- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Paper proposes PHASE, a neural operator for 2D incompressible magnetohydrodynamics that is a parameter-conditioned MHD operator.
Critical strengths
-
Improvements in the prediction of magnetic-field and current-density quantities.
-
Generalizes across multiple Reynolds-number regimes due to parameter conditioning.
Critical weaknesses
-
Generalization to unseen parameter regimes is evaluated at only one point, Re=800, which was used during training.
-
Limited to 2D flows, weak magnetic fields, and relatively low Re=Rm.
-
Multiple physics components were combined, obscuring their relative benefits.
-
Baselines are not directly comparable in terms of the training set, pretraining procedure, and computational budget. The baseline comparison is limited and does not include recent advances in neural operators, such as Transolver, Latent Mamba Operator, etc. Consider citing these recent works and including them as baselines with parameter conditioning.
Questions for authors
-
Both the adapter up-projection and the gate’s final layer are initialized to zero, which would block gradient flow through the gated update. Is this intentional??
-
How would a parameter-conditioned variant of DINO perform on the same multi-regime training distribution? Can you extend a similar setup to baselines based on Transolver and Latent Mamba Operator??
-
Would the method generalize to other unseen Reynolds numbers, especially those outside the training distribution? If not, consider adding limitations.
-
Can you evaluate the impact of each physics component independently (e.g., direct B prediction, Helmholtz projection, and derivative losses)?
-
What is the computational overhead of the diffusion step, and does it contribute to the spectral power discrepancy? Also, can you compare it against [3]? A comparison of computational overhead with Transolver and Latent Mamba Operator would be useful to see whether we really need a diffusion backbone.
-
Limited Novelty.
Reference:
-
Wu, Haixu, et al. "Transolver: A fast transformer solver for pdes on general geometries." arXiv preprint arXiv:2402.02366 (2024).
-
Tiwari, Karn, Niladri Dutta, and N. M. Krishnan. "Latent mamba operator for partial differential equations." arXiv preprint arXiv:2505.19105 (2025).
-
Lippe, Phillip, et al. "Pde-refiner: Achieving accurate long rollouts with neural pde solvers." Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 36 (2023): 67398-67433.
2 comments
Thank you for the rebuttal. I will maintain my score.
Response to reviewer sgm9
We thank the reviewer for recognizing PHASE's gains in PDE prediction and cross-regime modeling. We address their concerns below.
1. Generalization and physical scope
We first clarify that Re=800 was not used in training. The MR training set is {80,200,400,650,1000,1500,2050,2750,3600,4500}. We now additionally test generalization at unseen Re=1200 and out-of-range Re=60,6000, with no fine-tuning.
These results are shown in Fig. 5, Tab. 4, and App. A.7.
We agree that 3-D remains a limitation. The main study follows prior 2-D incompressible MHD work with Pm=1. To broaden the scope, we added a strong-field, non-unity-Pm case: Re=400, Rm=4000, Pm=10, Emag/Ekin=0.5. PHASE reaches aggregate primary/derived errors of 0.20/0.38 and accurately captures the magnetically dominated evolution (App. A.9; Figs. 20$-$22).
2. Isolating the physics components
Fig. 2 and App. A.3 now isolate the individual physics additions:
The full ablation also isolates transfer learning, naive conditioning, gated adapters, and diffusion.
3. Baselines and comparability
As explained in our general response above, our goal is not a generic neural-operator benchmark but an AI-for-Science study for MHD. We therefore use tFNO-MHD (Rosofsky & Huerta, 2023) and DINO (Kacmaz, Huerta & Haas, 2025), the two directly comparable prior methods for the same 2-D incompressible MHD equations and DNS setting.
All models use DNS trajectories from the same Dedalus configuration, resolution, and temporal sampling. App. A.3 now reports splits, initialization/pretraining, and model sizes.
Thus the gains are not explained by scale alone: DINO and PHASE have nearly identical total size, and their deterministic backbones are also comparable. Sec. 2 now additionally discusses Transolver, Latent Mamba Operator, PDE-Refiner, and recent MHD surrogates; parameter-conditioned MHD versions of these are valuable future work, but constitute a separate architecture-benchmarking study.
4. Adapter initialization
The implementation is correct; the original appendix didn't explicitly state the identity offset. The actual update is
hℓ+=hℓ+αℓgℓ(Φ)⊙Eℓ(hℓ),
where gℓ(Φ)=1+MLP(Φ) and αℓ=1. Zero initialization of the gate MLP gives gℓ=1, not zero, so the adapter up-projection receives nonzero gradients immediately; after it becomes nonzero, gradients reach the gate and down-projection. App. A.6.2 now state this explicitly.
The referred code in the text already contained the low level details:
ReResidualAdapter, lines 70--141.5. Diffusion cost and spectral tradeoff
Diffusion increases PHASE training cost to about 1.8$\times$ that of scOT alone and inference cost by about 50$\times$, while reducing aggregate prediction error by roughly 33%.
At Re=Rm=1000:
Diffusion improves pointwise error and low-k large/intermediate-scale accuracy, where MR PHASE is best across all fields. However, MR scOT is much better in the high-k tail. Residual diffusion recovers unresolved structures while injecting excess small-scale spectral power. We now state this limitation explicitly in App. A.7.2 and Tab. 5.
6. Novelty
PHASE's novelty is the MHD-specific integration of cross-physics transfer, parameter-conditioned multi-regime adaptation, direct magnetic-field prediction, hard physical constraints, derived-field supervision, and residual correction. This combination substantially advances prior 2-D incompressible MHD surrogates and extends evaluation from decaying turbulence to instability-driven dynamics. See also our the general reply.