- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4(+2)
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates reliable agent harness self-evolution, where agents modify prompts, tools, code, and workflows while keeping the underlying language model fixed. The authors establish a theoretical relationship between improvements on failed tasks and performance changes on previously successful tasks, derive sufficient conditions for reliable adoption, and propose two confidence-based validation rules, Two-Gate and Measured-Margin. The paper further analyzes candidate reachability, guarantees for progressive improvement, and verification costs, while introducing a framework to distinguish generation bottlenecks from validation bottlenecks. Experiments on DS-1000 illustrate how potentially beneficial modifications may be rejected due to insufficient validation evidence.
Critical strengths
The paper establishes sufficient conditions for reliable adoption by analyzing gains on failed tasks and performance changes on previously successful tasks. It further introduces statistically grounded validation rules and establishes cumulative improvement guarantees across multiple evolution steps.
The paper distinguishes actual improvement potential from performance ceilings imposed by validation rules and uses reachability analysis to identify generation and validation bottlenecks. The DS-1000 experiments also provide empirical evidence that insufficient validation evidence can prevent potentially beneficial modifications from being adopted.
Critical weaknesses
The experiments primarily use a confidence-interval-based screening procedure without directly comparing the proposed Two-Gate and Measured-Margin methods. Consequently, the practical benefits of these rules in actual self-evolution remain unclear.
The proposed validation mechanisms require extensive independent evaluations to control statistical uncertainty, while very few candidate modifications pass validation in the experiments. Although the paper analyzes theoretical verification costs, the practical trade-off between reliability and evaluation efficiency remains insufficiently demonstrated.
The reliable adoption condition requires gains on failed tasks to outweigh potential losses on retained tasks. However, the primary thresholds used in the DS-1000 experiments are not calibrated to this condition. Consequently, candidates meeting the experimental targets do not necessarily guarantee overall performance improvement, weakening the connection between the empirical analysis and the core theoretical framework.
Questions for authors
How does the validation procedure used in the DS-1000 experiments differ from the proposed Two-Gate and Measured-Margin rules? Can the authors clarify whether these rules would lead to different adoption decisions based on the existing experimental results?
Is the low validation acceptance rate primarily caused by large statistical uncertainty or by candidates failing to meet the required conditions? Would increasing the validation budget substantially improve this situation?
Why are the target thresholds in the DS-1000 experiments not directly aligned with the theoretical sufficient condition for reliable adoption? Based on the existing experimental data, would using theoretically calibrated thresholds substantially change the candidate qualification rates and stagnation diagnosis results?
6 comments
Response to Reviewer y8RD (Part 2/3)
W3 & Q3: Why are the target thresholds in the DS-1000 experiments not directly aligned with the theoretical sufficient condition for reliable adoption? Based on the existing experimental data, would theoretically calibrated thresholds substantially change candidate qualification rates and stagnation diagnosis results?
Response 3:
Thank you for pointing this out. We have recalculated the experimental results using the theoretical sufficient condition:
| Generation process | Estimated qualified candidates under the original target | Estimated qualified candidates under the sufficient condition |
|---|---|---|
| Independent generation | 37/96 | 8/96 |
| Label-free revision | 25/96 | 4/96 |
| Outcome-feedback revision | 33/96 | 14/96 |
The new results show that strictly applying this condition substantially reduces the candidate qualification rate, but they still support our conclusions from the stagnation analysis. We will update the relevant results and explanations in the final version of the paper.
Supplementary Experiments(Part 3/3)
1. Experimental Setup
We use Terminus-2[1] as the initial agent and keep the underlying model, deepseek-v4.1-flash-1017, fixed. We select 30 tasks from Terminal-Bench 2.1[1] and use the uniform distribution over these tasks as the user-task distribution. We use RRSI[2] to generate modifications: each generation batch contains 4 failed task and produces 8 candidate agents. The validation set contains 60 task records drawn independently from this distribution. For each record, the failure label is determined by an independent execution of the current agent; each agent performs 3 additional executions on the corresponding task to measure reward. We set the maximum allowed change on retained tasks to 0.15 and use a grid spacing of 0.005 for the Two-Gate parameters .
2. Experiment 1: Comparison of Validation Rules
| Confidence level | Two-Gate | Measured-margin |
|---|---|---|
| 99% | 0/8 | 0/8 |
| 95% | 0/8 | 1/8: N1 |
| 90% | 0/8 | 1/8: N1 |
| 80% | 1/8: N1 | 3/8: N1, N3, N7 |
| 70% | 1/8: N1 | 4/8: N1, N3, N4, N7 |
| 60% | 1/8: N1 | 5/8: N0, N1, N3, N4, N7 |
| 50% | 1/8: N1 | 6/8: N0, N1, N2, N3, N4, N7 |
As the baseline validation rule, we use a common approach in prior work: selecting candidates directly based on their overall performance on the validation set.
| Rule | Pass rate | Candidates |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline | 6/8 | N0, N1, N2, N3, N4, N7 |
3. Experiment 2: Multi-Step Self-Evolution
We conduct multi-step self-evolution using the Measured-margin validation rule at a confidence level of .
| Agent | Pass rate | Per-step gain lower bound (pp) | Mean reward (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| — | — | 78.89 | |
| 3/8 | +4.165 | 83.33 | |
| 1/8 | +1.808 | 85.56 | |
| 1/8 | +0.272 | 87.78 |
[1] Terminal-Bench: Benchmarking Agents on Hard, Realistic Tasks in Command Line Interfaces.
[2] RRSI: Regularized Recursive Self-Improvement of Agent Harnesses.
Response to Reviewer y8RD (Part 1/3)
W1 & Q1: How does the validation procedure used in the DS-1000 experiments differ from Two-Gate and Measured-Margin? Would these rules lead to different adoption decisions based on the existing experimental results?
Response 1:
Thank you for pointing out the difference between the validation procedure used in the DS-1000 experiments and our proposed rules. To simplify computation, the original experiments used binary task outcomes to calculate the repair proportion on failed tasks and the loss proportion on retained tasks. The corresponding confidence bounds were then compared with the prespecified targets. Two-Gate additionally requires a strictly positive lower bound on the overall expected-reward gain. Measured-margin directly uses a lower bound on the overall expected-reward gain to decide whether to adopt a candidate.
The DS-1000 experiments focus on understanding the sources of stagnation. We use additional evaluations to determine whether a candidate improves performance, then examine the original validation records to identify why it was not adopted. This simpler screening procedure therefore does not change the conclusion we draw from the example in the paper.
Following your suggestion, we also computed adoption decisions under both rules using the existing audit data from three independent runs:
These results show that changing the validation rule affects the adoption rate. In particular, no candidate passed Two-Gate validation and was adopted in this experiment. Our analysis shows that this is due to the base agent's limited capacity for self-evolution, rather than overly stringent theoretical requirements. Please see our response to W2 & Q2 for the detailed analysis and supplementary experiments. We will add an explanation of the validation procedure and these comparison results to the final version of the paper.
W2 & Q2: Is the low validation acceptance rate primarily caused by large statistical uncertainty or by candidates failing to meet the required conditions? Would increasing the validation budget substantially improve this situation? What is the practical trade-off between reliability and evaluation efficiency?
Response 2:
Thank you for your suggestion. Our analysis shows that DS-1000's low adoption rate mainly results from limitations in the initial agent's capacity for self-evolution and the modification generation method, rather than overly stringent theoretical requirements. The initial agent in the original experiment used a simple Python harness that made only one model call. The self-evolution process used basic strategies: direct candidate generation or a single revision based on feedback. In the repeated evaluations, 191 of the 286 valid candidates had an estimated failure-task contribution below the original prespecified target.
We have added experiments on Terminal-Bench 2.1 using Terminus-2 as the initial agent and a state-of-the-art method for generating modifications. Please see the Supplementary Experiments section below for the detailed settings and results. At an 80% confidence level, Two-Gate and Measured-margin supported reliable adoption of one and three of the eight candidates, respectively. These results show that the validation rules in our theoretical framework achieve acceptable adoption rates in practice and can support actual updates while meeting the reliability requirements.
Our experiments also show that increasing the validation budget can improve the validation pass rate. In the original DS-1000 experiment, we compared validation budgets of 8 and 48 tasks on the same candidates. The number of candidates passing validation increased from 0 to 2. This observation is consistent with our theoretical analysis: additional evaluation can reduce statistical uncertainty and provide the evidence needed to validate existing improvements. Thus, improving candidate generation and increasing the validation budget affect different stages, and both influence the adoption rate in reliable self-evolution. We will include these experimental results and analyses in the final version of the paper.