteed gains across accepted updates. The performance ceiling also depends on the validation rule and is relaxed by Rule 2. The authors should clarify what these results add beyond existing confidence-based acceptance methods and why separating gains and losses is preferable to directly estimating overall improvement.

  2. The theoretical contribution needs clearer differentiation from existing safe-improvement results. The adoption condition follows from decomposing average reward, and the progressive-improvement guarantee accumulates per-step confidence bounds. The performance ceiling concerns the proposed validation rule rather than self-evolution itself. The distinction from existing confidence-bound-based safe-improvement results should be clearer.

  3. The practical cost and conservatism of the validation rules remain unclear. Two-Gate penalizes absolute changes on retained tasks, including improvements. Measured-margin relaxes this restriction, but its sample efficiency remains untested. A comparison with directly testing a confidence bound on overall reward improvement would clarify the reliability–cost trade-off.

  4. The experiments do not validate the framework end-to-end. Evaluation uses one model on DS-1000 and mainly audits frozen candidates. Finding a useful rejected update does not show that the proposed rules resolve stagnation. Multi-step comparisons of adoption rates, regressions, final performance, and evaluation cost are needed.

Questions for authors

Please see the Weaknesses section.

7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Sjc4 (Part 1/4)

W1: The main theoretical results appear incremental. What do they add beyond existing confidence-based acceptance methods, and why is separating gains and losses preferable to directly estimating overall improvement?

Response 1:

Thank you for carefully reviewing our paper and for your specific questions about its theoretical contribution and research scope. We would like to clarify three points.

(1) Are the main theoretical results merely incremental?

First, we would like to clarify that describing our results as "subtracting losses from gains," "adding up gains across updates," and "relaxing the ceiling with another rule" leaves out the theoretical conditions and guarantees they establish. Our analysis of reliable adoption specifies how repair gains on failed tasks and performance changes on retained tasks must relate to ensure an increase in overall expected reward, and gives validation requirements that establish this guarantee using finite evaluation data. The progressive-improvement result connects gain lower bounds obtained before adoption to a cumulative gain guarantee across successive updates, with the overall error probability controlled and later agents and candidates allowed to depend on the preceding evolution history.

Our contribution also extends beyond these results. Multiple theorems, corollaries, and constructions together establish our conclusions about reliable self-evolution. For example, we quantify how generation capability and validation precision jointly determine the probability of a reliable update. We derive a performance ceiling imposed by validation, construct modifications with positive gains even when the current agent's performance exceeds that ceiling, and prove that an alternative validation principle can support reliable adoption under the stated conditions. This distinguishes a failure to validate improvement from a lack of actual improvement opportunities. Our analysis of the necessary evaluation cost further characterizes costs that cannot be eliminated solely by changing the validation principle, while guarantees for estimating the probability of generating qualified modifications provide a statistical basis for studying the sources of stagnation.

Together, these results explain the conditions for reliable self-evolution, how it can progress, and why it is constrained, rather than merely adding to a few intuitive observations. They clarify the requirements for reliable updates, the constraints that validation design can impose, and the evaluation effort required for further improvement, thereby informing future harness self-evolution algorithms.

(2) What does this work add beyond existing confidence-based acceptance methods?

Existing harness self-evolution work focuses primarily on generating better modifications rather than acceptance methods. A common acceptance rule in these systems is to adopt a new version when overall validation performance improves. We establish the first systematic theoretical framework covering the conditions for reliable harness self-evolution, progressive improvement, the performance ceiling, and the sources of stagnation. Our contribution is not an incremental result on existing acceptance methods. Please see Response 2 for a detailed comparison with existing confidence-based acceptance methods.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Sjc4 (Part 2/4)

Response 1 (continued):

(3) Why is separating repair gains and retained-task changes preferable to directly estimating overall improvement?

We would like to clarify that we analyze these two components separately to establish conditions for reliable self-evolution that account for both failure repair and preservation of existing capabilities. Overall net gain indicates whether average performance improves, but it cannot by itself ensure that performance changes on retained tasks remain within a specified range.

For example, one modification may yield a positive net gain because large repair gains outweigh substantial losses in existing capabilities. Another may offer smaller repair gains while leaving existing capabilities largely unchanged. They can have the same overall gain but different retention properties. Thus, net gain alone cannot express the requirement to preserve existing capabilities.

Accordingly, we characterize the repair contribution on failed tasks and performance changes on retained tasks separately. We prove that the overall expected-reward gain has a strictly positive lower bound when the repair contribution reaches the required lower bound, retained-task changes meet the specified constraint, and the two satisfy the derived relationship. We then give validation requirements with theoretical guarantees for finite evaluation data, and further establish guarantees for the probability of a reliable update and the accumulation of gains throughout evolution.

As shown in the Supplementary Experiments section below, six of the first eight candidates improve overall validation performance, but Measured-margin supports reliable adoption of only one at a 90% confidence level. This illustrates the role of the requirements for reliable adoption in validating actual candidates. Compared with estimating only overall gain, separately analyzing repair gains and retained-task changes allows us to establish conditions for reliable self-evolution that specify both the repair contribution and control of performance changes on retained tasks, and to prove how these conditions jointly ensure overall improvement.


W2: The theoretical contribution needs clearer differentiation from existing safe-improvement results.

Response 2:

Thank you for raising this question. We study reliable harness self-evolution, focusing on theoretical guarantees for the reliable adoption of self-evolved modifications. Existing harness self-evolution research primarily focuses on evolution algorithms. A common practice is to construct a validation set by sampling tasks and decide whether to adopt a new version based on improvements in overall performance on that set. A systematic theoretical study of reliable harness self-evolution is still lacking.

HCPI[1] and TRPO[2] also study safe improvement, and we have discussed their high-level connection to our work in Related Work. Specifically, HCPI studies how existing interaction trajectories can be used to provide high-confidence guarantees on a candidate policy’s return, while TRPO studies how constraining changes between old and new policy distributions can support policy improvement. These works address policy improvement in reinforcement learning, a fundamentally different research problem from reliable adoption in harness self-evolution. Our theoretical analysis and conclusions are therefore not derived from existing safe-improvement results.

Regarding the performance ceiling, our theoretical analysis focuses on reliable self-evolution. Starting from a sufficient condition for reliable adoption, we provide a validation procedure with theoretical guarantees and analyze the resulting performance constraints on reliable self-evolution. Our analysis of the performance ceiling therefore concerns reliable self-evolution.

[1] High Confidence Policy Improvement.

[2] Trust Region Policy Optimization.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Sjc4 (Part 3/4)

W3: The practical cost and conservatism of the validation rules remain unclear. A comparison with directly testing a lower confidence bound on overall reward improvement is needed.

Response 3:

Thank you for your suggestions on validation cost and conservatism. We have added end-to-end self-evolution experiments comparing different validation rules at the same validation cost. Please see the Supplementary Experiments section below for the detailed settings and results. At an 80% confidence level, Two-Gate and Measured-margin identify one and three modifications, respectively, that can be reliably adopted. This shows that the validation requirements in our theoretical framework can be met in practical self-evolution and support actual updates. The results show that Two-Gate requires greater stability in retained-task performance, whereas Measured-margin supports a broader range of candidates while controlling decreases and ensuring overall improvement. Compared with Two-Gate, Measured-margin identifies more reliable updates.

We also computed the results of directly testing a confidence bound on overall gain: one candidate passed at 95% confidence and three passed at 80%. This direct test supports an increase in overall expected reward, but cannot by itself guarantee that repairs on failed tasks meet the specified requirement or that changes on retained tasks are controlled. Please see Response 1 for the detailed distinction between our conditions for reliable self-evolution and directly estimating overall improvement.


W4: The experiments mainly audit frozen candidates and do not sufficiently validate the framework end-to-end. Finding a useful rejected update does not show that the rules resolve stagnation. Multi-step experiments and evaluation cost analysis are needed.

Response 4:

Thank you for your suggestions on strengthening the experimental validation. We have added detailed end-to-end self-evolution experiments. Please see the Supplementary Experiments section below for the settings and results.

First, we would like to further clarify the goal of our stagnation analysis. Our contribution is primarily a theoretical analysis of the sources of stagnation in self-evolution, together with a statistical basis for studying these sources using additional experimental data under the stated conditions. The DS-1000 experiment is a concrete example of this analysis. This part of the work focuses on understanding the sources of stagnation, rather than proposing a general method for resolving it.

We added comparisons of validation rules and a complete multi-step evolution experiment on Terminal-Bench 2.1, using Terminus-2 as the initial agent and a current state-of-the-art method for generating modifications. After each adoption, the modified agent was used for task execution and modification generation in the next round. The per-step gain lower bounds for all three updates were positive and summed to 6.245 percentage points along the actual update sequence. Meanwhile, mean reward over the task population increased progressively from 78.89% to 87.78%. These results show that reliable adoption can be carried out over successive updates, with per-step gain lower bounds accumulating throughout evolution and overall task performance improving over time, demonstrating the feasibility of our theoretical framework.

Regarding the low adoption rate on DS-1000, the original experiment used a simple Python harness that made only one model call, with modifications generated directly or through a single revision based on feedback. In the supplementary experiments, we used Terminus-2 as the initial agent and a current state-of-the-art method for generating modifications, and the validation pass rate increased substantially. As shown in the Supplementary Experiments section below, at an 80% confidence level, Two-Gate and Measured-margin identify one and three reliably adoptable modifications, respectively, among eight candidates. These results show that our requirements for reliable adoption can be met in practical self-evolution and support actual updates; the low adoption rate in the original experiment is not an inherent limitation of the theoretical framework.

For validation cost, each round uses 60 validation records to evaluate 8 candidates and requires 1,680 task executions, including independent executions for failure labels and separate reward measurements. The average validation cost per round is approximately 552 million tokens.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.