- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes MorphAct, a contextual parameterization framework that shares an adaptation rule rather than a fixed update, allowing adaptation to specialize without splitting the policy into operation-specific experts. It improves average success rates across three VLA backbones on LIBERO, Meta-World, and a real-world robot.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is reasonable and supported by experiments (Fig 2).
- The method design is simple yet effective. Then VLM side generates based on the context, and then the action side generates based on the updated VLM parameters. And this is a dynamic update process across the episode, which aligns the problem they found in robocasa365 atomic tasks.
- The experiment results show its advantages on three different VLA backbones and two benchmarks, especially on MetaWorld.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper mentioned other VLA parameter-generation methods like Hyper-LoRA and PhaseLoRA. But there lacks a direct benchmarking comparison between MorphAct and these method.
- Some important figures seem AI-generated (Fig 3), the readability is not good. The font and the too much text comment in the figure affect the understanding of the whole architecture.
Questions for authors
- Can you provide some benchmarking comparison between MorphAct and Hyper-LoRA/PhaseLoRA, or provide the reasons if you can not.
3 comments
Thanks for your rebuttal. I will keep my recommendation as a weak acceptance.
Thank you for your careful consideration of our submission and rebuttal. We appreciate your time and constructive feedback.
Rebuttal to Reviewer zFvr
Thank you for this suggestion. We ran PhaseLoRA [1] on the same backbone and benchmark as MorphAct (X-VLA, LIBERO, all four suites). We also trained a static LoRA whose total trainable-parameter budget is comparable to MorphAct's, under the same data and schedule, to check whether the gain comes from extra parameters:
MorphAct exceeds PhaseLoRA by 1.90 points and the budget-matched static LoRA by 2.50 points. PhaseLoRA modulates action-side LoRA per action chunk. MorphAct differs in two respects: it also generates VLM-side updates, and its action-side generator reads the adapted VLM representation. Table 3 tests each of these: without VLM-side generation (Action-only) success is 81.00%, and when the action generator reads unadapted VLM features (Unadapted) it is 86.00%, against 96.60% for MorphAct.
We were not able to complete a reproduction of Hyper-LoRA [2] on X-VLA within the discussion period, so we do not report a number for it. Its central design choice is, however, tested in Table 3. Hyper-LoRA generates the LoRA update from the language instruction, so the update depends only on the task and stays fixed throughout an episode. The Task-ID variant uses this kind of condition inside MorphAct's own architecture and training: one fixed generation condition per task, while the policy still receives the current image, instruction, and robot state. Each LIBERO task has its own instruction, so task identity carries the same task information as the instruction. Task-ID reaches 88.25%, compared with 96.60% for MorphAct (Section 5.1). This comparison isolates task-level from context-level conditioning with identical generators and training; it does not reproduce Hyper-LoRA's generator architecture or training recipe, as Section 5.1 of the revision now states.
The PhaseLoRA and static-LoRA comparisons are in Section 5.1 and Appendix D.6 of the revision, and Section 5.1 now also states the relation between Hyper-LoRA and the Task-ID variant.
Thank you for this comment. We agree that the original Fig. 3 contained too much text at too small a font size, which made the overall architecture harder to follow. We have redrawn it in the revision:
Thank you again for your kind support. We hope these results address your concerns. If you have further questions, we would be glad to answer them, and we would be very grateful if you would consider raising your score.
References
[1] PhaseLoRA: Control-Regime-Conditioned Low-Rank Adaptation for Continuous-Action Vision-Language-Action Policies.
[2] Efficient Domain Adaptation of Robotic Foundation Models via Hypernetwork-Generated LoRA. NeurIPS 2024 Workshop.