- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Tempo-Zero, a framework that treats executable programs as environments for video-based self-play. As a program executes, it simultaneously renders a video and records the sequence of events, from which questions, correct answers, and the specific temporal intervals serving as evidence are derived. A single vision-language policy functions as both the questioner and the solver; instead of relying on majority voting or an external model-based judge, the framework uses the success of program execution as a reward signal. Furthermore, the environment evolves through a curriculum based on success rates and dynamic adjustments to the rules governing policy selection.
Critical strengths
The paper clearly articulates the limitations, such as issues with supervision or adaptability, inherent in existing video self-play methods and program-generated video approaches. It proposes using program execution to simultaneously control video content and provide verifiable supervision.
Execution traces provide both the correct answers and the corresponding temporal evidence intervals. By re-evaluating sampled frames and checking for temporal dependencies, the framework ensures that labels remain valid for the specific frames visible to the model, thereby reducing noise in consensus-based labeling.
Critical weaknesses
The environment suite, task patterns, and rule sets are predefined by the authors. The range of physical behaviors and task types is limited, making it difficult to capture the open-ended events, common-sense relationships, and perceptual complexity found in natural, real-world videos.
The supervision mechanism relies on deterministic rendering and precise temporal coordinates. In contrast, real-world video events often feature ambiguous boundaries, frequent occlusions, overlapping events, and complex camera motion; thus, the precision of execution-based labels does not necessarily equate to a robust capability for understanding real-world video.
The reliance on fixed syntactic parsing, statement matching, and temporal interval overlap means that only specific phrasings and granularities are accepted, potentially leading to the rejection of valid evidence that is phrased differently. Additionally, the gating mechanism may inadvertently filter out legitimate questions, and the multi-component reward structure requires significant hyperparameter tuning.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weaknesses.
3 comments
Response to Reviewer YNoG (2/2)
Thank you again for your thoughtful comments on evidence flexibility, question gating, and hyperparameter sensitivity. Below we address each of these points with direct empirical audits.
W3 (part 1): The reliance on fixed syntactic parsing, statement matching, and temporal interval overlap means that only specific phrasings and granularities are accepted, potentially leading to the rejection of valid evidence that is phrased differently.
Answer: Statement matching prevents unrelated guesses from harvesting interval overlap credit, where Figure 7B shows roughly half of unconditioned IoU credit lands on wrong events, while an unmatched evidence line never reduces the main answer reward. To test sensitivity to alternative phrasings directly, we evaluated five controlled 100-statement rewrite probes built from accepted 4B evidence lines, measuring false-pass rates strictly on statements false against every fact in the video, as detailed in Appendix D.4.
| Controlled probe, N = 100 | Truly false statements | Outcome or false-pass rate | Audit detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| Natural paraphrase | 0 | 91.0% recall | 91 of 100 match the original fact with 0 misassigned |
| Non-instance number | 99 | 0.0% false pass | 0 of 99 accepted |
| Another number in same video | 46 | 0.0% false pass | 0 of 46 accepted; remaining 54 match another true fact |
| Another entity in same video | 62 | 0.0% false pass | 0 of 62 accepted; remaining 38 match that entity's true state |
| Insert predicate negation "not" | 100 | 1.0% false pass | 1 of 100 accepted; word-boundary filter blocks 99% of inversions |
Across all 314,619 evidence lines generated in the 4B run, only 41 of 3,276 lines containing negation terms were accepted, or 1.25%, nearly all of them compound sentences whose affirmative clause stated a true observation. Grounded scoring also uses continuous temporal IoU rather than rigid frame equality, and Table 3 confirms that both process terms complement answer supervision on Qwen3-VL-4B, while the revised Appendix G outlines future work pairing execution rubrics with lightweight typed decision models such as Jev [1, 2] for free-form multi-granularity evidence.
| Process supervision ablation on 4B | Temporal Grounding | Video QA & Reasoning | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4B Base | 25.08 | 54.68 | 44.81 |
| Answer reward only | 31.30 | 56.28 | 47.96 |
| w/o evidence score | 35.34 | 57.33 | 50.00 |
| w/o grounded score | 36.63 | 57.11 | 50.28 |
| Full Tempo-Zero | 37.00 | 57.71 | 50.81 |
W3 (part 2): Additionally, the gating mechanism may inadvertently filter out legitimate questions, and the multi-component reward structure requires significant hyperparameter tuning.
Proposal gating. Canonical questions and bank-replay items enter Solver training directly without proposal gating, while online Questioner gate pass rates rise quickly above 90% in Figure 6C. Manual inspection of 100 randomly sampled gated-out proposals in Appendix D.4 found objective supervision-corrupting defects in all 100 cases, with zero valid questions rejected.
| Defect category in gated-out proposals, N = 100 | Share | Observed failure modes |
|---|---|---|
| Malformed structure or duplicate options | 56% | Wrong option count, truncated output missing answer block, duplicate or symmetric options, placeholder text |
| Out-of-range or unresolvable options | 33% | Out-of-domain distractors, ground truth omitted, options closer than sampled frame resolution |
| Answer leakage or missing qualifiers | 11% | Answer leaked in question stem, missing time window or ordinal qualifier causing multiple solutions |
Reward hyperparameters. Equation 4 avoids component-wise weight tuning by taking unweighted arithmetic averages over unit-normalized Solver process terms and Questioner terms, with quadratic learnability peaking naturally at 0.5 pass rate. The remaining constants are standard curriculum pass-rate bounds, clipping ratios, and KL regularization in Table 5, fixed once on Qwen3-VL-4B and transferred unchanged to Qwen3-VL-8B, Qwen3-VL-30B-A3B, and Gemma-4-E4B-it without per-backbone retuning.
Thank you again for your constructive feedback. We hope these analyses clarify the scope and robustness of Tempo-Zero, and we are happy to address any further questions.
References
[1] Diogo Almeida. Introducing System One Models & Jev. TypeSafe AI Blog, September 2026. https://typesafe.ai/blog/introducing-system-one-models-and-jev
[2] Guanxu Yu and Yuhang Yao. Visual Jev: Accurate and Efficient Decisions from Shared Visual Context. arXiv:2609.25845, 2026.
Dear Reviewer YNoG,
We hope you are doing well, and thank you again for your careful review and helpful comments. We understand how busy things can be, so we really appreciate you taking a look at our response when you get a chance. If you feel that our clarifications have addressed your main concerns, we would be very grateful if you could consider revisiting your overall assessment. Please also let us know if any questions remain.
Thank you very much!
Response to Reviewer YNoG (1/2)
Thank you very much for your careful review and for recognizing that our frame-recomputed execution traces keep labels valid for the exact frames visible to the model while reducing consensus noise. Below we address your first two concerns on synthetic environment scope and real-video robustness.
Answer: As you note, rendered synthetic scenes do not attempt to replicate natural visual textures or open-world encyclopedic knowledge. Visual recognition of everyday objects, scenes, and common-sense priors comes from the pretrained vision-language backbone, whereas executable programs cultivate transferable temporal skills: tracking multi-entity state changes, resolving event order and duration, maintaining entity continuity across occlusions, counting recurring transitions, and anchoring answers to verified evidence intervals [1, 2]. At zero-shot test time, these temporal composition skills combine naturally with pretrained perceptual priors across all 12 real-world benchmarks and all four backbones in Tables 1 and 2, while we also discuss manual program design scope in our Limitations section. Under the same 3,200-instance, 100-step budget and verification interface, our 20-family suite retains all 12 original families and adds 8 new executable families. Four of them model multi-process occlusion via lane-crossing handoffs, hooded cascades, extended-occluder re-identification, and patrol beacons, and the other four model grid kinematics via atomic motion, 2D waypoints, long-horizon state memory, and terminal tracking.
Under matched compute, broadening the executable suite from 12 to 20 families improves both real-video temporal grounding and video QA & reasoning on 4B.
Answer: Deterministic execution prevents consensus drift during self-play, where Figure 7A shows majority voting errs on over half of collected groups, while our training signals teach the model to track state transitions across frames rather than latch onto isolated single-frame cues. Because visibility is recomputed on sampled frames, Equation 3 scores continuous temporal IoU conditioned on matching the right event first, and dedicated families model full visual occlusion, the trained policy compares start-to-end state changes across the sampled sequence. On natural videos, this helps follow gradual action onsets and completions, bridge brief occlusions via pre- and post-occlusion continuity, separate concurrent interleaved actors by event semantics, and stay anchored to subject actions during camera pans, as illustrated by verified 4B test predictions in Appendix F.
References
[1] Kexin Yi et al. CLEVRER: Collision Events for Video Representation and Reasoning. In ICLR, 2020.
[2] Songtao Jiang et al. Learning Transferable Temporal Primitives for Video Reasoning via Synthetic Videos. In CVPR, 2026.