- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1(−1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper provides a graph merging method for multimodal graphs. By selecting landmarks as reference points, it constructs node representations using similarities between each node and its intra-graph landmarks, together with a cross-graph landmark similarity tensor. It then uses optimal transport to add cross-graph edges wherever the corresponding entries in the transport plan are nonzero. The resulting merged graph retains the original nodes and edges and is used for downstream classification.
Critical strengths
- The paper explicitly constructs sparse cross-graph edges, enabling information exchange between modalities during message passing without requiring node-level correspondence labels.
- Experiments cover medical and remote-sensing tasks, with strong three-modality results among the evaluated baselines. Component ablations provide supporting evidence for the contributions of multiway landmark context and optimal transport.
Critical weaknesses
- It is unclear how the self-supervised encoder establishes a common coordinate system. Particularly in Eq. 9, the representations of the two graphs are indexed by different landmark sets.
- On TCGA-BRCA the method does not provide an explicit description on how to create initial graphs, including node definitions, features, edge-construction rules, and distance metrics.
- Uniform transport marginals require every node to participate in cross-modal connections, but some nodes may have no meaningful counterpart in another modality, whether it can introduce uninformative edge remains unclear
- Figure 1 is too abstract to clarify how node features become landmark fingerprints, transport plans, and final cross-graph edges. Several mathematical constructions precede their intuitive motivation, making the method difficult to follow.
Questions for authors
- How is GraphMAE trained across modalities, and what ensures that its output coordinates are comparable? In Eq. (9), how are distances computed between representations indexed by different landmark sets? How are unequal landmark counts handled?
- For TCGA-BRCA, what exactly do nodes and edges represent in each modality graph? Could the authors specify the node features, preprocessing, graph-construction metrics, and downstream GNN architecture?
- What motivates uniform, balanced transport when modalities may contain unmatched or modality-specific information? Have the authors considered partial or unbalanced transport?
- The “No OT” ablation uses greedy kNN. How is k selected, and how do its edge counts compare with those produced by EMD? Does the benefit of OT persist when the methods use comparable edge budgets?
- How many landmarks are used per modality, how are these counts selected, and do the reported repetitions include independent landmark sampling?