- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper formulates time-series forecasting as a spectral multi-objective problem, and proposes Dyadic Spectral Alignment and Coordination (DySAC) to define the loss function and optimize it. From a high level of overview, the methodology is combing two established techniques (viz. frequency alignment and MOO) with application to time-series forecasting. As a model-agnostic approach, it does not change forecasting backbone and inference procedure. The effectiveness of the proposed DySAC approach is validated on standard time-series benchmarks.
Critical strengths
The ablation study is thorough, containing uncertainty bounds, which improves the technical quality of this study.
The paper is clearly written, and provides a main figure (Figure 1) to facilitate the readers to understand and grasp the core ideas swiftly.
The experiments cover several additional metrics beyond standard MAE/MSE, such as SMAPE, WAPE and OWA-style score.
Critical weaknesses
While the implementation code is provided, the code is not very complete. It does not contain details on dataset selection, data file, and parameter specification/tuning, which difficult to execute. The resulting logs are also not available.
The frequency loss in (1) and (3) has been defined in diverse literature (with or without MRA). Authors should discuss it in a separate preliminary section and refer to the literature that uses it (with or without MRA, e.g., OLMA), and then build up their contribution on this basis.
The multi-objective optimization problem is ubiquitous and has been discussed with rich literature. Similarly, authors should discuss it in a separate preliminary section, with clear and comprehensive reference, and then build up their contribution on this basis.
Once again, since the frequency loss and the multi-objective optimization has numerous established studies, including in the time-series domain, this paper could benefit from articulating (1) the evolution and contribution of existing studies, (2) the limitation of existing studies (not only possible methodology difference, since different methods could resolve the same problem), (3) the evidence that the proposed method could address it. While authors make some discussion on frequency modeling, the discussion is not sufficient and strong.
Theoretical analysis is not available, but essential to demonstrate the utility of frequency aliment and moo strategy.
Questions for authors
How does the proposed moo strategy improve over existing methods in this task? What is the critical problem in this task that cannot be addressed by the established moo approach, while suiting the proposed moo approach? Could you provide additional theoretical/evidence to support these limitations and the effectiveness? Similarly, how does the proposed method outperform existing frequency-domain loss? Could you please provide theoretical/evidence to support the existence of these limitations and the effectiveness of the proposed method to address them?
6 comments
Response to Reviewer NVCr (Part 2)
Q2: What is the critical problem in this task that cannot be addressed by the established moo approach, while suiting the proposed moo approach?
A2: The critical problem is interference among frequency-specific objectives of the same forecast; established MOO solvers can address it once these objectives are defined. Our contribution is to expose this forecasting problem through band-wise objectives, coordinate their shared-parameter gradients, and evaluate which bands improve or regress (Sections 2.1–2.3; Appendix C). This brings gradient-conflict coordination studied in multi-task learning, including computer vision, into a spectral forecasting framework.
Existing MOO work mainly studies how to combine objectives that have already been defined. MGDA (Sener and Koltun, 2018) combines task gradients toward Pareto stationarity; PCGrad (Yu et al., 2020) projects conflicting gradients; CAGrad (Liu et al., 2021) balances average progress and conflict aversion. Nash-MTL (Navon et al., 2022) treats task combination as bargaining, while GradNorm (Chen et al., 2018) adapts task weights using gradient norms. ConFIG (Liu et al., 2025) coordinates gradients for physics-informed neural networks; we adopt its direction construction unchanged (Appendix A.3).
Our distinction is the forecasting task definition and its evaluation. We construct separate objectives from the frequency bands of a single forecast, coordinate their shared update, and measure gains and regressions on those same bands (Sections 2.1–2.3; Appendix C). Existing solvers can operate on these objectives: Table 5 in Section 3.4 compares them under identical band losses. The claim is a spectral forecasting framework and aligned evaluation, not a new MOO solver.
Q3: Could you provide additional theoretical/evidence to support these limitations and the effectiveness?
A3: Appendix B provides conditional coordination analysis, and the added matched comparisons test forecasting effectiveness. The evidence below addresses gradient conflict, the information omitted by scalar loss statistics, and the conditions for descent; our response to Reviewer jV4U, Question 2, reports additional training-stage diagnostics.
| Question addressed | Evidence | Paper location |
|---|---|---|
| Do band gradients conflict? | Mean pairwise conflict of 10.89%–44.00% across four Fred-md backbones. | Table 22 in Appendix K |
| What do scalar loss statistics omit? | Two configurations have identical losses, gradient norms, and loss histories but different gradient geometry. | Appendix B.3 |
| What does the coordination analysis establish? | Conditions for common descent; sufficiently small direct-step descent; an O(T^(-1/2)) projected-residual best-iterate bound under the stated deterministic smoothness assumptions. | Appendices B.1–B.2 |
Forecasting effectiveness is tested by the controlled results in Q1. The analysis concerns direction geometry and conditional direct updates. Raw band-gradient conflict is a different diagnostic from the merged update and forecasting accuracy; our response to jV4U Q2 discusses the 96-run training-stage measurements.
Response to Reviewer NVCr (Part 3)
Q4: Similarly, how does the proposed method outperform existing frequency-domain loss?
A4: DySAC achieves the highest mean task-wise spectral improvement and the best average task rank among the evaluated objectives. We compare MSE and six established objectives across seven datasets and four backbones, including FreDF (Wang et al., 2025), DBLoss (Qiu et al., 2025), and PS-Loss (Kudrat et al., 2025). The compact comparison below retains the strongest competing objective separately for each measure.
| Spectral evaluation measure | Ours | Best competing objective |
|---|---|---|
| Mean task-wise improvement over MSE ↑ | +3.85% | DBLoss: +2.85% |
| Worst-band mean improvement ↑ | +2.39% | FreDF: +1.60% |
| Average task rank ↓ | 2.01 | FreDF: 3.42 |
DySAC also has the best average task rank in 19 of 28 settings, including ties. Figure 3 in Section 3.3 and Table 21 in Appendix I report the complete spectral comparison; Table 1 in Section 3.2 and Appendix E report aggregate MSE/MAE. These results assess both forecasting accuracy and how gains are distributed across bands.
Q5: Could you please provide theoretical/evidence to support the existence of these limitations and the effectiveness of the proposed method to address them?
A5: Figure 3 in Section 3.3 shows that improvements in some frequency bands can coexist with deterioration in others. For example, TILDE-Q improves the first two bands by +5.59% and +3.37%, while its fourth- and fifth-band means are -1.81% and -3.60%. This motivates evaluating gains and regressions on individual bands.
Table 4 in Section 3.4 separates the effects of spectral supervision, dyadic decomposition, and gradient coordination. The three-seed FreTS means below show the component comparison; Table 4 in Section 3.4 provides standard deviations and the additional L2 variants.
| Training variant | Electricity MSE / MAE | Weather MSE / MAE |
|---|---|---|
| Single full-spectrum L1 | 0.1910 / 0.2769 | 0.2101 / 0.2637 |
| Dyadic + Mean | 0.1879 / 0.2743 | 0.2100 / 0.2608 |
| Ours | 0.1877 / 0.2733 | 0.2078 / 0.2569 |
Both decomposition and coordination improve all four means in this ablation. Appendix B supplies the conditional coordination analysis summarized in Q3, while Table 6 in Section 3.4 separately tests the frequency partition with loss and coordinator fixed. Together, these comparisons support the proposed framework and its design choices.
Code and reproducibility. Appendices D.2–D.3 document datasets, splits, preprocessing, configurations, and training settings. We commit to releasing the full code alongside the final version of this paper, together with complete reproduction details including dependencies, dataset selection and preprocessing, per-setting configurations, seeds, training/evaluation commands, run logs, and checkpoint identifiers.
Response to Reviewer NVCr (Part 1)
Many thanks to Reviewer NVCr for providing a detailed review and insightful questions.
We respectfully disagree that prior spectral losses and multi-objective optimization (MOO) solvers subsume our contribution. Our contribution is a spectral multi-objective formulation of forecasting, a gradient-coordinated training framework, and an evaluation protocol on the same frequency objectives (Sections 2.1–2.3). Prior spectral losses specify what to optimize, while MOO solvers combine gradients of given objectives. Our framework connects these two levels: it exposes frequency-specific forecasting errors as separate objectives, coordinates their shared update using ConFIG, and measures gains and regressions on those same bands. We adopt ConFIG’s coordination rule and do not claim a new aggregation algorithm.
The other reviewers’ comments identify this formulation and application as the contribution. Reviewer jV4U recognized the meaningful problem formulation, noting that frequency-specific objectives provide a reasonable way to consider optimization trade-offs. Reviewer PfQa identified the application of conflict-aware multi-task optimization to spectral forecasting losses as the main contribution. The responses below substantiate this distinction through matched comparisons, conditional analysis, and component ablations.
Q1: How does the proposed moo strategy improve over existing methods in this task?
A1: DySAC achieves the lowest mean MSE and MAE in three of four matched settings. Thank you for suggesting this comparison; we added the complete results to the main paper (Table 5 in Section 3.4). We compare PCGrad (Yu et al., 2020), MGDA (Sener and Koltun, 2018), CAGrad (Liu et al., 2021), Nash-MTL (Navon et al., 2022), GradNorm (Chen et al., 2018), and Dyadic + Mean, plus an MSE-trained reference. The spectral methods share identical dyadic objectives and matched training conditions.
The complete eight-method results below report three-seed mean ± sample SD; bold marks the lowest mean for each metric. Table 5 in Section 3.4 reports the same comparison.
Electricity / FreTS
Weather / FreTS
Electricity / TimeMixer
Weather / TimeMixer
The strongest improvement over Mean is on Electricity / TimeMixer: 10.05% lower MSE and 8.60% lower MAE. PCGrad leads on Weather / TimeMixer; the comparison establishes the observed benefit of coordination and its dependence on the forecasting setting.