- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a closed-loop, encoder-side optimization approach for generative image compression. The key idea is to make the encoder revise its compression scheme by observing provisional reconstructions from a fixed decoder. First, the input image is divided into regions, and regional compression-tier updates are proposed based on regional importance, codec error, and generative recovery; whether to accept each update is then decided iteratively based on provisional reconstructions from the decoder and their rate cost. Second, the codec and generative reconstructions are combined with regional mixing weights, which are selected at the encoder and transmitted. The system builds on DLF as a fixed base codec, followed by BAGEL, a fine-tuned large generative model used as a generative enhancer. The method is compared with several generative codecs, including DLF, on CLIC 2020 and DIV2K using PSNR, MS-SSIM, DISTS, TOPIQ-FR, MS-SWD, and FID.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
W1: Recent generative codecs already train the encoder jointly with a pretrained generative model (e.g., using LoRA adapters) and achieve strong performance without particular difficulty [1–3]. In contrast, this paper keeps the encoder fixed and optimizes only the coding scheme by running the generative decoder repeatedly at the encoder side. This approach clearly increases encoder-side complexity. However, it is not clear what advantage this approach offers over joint training that would justify this cost. Therefore, the proposed approach is difficult to view as a significant contribution.
W2: It is unclear what significant advance the proposed method achieves over existing work. In the ablation (Fig. 5), removing each component changes DISTS only marginally (e.g., by 0.001–0.003 for the feedback-based scheme revision). Compared with DLF, the method also shows similar DISTS and FID around 0.01 bpp, despite using a high-complexity generative model (Fig. 3). In addition, all experiments are conducted only on a single combination of models (DLF + BAGEL), so it is unclear whether the proposed approach generalizes to other codecs or generative models.
References
[1] T. Zhang, X. Luo, L. Li, and D. Liu. StableCodec: Taming one-step diffusion for extreme image compression. In ICCV, 2025.
[2] N. Xue, Z. Jia, J. Li, B. Li, Y. Zhang, and Y. Lu. One-step diffusion-based image compression with semantic distillation (OneDC). In NeurIPS, 2025.
[3] T. Zhang, D. Liu, and C. W. Chen. Ultra-low bitrate perceptual image compression with shallow encoder (AEIC). In CVPR, pp. 12118–12128, 2026.
Questions for authors
Given the current manuscript, I do not have questions whose answers could materially change my assessment. The critical weaknesses (W1 and W2) would require additional comparisons and analyses beyond what can be clarified in a rebuttal.
Nevertheless, I believe the core idea of encoder-side optimization itself, which allocates fewer bits where the generative decoder already reconstructs well and more bits where it does not, can be a meaningful research direction. If its advantage over joint training is clearly shown, and the approach is validated beyond a single combination of codec and generative model, this work could develop into a stronger paper.