- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a bidirectional self-distillation framework, BEAD, for multi-round agent reinforcement learning. This method first extracts tool contracts from the environment implementation and builds enhanced feedback for rejected tool calls. These enhanced feedbacks are generated in the offline stage and can be reused between tasks and trajectories that trigger the same rejection pattern. Subsequently, BEAD uses the enhanced feedback for bidirectional teacher scoring: the reverse scoring provides post-event information on the rejected actions, while the forward scoring evaluates the subsequent recovery actions. The resulting token-level log probability gap is used to reweight the original reinforcement learning advantage value without changing its sign.
Critical strengths
- An effective method for constructing reusable supervision from the environment.
- Achieve continuous experimental improvement through detailed analysis.
Critical weaknesses
- The contributions of environmental enhancement and bidirectional scoring are not completely independent.
- The efficiency advantages and differences from related self-distillation methods still require more evidence.
Questions for authors
Q1. Contribution of Environment Augmentation.
Can the author conduct an ablation experiment on the complete two-way BEAD framework solely using the original rejection feedback without resorting to environmental enhancement? Additionally, what impact will removing the usefulness filtering based on replay have on performance? These comparisons will help distinguish the respective contributions of the extracted tool contracts and the feedback selection process.
Q2. Backward Correction and Advantage Reweighting.
Equation (8) maintains the original RL advantage's sign. Therefore, even if the backward teacher assigns negative context influence scores, the rejected actions with positive trajectory advantages will still receive positive updates. Has the author analyzed how backward scoring affects rejected actions under positive and negative advantages separately? Such analysis will help clarify the actual correction mechanism.
Q3. Computational Efficiency and Reusability.
Compared to the standard GRPO and self-distillation baselines, how much wall time and computational cost does BEAD require additionally? Can the author separately report the offline costs of contract generation, verification, and replay checks, excluding the overhead of online teacher scoring? Since reusable feedback is the core motivation, analyzing the depreciation cost of training trajectories will be particularly beneficial.
Q4. Comparison with Related Methods.
Can the author further clarify the differences between its approach and HINT-SD [1] and AHEAD [2], especially in terms of the source and reuse of privileged contexts and the resulting credit allocation mechanism? If feasible, conducting matching comparisons will help strengthen the assessment of novelty.
References
[1] Yeo et al., "HINT-SD: Targeted Hindsight Self-Distillation for Long-Horizon Agents." 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.17873
[2] Jin et al., "AHEAD: Adaptive Hindsight with Environment-Augmented Distillation for Agentic RL." 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.24114
4 comments
Response to Reviewer uKMS: Part 2
Q2 Backward Correction and Advantage Reweighting. Equation (8) maintains the original RL advantage's sign. Therefore, even if the backward teacher assigns negative context influence scores, the rejected actions with positive trajectory advantages will still receive positive updates. Has the author analyzed how backward scoring affects rejected actions under positive and negative advantages separately? Such analysis will help clarify the actual correction mechanism.
The advantage reweighting in Eq. (8) follows the direction-aware credit assignment in RLSD [1], where the environment reward determines the update direction and the privileged teacher adjusts its token-level magnitude. A positive advantage trajectory may still contain rejected tool calls. When backward scoring produces a negative log-probability gap , Eq. (8) attenuates positive updates for and amplifies negative penalties for , without reversing the original update direction.
To examine these effects separately, we recorded backward-scored rejected calls during training and divided them into positive and negative advantage groups. For each rejected call, we compute , the mean effective advantage multiplier over its action tokens, where . The results are shown below.
| Backward-scored rejected calls | ||
|---|---|---|
| Fraction of calls with | 82.1% | 18.9% |
| Fraction of calls with | 17.6% | 80.8% |
For rejected calls with positive advantages, 82.1% receive attenuated positive reinforcement, whereas for those with negative advantages, 80.8% receive amplified negative penalties. These findings are consistent with the predominantly corrective backward teacher signals observed in Figure 4(b).
These results clarify that BEAD's backward scoring does not directly assign negative advantages to rejected actions. Instead, it uses backward teacher evidence to adjust the magnitude of RL updates while preserving the update direction determined by the environment reward. For rejected calls with positive advantages, backward scoring predominantly attenuates positive reinforcement, whereas for those with negative advantages, it predominantly amplifies negative penalties.
Reference
[1] Chenxu Yang et al. Self-distilled RLVR. arXiv preprint arXiv:2604.03128, 2026.
Response to Reviewer uKMS: Part 3
Q4 Comparison with Related Methods. Can the author further clarify the differences between its approach and HINT-SD and AHEAD, especially in terms of the source and reuse of privileged contexts and the resulting credit allocation mechanism? If feasible, conducting matching comparisons will help strengthen the assessment of novelty.
Thank you for highlighting these related works. AHEAD[1] and HINT-SD[2] are concurrent works on self-distillation, both cited in our Introduction. Both demonstrate the value of hindsight-based self-distillation for fine-grained credit assignment. However, their corrective annotations are constructed for individual training trajectories. HINT-SD analyzes complete failed trajectories to identify actions related to the failure and generate targeted feedback, while AHEAD combines environment observations with corrective hints generated by an LLM for identified error steps. Such hindsight information is tied to the particular trajectory and requires repeated generation as new failures arise during training.
Regarding matched experiments, we could not find a publicly available training implementation of AHEAD. We reproduced HINT-SD using its released implementation to train Qwen3-4B in thinking mode on the same BFCL v4 training split used for BEAD. As shown in the table below, HINT-SD yielded modest gains over the vanilla model in this setting.
| Method | BFCL v4 (ID) Avg. (%) | BFCL v4 (OOD) Avg. (%) |
|---|---|---|
| Vanilla | 33.67 | 19.16 |
| HINT-SD | 37.33 (+3.66) | 20.17 (+1.01) |
| BEAD | 51.56 (+17.89) | 27.94 (+8.78) |
BEAD addresses a complementary but previously overlooked source of supervision in tool-use environments, namely the underlying tool contracts. A rejected tool call reflects a violation of environment-defined constraints, such as parameter domains, value provenance, or state preconditions. Unlike trajectory-specific corrective hints, these constraints describe how tools operate and remain valid across different tasks and trajectories. BEAD therefore mines and validates these contracts offline, constructing reusable augmentations associated with rejection signatures rather than generating new explanations for individual failures.
This difference in supervision source also enables a distinct credit allocation mechanism. BEAD uses the same augmentation derived from tool contracts bidirectionally. Backward scoring provides hindsight correction for the rejected call, while forward scoring evaluates the subsequent action to guide recovery. In this way, BEAD provides complementary supervision for both the decision that violated the tool contract and the subsequent attempt to recover, using a shared, reusable environment-grounded signal.
The reuse of augmentations across tasks and trajectories is supported by our analysis in Figure 4(a). Moreover, as detailed in our response to Reviewer VpFC's W2, our analysis of construction costs estimates approximately $1,583.07 and 49 hours for online trajectory-specific annotation, compared with $6.97 and 12.3 minutes for BEAD's one-time offline generation. This highlights the efficiency of BEAD's offline construction in substantially reducing the cost of privileged-context generation.
Reference
[1] Jin et al., AHEAD: Adaptive Hindsight with Environment-Augmented Distillation for Agentic RL. arXiv preprint arXiv:2608.24114, 2026.
[2] Yeo et al., HINT-SD: Targeted Hindsight Self-Distillation for Long-Horizon Agents. arXiv preprint arXiv:2605.17873, 2026.
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. The responses have adequately addressed my concerns.
Response to Reviewer uKMS: Part 1
Thank you for this suggestion. We conducted the requested ablations on BFCL v4 with Qwen3-4B. The ablations for environment augmentation and scoring directions are already reported in Table 3 of our paper, and we additionally conducted an experiment removing the replay check.
Removing environment augmentation has a particular consequence for bidirectional scoring. Without augmentation, the teacher and student have identical contexts for forward scoring, resulting in a zero log-probability gap and no additional supervision. Backward scoring remains applicable because the original rejection feedback can still serve as hindsight for the rejected action. Therefore, the variant without augmentation effectively retains only backward scoring.
The results are shown below.
These results show that contract-derived augmentation provides substantial additional supervision beyond the original rejection feedback, even under the same backward-only setting. In contrast, removing the replay check has little impact on performance, suggesting that the preceding generation and validation stages already produce useful augmentations. The replay check therefore serves mainly as an additional quality gate rather than the primary source of performance improvement.
Thank you for your question. We use Skill-SD as a representative self-distillation baseline and report the average wall-clock time per training step below.
The additional online computation mainly comes from teacher log-probability computation. Rollout dominates RL training time in our setting, so this additional computation accounts for a relatively small fraction of the total runtime. When rollout and training are pipelined across separate machines, teacher scoring can overlap with subsequent rollouts, further reducing the added wall-clock overhead.
We also separately report the offline construction costs, excluding online teacher scoring.
These costs are incurred only once before RL training. The resulting augmentations are reusable across tasks and trajectories, allowing the fixed offline construction cost to be amortized over an increasing number of training trajectories without repeated generation or verification.