- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SafeConductor, a training-free sampling-time safeguard for text-to-image models with classifier-free guidance. For each of seven unsafe categories, it builds a direction from the difference between predictions under paired unsafe and safe descriptions. It then corrects the prompt guidance by finding the vector closest to it with non-positive projections onto all category directions, which reduces to a nonnegative quadratic program over one coefficient per category, solved by cyclic coordinate descent. The correction is scaled by a sinusoidal schedule that emphasizes the intermediate sampling stage. The method is evaluated on SD1.5 and FLUX.2 (and FLUX.1-dev in the appendix) using ASR on I2P, T2VSafetyBench, Unsafe Diffusion, and CoProV2, FID and CLIP score on MS-COCO, a combined SQA score, and adversarial prompts from P4D, Ring-A-Bell, and MMA-Diffusion.
Critical strengths
-
SafeConductor achieves the lowest ASR on all four safety benchmarks on both SD1.5 and FLUX.2 (Table 1), and compared with the sampling-time baselines SLD-Max and CASG, it also improves FID and CLIP score on both backbones. The results hold on FLUX.1-dev (Table 7) and across all seven I2P categories (Table 8), and SafeConductor also achieves the lowest average ASR on adversarial prompts (Table 4). These consistent results across backbones and benchmarks are the main reason for my positive assessment.
-
The joint correction is a reasonable extension of single-direction correction. Rather than correcting only the category direction most aligned with the current guidance, as in CASG, it determines the coefficients of all category directions together, and Table 2 shows lower ASR than independent correction (5.38% vs. 9.04%) with similar FID and CLIP score. The method requires no training and applies to both noise and velocity predictions.
Critical weaknesses
-
Each of the two main components is ablated on only one backbone: the joint correction on SD1.5 (Table 2) and the phase-aware allocation on FLUX.2 (Table 3), without explanation or corresponding cross-backbone ablations in the appendix. Since the paper claims architectural transferability across noise and velocity prediction, it is unclear whether the benefit of each component holds on the other backbone. In addition, the paired unsafe and safe descriptions, which are intended to reduce the influence of shared semantic content (Section 3.2), are not evaluated separately; the gap between the joint correction and the full SafeConductor in Table 2 (5.38% vs. 4.81% ASR) combines their effect with that of the sinusoidal allocation.
-
The phase-aware allocation is one of the two main contributions, but it is compared only with constant and single-window schedules of the proposed correction (Table 3). Dynamic Negative Guidance (Koulischer et al., 2025), which the paper discusses in Section 2.2 as modulating negative guidance according to sampling time and state, is not included as a baseline or as an alternative allocation. It is therefore unclear whether the sinusoidal allocation offers an advantage over such adaptive time-dependent guidance.
Questions for authors
- (Clarification) Why is the joint correction ablated only on SD1.5 and the phase-aware allocation only on FLUX.2? How do both ablations look on the other backbone?
- (Additional result) What is the effect of the paired unsafe and safe descriptions alone, for example, compared with directions computed against the empty condition under the same setting?
- (Additional result) How does the sinusoidal allocation compare with Dynamic Negative Guidance applied to the same joint correction?
6 comments
Response to Reviewer 6sSe
W2 Alternative allocation functions and adaptive guidance
Thank you for highlighting the need to compare our sinusoidal allocation with other strength allocation methods. Beyond the constant and single-window controls in the main paper, we compare it with alternative functions on FLUX.2 in Table 4. We follow the experimental settings of Table 3 in the main paper, retaining paired descriptions and joint correction and changing only the allocation function. All continuous functions are normalized to a peak of one and use the same strength parameter . ASR is evaluated on I2P, while FID and CLIP are evaluated on COCO.
Let denote the normalized sampling progress at iteration , where is the number of sampling iterations. We define the correction strength as , where is a strength allocation function and controls the overall scale of the correction strength. Besides the sinusoidal function , we compare the sine-squared function , the parabolic function , and a Gaussian function centered at with width parameter . We also consider two functions derived from the Beta distribution: , . Their continuous peaks occur at and , respectively, allowing us to examine allocations that place the strongest correction earlier or later in the sampling trajectory.
Table 4. Comparison of correction strength allocation functions on FLUX.2.
| Allocation function | ASR (%) ↓ | FID ↓ | CLIP ↑ | SQA ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Native | 34.15 | 72.24 | 32.15 | 79.41 |
| Sine-squared | 11.80 | 73.05 | 31.24 | 92.85 |
| Parabolic | 6.66 | 77.98 | 29.76 | 92.97 |
| Gaussian | 13.52 | 73.15 | 31.35 | 91.94 |
| Beta(2,3) | 7.87 | 79.80 | 29.96 | 91.98 |
| Beta(3,2) | 16.01 | 73.39 | 31.70 | 90.68 |
| Sinusoidal (Ours) | 7.70 | 75.69 | 30.39 | 93.62 |
As shown in Table 4, sinusoidal allocation achieves a relatively low ASR and the highest SQA among the compared functions. The parabolic function achieves a lower ASR but degrades image quality and prompt alignment. At the same peak parameter, the parabolic function has a larger area and a higher sum of strength coefficients than the sinusoid, which may help explain its stronger suppression but worse image quality and prompt alignment. Sine-squared and Gaussian functions better preserve image quality and prompt alignment but provide weaker suppression of unsafe content. These results support our choice of sinusoidal allocation to balance safety, image quality, and prompt alignment.
Regarding your suggestion to compare with adaptive guidance, We further compare sinusoidal allocation with DNG weighting on SD1.5 in Table 5. DNG adaptively scales negative guidance using an estimated posterior of the undesired condition. Following its formulation for diffusion models, we evaluate it on SD1.5, retaining unsafe–safe description pairs and joint correction while replacing sinusoidal allocation with DNG weighting. The comparison follows the SD1.5 sampling and evaluation settings used in Table 1 of the main paper. ASR is evaluated on I2P, while FID and CLIP are evaluated on COCO.
Table 5. Comparison of sinusoidal allocation and DNG weighting for joint correction on SD1.5.
| Method | ASR (%) ↓ | FID ↓ | CLIP ↑ | SQA ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Native | 42.50 | 69.81 | 31.59 | 73.02 |
| DNG | 39.87 | 69.94 | 31.47 | 75.02 |
| Sinusoidal (Ours) | 4.81 | 72.12 | 29.51 | 95.13 |
As shown in Table 5, the DNG variant preserves image quality and prompt alignment well, but its ASR remains close to Native, indicating limited suppression of unsafe content. A possible explanation is that its posterior is estimated from the aggregated negative condition and the user’s positive condition, whereas the resulting coefficient scales a joint correction constructed from seven unsafe–safe description pairs. A low posterior for the aggregated condition does not necessarily mean that the individual category constraints require little correction. The resulting weighting may therefore apply insufficient correction. In comparison, sinusoidal allocation achieves substantially stronger safety, reducing ASR from 39.87% to 4.81% and increasing SQA from 75.02 to 95.13, while maintaining competitive generation quality.
Response to Reviewer 6sSe
Q1 Ablations on both backbones
Thank you for this question. We address it in W1 by providing the additional comparison of correction strategies on FLUX.2 in Table 1 and strength allocations on SD1.5 in Table 2. On FLUX.2, joint correction achieves lower ASR than averaging and independent correction, supporting the benefit of accounting for interactions among unsafe directions. On SD1.5, sinusoidal allocation achieves lower ASR than the mean-matched constant and all three window controls, while avoiding the substantial image-quality and prompt-alignment losses of the peak-matched constant. These additional results extend the original ablations to the other backbone and support the effectiveness of joint correction and phase-aware strength allocation on SD1.5 and FLUX.2.
Q2 Contribution of paired descriptions
Thank you for highlighting the need to examine the contribution of paired descriptions more directly. We provide the additional comparison in Table 3 of our response to W1. The full configuration with paired descriptions achieves lower ASR and higher SQA on both backbones, with particularly clear improvements in safety and image quality on FLUX.2. These results support our use of paired descriptions in the full configuration for stronger safety.
Q3 Comparison of sinusoidal allocation and DNG weighting
We appreciate your suggestion to compare sinusoidal allocation with DNG, which dynamically adjusts guidance strength during sampling. We provide this comparison in Table 5 of our response to W2, retaining unsafe–safe description pairs and joint correction in both variants. On SD1.5, DNG weighting achieves an ASR of 39.87%, close to Native’s 42.50%, indicating limited suppression of unsafe content in this adaptation. Sinusoidal allocation reduces ASR to 4.81% and achieves an SQA of 95.13, compared with 75.02 for DNG weighting. Although the DNG variant preserves image quality and prompt alignment better in this experiment, sinusoidal allocation provides substantially stronger safety while maintaining competitive generation quality. These results support sinusoidal allocation as the more effective choice for balancing safety, image quality, and prompt alignment.
Response to Reviewer 6sSe
We sincerely appreciate your careful review and your recognition of our method’s consistent improvements across backbones and benchmarks. In response to your valuable suggestions, we provide additional ablations, comparisons with alternative strength allocation methods, and further analysis of the contribution of paired descriptions below.
W1 Component ablations across architectures
Thank you for suggesting these complementary ablations. We provide the comparison of strategies for handling concurrent unsafe concepts on FLUX.2 in Table 1 and the comparison of correction strength allocations across sampling stages on SD1.5 in Table 2. ASR is evaluated on I2P, while FID and CLIP are evaluated on COCO, following the sampling settings used in the main paper.
Table 1. Comparison of strategies for handling concurrent unsafe concepts on FLUX.2.
On FLUX.2, we follow the experimental design of Table 2 in the main paper and evaluate the strategies without paired unsafe–safe descriptions or sinusoidal strength allocation. Among these correction strategies, joint correction achieves the lowest ASR and highest SQA while maintaining competitive image quality and prompt alignment. These results support the value of jointly optimizing category coefficients to account for interactions among unsafe directions. We also include the full SafeConductor method, which further improves safety, image quality, and prompt alignment.
Table 2. Comparison of correction strength allocations across SD1.5 sampling stages.
On SD1.5, we follow the experimental design of Table 3 in the main paper, retaining paired descriptions and joint correction while comparing different strength allocations. Maintaining the peak strength throughout sampling provides the strongest suppression but substantially degrades image quality and prompt alignment. Among the window controls, early-only correction provides the strongest suppression but causes the greatest quality loss, whereas intermediate-only and late-only correction preserve quality better but offer weaker suppression of unsafe content. Sinusoidal allocation achieves lower ASR than the mean-matched constant and all three windows while avoiding the substantial quality and alignment losses of the peak-matched constant. The original and additional ablations support the effectiveness of joint correction and phase-aware strength allocation on both SD1.5 and FLUX.2.
In addition, to address your concern about the role of unsafe–safe description pairs, we present further experimental results in Table 3. Both variants retain joint correction and sinusoidal strength allocation, using the sampling and evaluation settings reported in the main paper. ASR is evaluated on I2P, while FID and CLIP are evaluated on COCO.
Table 3. Comparison of SafeConductor with and without unsafe–safe description pairs.
As shown in Table 3, the full configuration with unsafe–safe description pairs achieves lower ASR and higher SQA on both backbones. The improvement is especially substantial on FLUX.2, where ASR decreases from 19.88% to 7.70%, a relative reduction of approximately 61%, while FID improves from 85.41 to 75.69. These results demonstrate the value of the full paired-description configuration in achieving stronger safety.