- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper says that labels in temporal grounding benchmarks have a resolution of one second. It gives TickTock, a method that attaches each label to a decoded video frame. A human or an MLLM selects the boundary frames on numbered contact sheets. The paper releases four resources: a training set, MLLM-refined TimeLens labels, a benchmark that Gemini re-annotated, and 500 human time points. The paper tests many Video LLMs which get very low performance with 0.1-level annotations.
Critical strengths
None.
Critical weaknesses
- **The paper does not show that sub-second temporal grounding is a meaningful application. ** It is not clear why improving timestamp precision from 1 s to 0.1 s matters, especially when this precision may exceed the consistency of human annotation. For example, the paper reports no human agreement data at sub-second precision, and no task is exemplified where 0.1 s accuracy changes the outcome meaningfully.
- The Newton example is confusing. It describes human perception at a low frame rate rather than a model task. It is also not a use case for sub-second grounding: the problem in the example is the input frame rate, but TickTock changes only the labels.
- The refinement of current benchmarks is limited. Building a temporal grounding benchmark involves both event search, which is the main challenge, and boundary finding, which current benchmarks already annotate at the 1 s level. The refinement moves endpoints by only a fraction of a second (median about 0.4 s, App. C.2), and the paper does not explain which applications need this change.
- The paper shows no benefit of the new data. The paper does not train a model on the released data. Thus, it is unclear whether the training data provides additional learning signal, or how well current models can learn sub-second temporal grounding. The word "Teaching" in the title is therefore not yet supported.
- The role of TickTock-5K is unclear. Based on the Fig. 2 caption and Sec. 3.2, TickTock-5K does not appear to contain frame-level annotations. It seems to be a curated set of 5K samples from existing data, which does not match the dataset name or the main claim of the paper. As a result, the dataset seems disconnected from the rest of the paper, and its purpose is unclear.
- TickTock-Refined is not human-verified. Gemini 3.1 Pro produced the TickTock-Refined boundaries, and no human checked them (App. C.4). LLM-generated labels can be acceptable for training data, but benchmark references should be verified by humans.
- The paper is difficult to read. Many engineering details, overlapping evaluation subsets and data statistics are spread across long paragraphs in the nine pages. These details obscure the main claims and the logic of the paper.
Questions for authors
- What is the proof that sub-second temporal grounding is significantly more useful than the current second-level practice?
- What is the point of TickTock5K if it is not even frame/sub-second-level annotations which is the main claim of the paper?
- Can the current MLLM models really benefit from the proposed training data?