acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Elastic Prediction from the First Time-Step: Spiking Neural Networks with Temporal Membrane Biasing

Abstract

Spiking neural networks (SNNs) naturally support elastic inference, where salient inputs trigger early predictions, and additional time-steps progressively refine the output, enabling fast responses and improved accuracy without repeated inference or model retraining. However, existing SNN methods are not well-suited for elastic inference: ANN-to-SNN conversion methods suffer from poor early-time-step accuracy, whereas directly trained SNNs perform well at specific time-steps but often degrade when inference continues, limiting the accuracy refinement. In this work, we identify the root cause of the early-stage performance degradation as a *membrane-threshold mismatch* between membrane potentials and firing thresholds. To mitigate this mismatch, we propose a temporal membrane biasing (TMB) method that applies sustained calibration across time-steps while preserving Quantized Artificial Neural Network (QANN) equivalence. In addition, we develop a bias-only fine-tuning strategy that enables efficient optimization with minimal training cost. Across multiple tasks, our work markedly improves low time-step accuracy (*e.g.,* 70.15% top-1 accuracy improvement at the first time-step on ImageNet). Combining elastic inference and adaptive methods, TMB achieves 24.3% operation and 24.8% time-step reduction with % accuracy degradation compared to the same SNN without TMB.

Primary area:
other topics in machine learning (i.e., none of the above)
Keywords:
Spiking Neural Network, Elastic Inference, Accuracy-Operation Trade-off

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_kGZoOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper focuses on the hybrid training of Spiking Neural Networks (SNNs). The SNNs are initially obtained via conversion, and a unique bias is applied at each time step to mitigate what the authors term a "membrane-threshold mismatch." The authors provide an analysis of how this mitigation is achieved. Experimental results indicate that the proposed method enables the network to perform similarly during both early and late stages of the inference process.

Critical strengths

Strengths: Addressing the performance of SNNs in practical applications is an important endeavor. The opening figure effectively illustrates the potential application of SNNs in autonomous driving.

Critical weaknesses

Weaknesses: A compelling question—perhaps one the authors have not yet considered—is this: if a model can indeed perform well from the very first time step, why not simply use a binary or ternary neural network instead? Furthermore, if high performance is achieved within the first few time steps, what is the practical utility of the subsequent inference time? This is a fundamental question that should have been addressed during the initial design phase of the research.

Initially, based on the abstract, I assumed this was a paper about SNN conversion—a topic that would be quite significant, as it would obviate the need for post-conversion training. However, upon reading the full paper, I discovered it actually concerns "hybrid learning." Consequently, I believe the benchmarks used for comparison are either unfair or inadequately labeled.

A primary reason for my rejection recommendation: The paper states, "For the first time, we define and systematically analyze the 'membrane-threshold mismatch' in SNN inference systems, which hampers the usefulness of elastic inference." A quick query via a tool like Google AI (accessible to everyone) regarding whether the "membrane-threshold mismatch" in SNN inference has been analyzed yields an affirmative answer. I am curious as to why the authors chose to make this claim. I strongly advise removing phrases like "for the first time." Instead, clearly articulate the scope, objectives, and rationale of your work. This is far more valuable than dismissively ignoring the existing literature.

Questions for authors

Questions:

  1. Regarding the abstract (line 28): You mention issues related to both conversion and direct training, then immediately transition to the "root cause of early-stage performance." Does this "root cause" refer to conversion, direct training, or both? Additionally, the text does not explicitly state that the "temporal bias" is trainable, which could be misleading to readers.

  2. Is the component on the left side of Figure 1 the source ANN? Why does the SNN on the right exhibit higher performance? The relationship between ANN and SNN should be clarified in the figure. Furthermore, what is shown in the first row? Why does the SNN have bounding boxes (bboxes) while the one on the left does not? In the second row, why does the SNN on the right have bounding boxes but no numerical values, while the one on the left lacks bounding boxes entirely? This is quite confusing; I find it completely incomprehensible.

  3. Lines 70–74: Regarding "early inference," there is an implicit assumption that has not been addressed: how is the decoding performed? This should be explicitly stated—especially since this paper is not solely focused on classification accuracy.

  4. The authors employ the STBIF neuron model. On which hardware does this specific neuron model offer an advantage? Has this method been implemented on any actual hardware? Why did the authors choose this particular model? For a paper with an applied focus, it is essential to consider neuron models that are feasible for hardware implementation.

  5. Lines 151–152: The paper you cite to prove equivalence is from arXiv and has not undergone peer review. For a paper intended for publication in a peer-reviewed venue, it is advisable to cite appropriate, peer-reviewed sources. It is not even clear from the citation where this paper is published—is it indeed on arXiv? The reference is: "Jing Yan, Kang You, Zhezhi He, and Yaoyu Zhang. 2026. Determinism in the undetermined: Deterministic output in charge-conserving continuous-time neuromorphic systems with temporal stochasticity."

  6. Table 1 should include an additional column indicating that your method requires further training after the conversion process, so that readers are clearly aware of the associated costs.

Reviewer_ExanOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies elastic inference in converted spiking neural networks: producing useful predictions at very early time steps while retaining the converged output of the corresponding quantized ANN. The authors associate poor early predictions with membrane–threshold mismatch and propose Temporal Membrane Biasing (TMB), which introduces channel-wise, time-dependent membrane offsets. A zero-sum temporal schedule is intended to preserve equilibrium outputs, while bias-only fine-tuning improves early predictions with frozen backbone parameters. Experiments cover ImageNet, CIFAR10-DVS, HAR-DVS, and COCO, with additional evaluations across architectures and neuron types. The strongest result is the substantial improvement in first-step ImageNet accuracy, reaching 70.25% with ViT-L. Combined with confidence-based adaptive inference, TMB reportedly reduces operations by 24.3% and average time steps by 24.8% with a 0.010-percentage-point accuracy decrease.

Critical strengths
  1. Substantial improvement in useful early predictions. Table 1 reports first-step accuracies of 40.33%, 63.79%, and 70.25% for TMB-equipped ViT-S/B/L models, whereas the listed conversion baselines are approximately at chance at that step. The matched-baseline results on neuromorphic datasets also support a real early-inference benefit: at four steps, accuracy increases from 74.5% to 79.1% on CIFAR10-DVS and from 42.6% to 47.7% on HAR-DVS. Improving intermediate predictions while retaining converged performance is a worthwhile objective.
  2. A lightweight intervention with a meaningful adaptive-inference result. TMB freezes the backbone and optimizes relatively few parameters. The zero-sum construction offers a principled way to modify transient dynamics without intentionally changing the equilibrium mapping. The reported reduction from 49.7G to 37.6G accumulation operations at nearly unchanged accuracy provides a more practically relevant demonstration than first-step accuracy alone.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The experiments do not isolate the contribution of temporal biasing from simpler calibration alternatives. The main comparisons establish the benefit of adding trainable calibration to converted networks, but do not show whether sustained, time-dependent injection is necessary. Missing controls include learned initial membrane potentials, a shared channel-wise bias with compensating cancellation, and alternative compensation schedules under matched training budgets. This matters especially because the default loss supervises only (T_{\mathrm{tar}}=1): future injected biases cannot directly affect the first prediction, although they can influence it through the compensatory initialization. Consequently, first-step gains alone do not demonstrate the need for the full temporal parameterization. The broader benchmark comparisons also overstate attribution in places: the matched baseline already achieves the same terminal results as TMB on CIFAR10-DVS, HAR-DVS, and COCO. On COCO, the isolated improvement is from 15.1 to 16.5 mAP at eight steps, rather than the much larger cross-architecture gain emphasized in the text.
  2. Important mathematical and implementation details remain unresolved. In Appendix Eq. (A4), the spike tracer satisfies (M_t=M_{t-1}+s_t^{\mathrm{out}}), but Eq. (A7) uses (1-\partial s_t^{\mathrm{out}}/\partial M_{t-1}). Under the stated update, the corresponding total derivative has a plus sign; if a direct computational-graph derivative is intended, that direct contribution is simply one. The cancellation in Eq. (A12) therefore requires explanation, including whether the implementation follows this expression or a different gradient rule. Separately, the compensation indexing differs between Figure 7 and the text. Finally, equal aggregate accuracy at a selected terminal step does not establish output-level equivalence or demonstrate that both networks have reached equilibrium. These issues affect reproducibility and confidence in the claimed mechanism, although they do not by themselves invalidate the reported first-step results.
Questions for authors
  1. Temporal schedule and optimization: What are the exact values of (T_{\mathrm{alloc}}) in each experiment, and how are (b_0,b_1,\ldots,b_{T_{\mathrm{alloc}}}) constructed? Is compensation applied before any firing occurs? Please reconcile Figure 7 with the sum starting at (t=2), and explain how future bias parameters receive gradients when only the first-step output is supervised.
  2. Decisive controlled comparison: Under the same QANN checkpoint, training data, and optimization budget, how does TMB compare with learned membrane initialization and a simpler compensated bias schedule? Accuracy–operation curves for these controls would materially clarify the contribution of temporal parameterization.
  3. Backward implementation: Is Eq. (A7) a typographical error, an intentional surrogate-gradient modification, or the expression used in code? Please provide the implemented tracer-gradient recurrence and explain its consistency with Eq. (A4), particularly for training horizons longer than one step.
  4. Equivalence and practical savings: Can the authors report numerical output discrepancies against the original QANN after verified convergence, together with convergence-time statistics? For adaptive inference, please clarify how confidence thresholds were selected and whether the reported operation savings include bias injection and all relevant non-spiking operations.
Reviewer_NrNqOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Paper argues that the existing methods for training SNNs are not suitable for elastic inference, although spiking neural networks naturally support it due to their event driven nature. As the main reason for the performance degradation in early time steps, they identify membrane-threshold mismatch, and propose temporal membrane biasing -- TMB -- a calibration method that enhances performance of SNNs trained through ANN-SNN conversion.

Critical strengths

Performance of the models obtained through ANN-SNN conversion using TMP method is high compared to the shown baselines, especially in low latency.

Critical weaknesses

Methodology and contributions:

  1. As your first contribution, you emphasize that you are the first to identify membrane-threshold mismatch in SNNs, but there is a substantial literature on this particular topic. You already cited a few papers that deal with this issue, such as [1], but there are others as well such as [2] and [3], that are both designed to address exactly this.

  2. Your third contribution is not clear. What does minimal training cost mean (compared to what class of training methods does make your method minimal cost inducing?) and what is the significance of comparing with full-parameter training?

  3. Lemma 2.1 is not true as stated, or it seems it is missing substantial assumptions for it to be true. This can be easily seen if one takes into account accumulated conversion or that emanated spikes can occur at different time steps. For example, take a look at Figure 1 in [4]. Also, it has been referred to as Theorem 2.1 in the text, which should be changed to Lemma (after its the statement/conclusion is corrected).

Furthermore TeqT_{eq} is never defined, which is okay if it is only used in Lemma that authors refer to, but it is repeatedly used further in the paper in essential places, such as Theorem 4.1 which pertains to be original contribution in the paper.

Experimental section:

In all the experiments, the authors have used transformer based architectures, but the method itself is not constrained to these, at least not in an obvious way. I wonder why the authors have not used their method in combination with CNN based architectures and compared their method with the baselines there? Or, bringing [2] and [3] (and other bias calibration methods) into transformer architectures for the fair comparison would shed light on the advantages and shortcomings of the proposed method.

Other remarks:

Line 120: Signed neuron (with outputs -1,0,1) has been proposed earlier than the cited paper (see for example [4]). Line 145: "at a small time step" is not really accurate in general, please remove. Line 151-152: SNN is proven to be equivalent in citation 1, but then formally proven in citation 2 - this should be rephrased.

Section 3.3 It is not clear what is membrane-threshold mismatch. Although authors point to Figure 6(a), it was never precisely defined, and what is the "non-mismatched" relation between potential and threshold that we should be aiming for, and why.

Line 288: This is not clear, in Phase 1 we sum up the biases from Phase 2.

[1] Bu T. et al. Optimized potential initialization for low-latency spiking neural networks, AAAI 2022,

[2] Li Y. et al. A free lunch from ann: Towards efficient, accurate spiking neural networks calibration, ICML 2021,

[3] Wu X. et al. FTBC: Forward Temporal Bias Correction for Optimizing ANN-SNN Conversion, ECCV 2024,

[4] Wang Y, et al. Signed Neuron with Memory: Towards Simple, Accurate and High-Efficient ANN-SNN Conversion, IJCAI 2022,

Questions for authors

See Weaknesses. In a nutshell, I think the paper would benefit from a proper positioning within the existing literature, and fair and extended experimental section (to compare with the related baselines).

Another, somewhat general remark, is about the emphasis of one time step performance. One time step SNN is just a quantized ANN, so temporal calibration in one time steps reduces to finetuning bias in ANNs. That is, all the benefits of temporal processing of SNNs is lost and it becomes blurry whether the contribution is on the SNN side or belongs somewhere else.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.