- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents DressAgent, a hierarchical agentic framework for recovering simulation-ready garments from a single in-the-wild image. The method first introduces GarmentCode-XL, which extends the original garment program representation with richer garment constructions, wider design ranges, and explicit multi-layer relations. DressAgent then decomposes an outfit into ordered layers, generates canonical and layer-specific views, and estimates an initial garment program for each layer. A Tailor-Critic-Orchestrator trio subsequently refines the programs through iterative cloth simulation and measured visual feedback. The framework additionally supports texture reconstruction and dynamic simulation, enabling the recovered garments to be reposed and simulated after reconstruction
Critical strengths
- GarmentCode-XL broadens the garment program space with richer constructions and explicit multi-layer relations, enabling structured reconstruction of complex outfits.
- The Tailor–Critic–Orchestrator design provides a well-structured closed-loop refinement process, with extensive ablations supporting its effectiveness and stability.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper's main contributions largely center on GarmentCodeData-XL and an agentic pipeline heavily dependent on pretrained VLMs and existing tools, raising concerns about its methodological novelty for ICLR. Furthermore, while Tables 3, 11, and 14 support the benefits of refinement and role decomposition, the experiments do not sufficiently isolate the incremental benefit of adding GarmentCodeData-XL to decoder training, leaving the contribution of this additional training data unclear.
- The claimed generalization to diverse real-world garments is not convincingly demonstrated. GarmentCodeData-XL is generated within the predefined GarmentCode-XL design space, inherently favoring the proposed representation. Although real-world evaluations are included, the paper lacks systematic quantitative and qualitative evaluations on structurally novel or difficult-to-represent garments, leaving its practical generalization capabilities and limitations unclear.
Questions for authors
- What is the key methodological novelty of DressAgent beyond combining pretrained VLMs with garment-specific tools?
- Could you provide comparisons with existing methods on per-layer sewing-pattern accuracy and final multi-layer geometry using GarmentCodeData-XL, beyond layer-count and relation accuracy?
- How is structural consistency verified across the synthesized canonical front, generated back, and peeled views, and how do inconsistencies among these views affect reconstruction quality?
- Could you provide quantitative and qualitative evaluations on unseen garment structures and garments beyond GarmentCode-XL's design space, including representative failure cases?
- Since the representation ablation in Table 3 is partly evaluated on GarmentCodeData-XL, could you provide controlled comparisons on real-scan datasets, including refinement of existing methods (e.g., ChatGarment (Bianetal.,2025))?
Thank you for your constructive feedback! We address your questions and concerns as follows:
(A) Methodological Novelty
To our knowledge, DressAgent is the first work to harness coding agents for multi-layer sewing pattern reconstruction through garment-specific skills and tools that extend their capabilities to physical design. Our complete workflow enables (1) intelligent planning of layers and structural relations, (2) closed-loop refinement where agents autonomously coordinate subagents and select physical tools, and (3) agentic texture generation and extended garment simulation.
(B) Benefit of Decoder Training using GarmentCodeData-XL
Our goal of Stage 1 is to write semantically aligned GarmentCode-XL programs from images. A straightforward approach is asking a VLM to read the source code of GarmentCode-XL and write programs directly from images, but its performance varies substantially across VLM backbones. To improve consistency and robustness of our framework, we introduce a more robust solution (
Lines 211–255): predefine visual questions from the source code, let VLMs answer them from images, and train a decoder to map the answers back to executable parameters, which helps narrow the knowledge gap and improves consistency for our specific task.To demonstrate this, we compare this design with direct program writing with source code across different backbones on cases of
Fig. 8, with Stage 1 results reported below:Compared with direct program writing, our decoder-based approach yields consistent gains for the closed-source backbones and more substantial gains for open-weight Qwen (
+0.112 IoU), narrowing the performance gap and improving the capability of backbone models.(C) Per-Layer Pattern Accuracy and Multi-Layer Geometry
We extend
Table 9by reporting per-layer sewing-pattern accuracy and final multi-layer geometry on GarmentCodeData-XL, evaluated only on cases where each method predicts the correct number of layers.(D) Structural Consistency across Front, Back, and Peeled Views
During generation, we use strict prompts to instruct the image model to preserve the outfit and keep the human pose consistent across views (similar to [1]). We then use least-squares camera fitting to align each view with a shared 3D body, mitigating minor differences in position and scale. We measure our body-landmark alignment differences on 4D-Dress and report that all errors remain below 3% of body height (see table below). We’ll provide more details in the revised version.
[1] Dress-1-to-3, SIGGRAPH 2025.
(E) Evaluations on Generalization and Representative Failure Cases
Appendix Fig. 23demonstrates broad coverage of everyday outfits, while our user study (Table 2) on DeepFashion, Pinterest, and user-uploaded photos, covering general garment structures beyond the synthetic training distribution, shows substantially higher preference than baselines. These results demonstrate applicability to everyday garments. We also discuss limitations in the appendix and show a failure case inFig. 22(a free-hanging sash, beyond our current scope).(F) Representation Ablation on Real Scans, and Refining ChatGarment
We report the representation ablation and the refinement of ChatGarment on the real scans of CloSe and 4D-Dress (same cases as
Table 1) with a refinement budget ofT = 6:We also provide visual comparisons on the ChatGarment dataset: https://imgur.com/a/JFvVlpR. ChatGarment generates standard-size garments on an SMPL body without layering, fine-grained component control, or texturing, while our refinement reduces these discrepancies and provides substantial improvements.