- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes that theta sweeps accelerate sensory-map learning by associating the animal’s current observation with internally represented nearby locations. It combines an established direction/grid-cell sweep mechanism with recurrent hippocampal populations and a plastic hippocampal-to-sensory readout. In simulated spatially smooth environments, the sweep-enabled model learns more accurate sensory predictions than its no-sweep counterpart and an adapted Vector-HaSH baseline, including at unvisited locations. Ablations examine multiple spatial scales and hippocampal recurrence. Parameter scans show that broader sensory correlations favor longer optimal sweeps, while a prescribed reduction in theta modulation illustrates a tradeoff between rapid early generalization and later accuracy. The principal contribution is a functional account of sensory broadcasting and its limitations, supported by simulations, but network-compatible mechanisms of theta strength annealing and sensory correlation dependent adaptation are not within the scope of this work.
Critical strengths
The paper provides a useful account of how internally generated spatial activity could support sensory generalization. Extending prior sweep-based learning of spatial connectivity (Marshall et al., 2025; Ji et al., 2026) to sensory-content associations exposes a consequential tradeoff: longer sweeps reaches more and locations farther away, but risk associating observations with locations whose sensory content differs. Further experiments connect the optimal sweep span to sensory correlation width, and illustrates a benefit from reducing broadcasting later in learning. These results are mostly well-validated and add a specific computational explanation beyond the general proposition that sweeps facilitate map formation.
Critical weaknesses
The attribution of improved learning to spatial-scale diversity is confounded by model capacity. Figure 4a,b compares 6,400 hippocampal cells in M1 with 32,000 cells across five populations (Appendix B.5), changing the number of trainable readout weights and the populations entering normalization along with scale and sweep diversity. The result therefore establishes an advantage of the full configuration, but does not isolate the contribution of diverse scales. This limits an important mechanistic interpretation of the architecture; a capacity-matched comparison would make that attribution more convincing.
The annealing result has limited validation relative to its familiarity-based interpretation. Figure 5 uses a prescribed elapsed-time schedule on one 4,000 s trajectory, with a shared learning coefficient rather than independently tuned fixed-modulation controls. Figure 7d also shows that sustained full modulation remains beneficial at persistently unvisited locations. The experiment supports a possible benefit from reducing broadcasting, but leaves unclear how robust that benefit is to exploration history and baseline tuning. This matters because familiarity-dependent sweep shortening is one of the paper’s three central predictions. A biological familiarity controller would be a valuable extension, but its implementation is not necessary to establish the narrower functional result.
Questions for authors
Major questions: please see criticial weaknesses.
Minor issues/clarifications:
- In figure 3(c) caption, “Under the same exploration trajectory” followed by “mean ± SD over three trajectories” is a little confusing, can the authors clarify?
- Spatial units vary: metres in 2c, “world units” in 2d, unspecified units in 2e, and normalized coordinates in 3d, is it feasible to conform the use of units?
- In line 21 (abstract) and line 466 (discussion), what does independent mean? The modules share a theta clock and movement inputs. “Module-specific sweeps with different directions and extents” may describe the demonstrated result more precisely.
- In section 4.3, lines 409–412, the manipulated theta parameter controls anchoring modulation strength, whereas the biological comparison concerns LFP theta power, can the authors make this clear?
- “sweep length” vs. “sweep span”, can the authors use a brief definition in the caption to avoid ambiguity in figure 6?
- “we add global inhibition to presynaptic input” — line 206. Equation 2 instead expresses inhibition through divisive firing-rate normalization, can the authors make it clearer in the text?
8 comments
Response to Reviewer 5BNv (Part II)
W2. How robust is the benefit of theta annealing?
The annealing result has limited validation relative to its familiarity-based interpretation. Figure 5 uses a prescribed elapsed-time schedule on one 4,000 s trajectory, with a shared learning coefficient rather than independently tuned fixed-modulation controls. Figure 7d also shows that sustained full modulation remains beneficial at persistently unvisited locations. The experiment supports a possible benefit from reducing broadcasting, but leaves unclear how robust that benefit is to exploration history and baseline tuning. This matters because familiarity-dependent sweep shortening is one of the paper’s three central predictions. A biological familiarity controller would be a valuable extension, but its implementation is not necessary to establish the narrower functional result.
Thank you for this insightful critique. To rigorously evaluate the robustness of theta annealing against exploration history and baseline hyperparameter tuning, we repeated the 4,000-s experiment across 10 independent trajectories while using independently optimized learning coefficients for each fixed-modulation baseline.
- Consistent advantage across trajectories: Across all 10 independent 4,000-s trajectories (where all three conditions followed the exact same path and received identical sensory observations within each replicate), annealing achieved the lowest final all-position prediction error on every single trajectory. The mean relative prediction error at 4,000 s was 0.244 ± 0.003 for annealing, compared with 0.271 ± 0.003 for fixed zero modulation and 0.376 ± 0.004 for fixed full modulation (mean ± SD across 10 trajectories).
- Independent selection of learning coefficients: You are right that the original Fig. 5 used a shared learning coefficient (). In our original parameter sweep (evaluating 15 candidate coefficients per condition to minimize mean 400-s error across three validation trajectories; Appendix C, Fig. 7a), the optimal learning coefficients were 0.1486 for fixed zero modulation and 0.5384 for fixed full modulation. In the revised Fig. 5, each fixed-modulation baseline uses its own dedicated optimal coefficient throughout the 4,000-s run. For the annealing schedule, each stage’s learning coefficient was tuned on a separate 4,000-s development trajectory (carrying learned weights and network states across stages) and fixed prior to testing on the 10 evaluation trajectories.
- Trade-off at persistently unvisited vs. visited locations: We fully agree with your interpretation of Fig. 7d, and we have highlighted this mechanistic trade-off in the revised text. At persistently unvisited locations, sustained full modulation outperforms annealing (0.816 ± 0.008 vs. 0.884 ± 0.008) because long sweeps continue broadcasting sensory information from the path into unexplored regions. Conversely, at visited locations, repeated visits allow the animal to refine its sensory associations; shortening the sweeps localizes updates to the animal's true position, enabling annealing to achieve dramatically lower error than full modulation (0.068 ± 0.001 vs. 0.255 ± 0.003). Because visited locations cover 78.4% of the arena by 4,000 s, this substantial gain over familiar territory drives the lower overall error.
- Candidate biological familiarity signal: We also appreciate your perspective on biological implementation. One possible plausible feedback signal might be sensory prediction error: in the hippocampal circuit model of Chen et al. (2024), CA3 predicts upcoming entorhinal inputs while CA1 computes the mismatch upon arrival. Large mismatches in novel environments could sustain strong theta modulation (and long sweeps), whereas declining prediction error with familiarity could down-regulate modulation and shorten sweeps. We have added this discussion to Section 5 as a concrete direction for future closed-loop modeling.
Q1. How are trajectories matched and averaged in Fig. 3c?
In figure 3(c) caption, “Under the same exploration trajectory” followed by “mean ± SD over three trajectories” is a little confusing, can the authors clarify?
Thank you for catching this ambiguity. Within each replicate, all models followed the exact same physical trajectory and received identical sensory observations; across the three replicates, three distinct trajectories were used. For each trajectory, we first averaged the relative prediction error across all spatial query locations at each time point, and Fig. 3c plots the mean ± 1 SD across the three resulting trajectory-level error curves. We have clarified this wording in the Fig. 3c caption (and noted in the Fig. 5a,c captions that the late-stage SD shading is narrower than the plotted line width).
Response to Reviewer 5BNv (Part III)
Q2. Can spatial units be standardized?
Spatial units vary: metres in 2c, “world units” in 2d, unspecified units in 2e, and normalized coordinates in 3d, is it feasible to conform the use of units?
Yes. We have standardized all spatial measurements across the manuscript and figures: positions, tuning widths, and sweep lengths are now consistently reported in metres (), and running speeds in metres per second (). We updated the axes and captions of Figs. 2c–e, 3d, and 6b–d, as well as all corresponding supplementary figures (with phase in radians and preferred direction in degrees).
Q3. What does “independent” mean for modules that share a theta clock?
In line 21 (abstract) and line 466 (discussion), what does independent mean? The modules share a theta clock and movement inputs. “Module-specific sweeps with different directions and extents” may describe the demonstrated result more precisely.
Thank you for suggesting this much more accurate phrasing. Because all modules share a common 10 Hz theta clock as well as common velocity and heading inputs, their sweeps are indeed coupled to the same global rhythm while diverging in trajectory due to each module’s own attractor state, adaptation dynamics, and spatial scale. We have replaced “independent” with your exact suggested phrasing—“module-specific sweeps with different directions and spatial extents”—in the Abstract and aligned the Discussion accordingly.
Q4. How does the model’s modulation parameter relate to LFP theta power?
In section 4.3, lines 409–412, the manipulated theta parameter controls anchoring modulation strength, whereas the biological comparison concerns LFP theta power, can the authors make this clear?
Thank you for pointing out the need to distinguish our model parameter from experimental LFP recordings. In our model, controls the modulation depth of the external anchoring inputs (position and heading cues) across each theta cycle, varying their gain between and . When , anchoring remains constant; when , anchoring drops to zero at the trough of the theta cycle, freeing the activity bump to sweep outward before being pulled back.
By contrast, Penley et al. (2013) measured local field potential (LFP) theta power in CA1 and the dentate gyrus, reporting elevated theta power during novel-environment exploration. Our hypothesis links the two by proposing that stronger population theta oscillations (higher LFP theta power) reflect deeper rhythmic modulation of the inputs anchoring hippocampal activity, thereby enabling longer sweeps. Directly testing this quantitative link will require simultaneous recordings of LFP theta power, anchoring input strength, and sweep length.
Q5. How is sweep length defined?
“sweep length” vs. “sweep span”, can the authors use a brief definition in the caption to avoid ambiguity in figure 6?
We now use “sweep length” consistently throughout the paper. Specifically, within each complete 0.1-s theta cycle, we express the decoded position relative to the animal’s instantaneous position and compute the maximum Euclidean distance between any two points along that relative trajectory, averaging this distance across complete cycles. We have added this concise definition to the Fig. 6 caption and provided the full mathematical estimator in Appendix B.3.
Q6. How is global inhibition implemented in Eq. 2?
“we add global inhibition to presynaptic input” — line 206. Equation 2 instead expresses inhibition through divisive firing-rate normalization, can the authors make it clearer in the text?
Thank you for catching this discrepancy between the text and Eq. 2. You are completely right: rather than subtractive inhibition on presynaptic inputs, our circuit implements divisive firing-rate normalization within each place-cell population, where each cell’s squared, rectified input is divided by the summed squared, rectified inputs across all cells in that population. We have corrected Section 3.1 to state this explicitly and cited the continuous-attractor models from which this normalization formulation is adapted (Wu et al., 2008; Fung et al., 2008).
Thank you once again for your constructive guidance, your suggestion of the capacity-matched control, and your insightful analysis of the spatial trade-off in theta annealing. We hope that these new experiments, statistical analyses, and textual clarifications fully address all of your concerns. If so, we would be very grateful if you would consider raising your score.
Response to Reviewer 5BNv (Part I)
Thank you very much for your thoughtful, thorough review and for recognizing the core computational trade-off between generalizing to unexplored space and refining predictions along familiar paths. Your insightful suggestions—particularly regarding the capacity-matched control, trajectory-replicated and independently tuned annealing experiments, and terminological precision—have substantially strengthened the mechanistic clarity and rigor of our manuscript. We address each of your points in detail below.
W1. Does the multiscale advantage persist at matched capacity?
Yes—the advantage of spatial-scale diversity persists with high statistical significance when network capacity is strictly matched.
Thank you for pointing out that our original comparison varied both spatial scale and the total number of hippocampal cells. Following your suggestion, we replaced the single-module baseline in Fig. 4a with a capacity-matched single-scale control consisting of five populations that all share the spatial scale of M1. Both the single-scale control and the multiscale model now have:
Across 10 matched trajectories, the multiscale model still achieved a substantially lower all-position prediction error at 400 s than the capacity-matched single-scale control (0.509 ± 0.008 vs. 0.653 ± 0.010, mean ± SD; two-sided paired t(9)=−49.78, p=2.67×10−12). We have updated Fig. 4a with these capacity-matched learning curves and included Fig. 4b to illustrate the spatial coverage of M1 compared with the combined five-module population across ten trajectories (mean ± SD).