acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

SciDialect: Symbolic Compression as an Intrinsic Reward for Scientific Discovery Agents

Abstract

Autonomous scientific discovery often depends on expensive or delayed external validation, leaving intermediate reasoning decisions without a task reward. We ask whether abstraction itself can provide useful intrinsic guidance. Our principle, grounded symbolic compression, rewards shorter representations of task-visible scientific content while checking that their claims, conditions, and evidence remain recoverable through a designed decoder. We instantiate it in SciDialect, a black-box controller that calibrates reusable scientific primitives on development tasks, then uses independently validated, query-specific instantiations to condition the next solver step. Its online representation reward requires no external correctness score. Our analysis establishes when verified predictive compression improves expected log score after representation cost, and when the scientific-state representation preserves downstream decision information, with a qualified minimality result. Across PreScience, DiscoveryBench, and SciCode, our proposed SciDialect achieves the highest mean contribution token F1 on three model families, improves adapted discovery score over prompt compression, and improves mean observable code execution. Four equal-budget scientific optimization tasks, i.e., MBO, NHO, SPO, and TMC, provide complementary evidence of improved trajectory quality when the intrinsic controller augments an existing objective-based search. Together, these results support grounded abstraction as an intrinsic signal for scientific reasoning, without treating it as a substitute for scientific validation.

Primary area:
unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords:
multi-agent, scientific discovery

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_KogHOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

SciDialect proposes symbolic compression as an intrinsic, label-free reward for scientific discovery agents. A proposer rewrites the current "scientific state" as compact symbolic expressions over a primitive dictionary. Candidates pass audit gates (independent reconstruction, anchor grounding, cross-decoder consistency) and are ranked by description-length reduction, grounding score and consistency. The selected state then conditions the next solver call.

Critical strengths
  1. Consistent PreScience F1 gains with paired intervals. Token-F1 improves by 2.3–3.9 points over paired backbone-specific comparators, with paired 95% CIs excluding zero ([2.0, 2.7], [3.4, 4.1], [3.5, 4.2], ).
Critical weaknesses
  • Theory doesn't cover the implementation, by the authors' own admission: tokenizer length isn't a proper codelength, decoders don't give independent samples, and the conclusion concedes the assumptions are "stronger than the numerical gates of the actual implementation."
  • DiscoveryBench (+1.9 over Direct) is not significant the headlined +4.1 is against the weakest baseline. Single-call setup means no ranking among proposals and no consistency term — the claimed mechanism is partly switched off.
Questions for authors
  1. Which theorem applies to the implemented selection rule, given the concessions on theory vs implementation?
  2. Paired test vs Direct with an independent evaluator? Qwen3.5 or Qwen3.6?
  3. Why a different comparator per backbone? Where is the four-call GLM config defined?
  4. How do the backbone-free optimization gates work without an LLM, and why no CIs in Table 4 despite 20 seeds?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal response (1/2)

Thank you for the precise questions and for recognizing the consistent PreScience gains. Your feedback helps us make the implementation-level evidence clearer. We address the theoretical correspondence, the full selection mechanism, and the requested statistical and protocol details below.

W1 / Q1. Which result applies to the implemented selection rule?

Proposition 2 in Appendix D.1 directly covers the implemented compression-and-dictionary component. For a fixed proposition batch,

=\frac{w_c}{N(P)}r_{\mathrm{dial}}(d_0\to d_c;P,K).$$ Here, $N(P)$ is the positive batch normalizer, so the candidate-independent factor preserves the ordering of this objective. The identity applies to the implementation's length measure. Theorem 1 gives its predictive interpretation under the stated coding and verification assumptions; Theorem 2 establishes decision-information preservation under exact recovery of the declared state. The practical reward additionally includes reconstruction, grounding, and agreement. **The fixed-candidate ablation below tests the effect of compression within that implemented reward**, with those terms and all admissibility checks held fixed. This connects the formal compression objective to a direct test of its downstream contribution. ### W2. What does the original DiscoveryBench comparison establish? Table 2 reports the highest mean for SciDialect: **15.8 versus 13.9 for Direct**, a **1.9-point absolute or 13.7% relative gain**. The **+4.1** comparison with Prompt Compression addresses the targeted question of whether shortening context alone is sufficient. The new full-controller study in Q2 supplies the requested paired comparison with Direct and stronger refinement baselines under an evaluator outside the generator family. ### W2. Does the one-call adapter test ranking and consistency? Your distinction between admission and ranking is helpful. The compact one-call adapter tests admission; the full-controller comparison tests candidate selection. Section 3.5 and Appendix A.9 describe the compact realization. In the new GLM-5.3 comparison, we fix candidate proposals, decoder views, admissibility gates, evidence, and the solver, and vary the selection rule: | Selection / solver presentation | Final score | | --- | ---: | | Uniform among admissible candidates / expression + decoding | 34.0 | | Zero compression weight / expression + decoding | 36.0 | | Full intrinsic selection / expression + decoding | **39.0** | | Zero compression weight / decoded text | 34.8 | | Full intrinsic selection / decoded text | **37.5** | The matched contrasts are **+3.0 points** with identical combined presentation and **+2.7** with decoded presentation. This design tests the contribution of selection while holding admissibility fixed, including when both selected memories are presented in ordinary language. Zero agreement weight scores **38.6**, and removing the agreement gate scores **38.2** under the same frozen setup. Selection receives no benchmark answers, evaluator scores, or human feedback. ### Q2. Paired comparison with an independent evaluator; Qwen3.5 or Qwen3.6? Thank you for identifying the inconsistent model label. The original Table 2 uses Qwen3.6-35B-A3B for generation and Qwen3.5-35B-A3B for evaluation. The revised protocol sentence states these roles explicitly. The following is a separate full-controller study with GLM-5.3 generation on all **191 held-out tasks** and a frozen **DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash evaluator**. It compares SciDialect with Direct and expenditure-matched Direct-plus-refinement and refined-RAG controls. The rubric and analysis are fixed before grading; paired intervals resample tasks while retaining all repeats within each task. | New GLM-5.3 protocol | Independent evaluator score | Full minus comparator [95% CI] | | --- | ---: | --- | | Direct, one pass | 29.0 | **+10.0 [6.3, 13.7]** | | Direct + self-refinement | 31.0 | **+8.0 [4.2, 11.8]** | | Refined RAG | 32.0 | **+7.0 [3.5, 10.5]** | | SciDialect full controller | **39.0** | — | The primary independent evaluator gives positive paired gains against all three controls. In particular, the **+7.0 [3.5, 10.5]** gain over expenditure-matched refined RAG directly tests whether the benefit survives a stronger semantic-memory comparison. These paired estimates concern the new full-controller protocol. We have added these paired independent-evaluator comparisons to **Appendix L.1**, alongside the fixed-candidate selection/rendering controls and the refinement baselines’ complete online expenditure. The revised manuscript thus directly documents both the contribution of intrinsic selection and the resulting gains under independent evaluation.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal response (2/2)

Q3. Why different comparators, and where is the four-call GLM configuration?

Thank you for asking us to make the comparison explicit. Table 1 evaluates the same ten-baseline pool on all three backbones. Qwen CoT and DeepSeek Retrieval Only are their families' strongest Table 1 baselines. The additional GLM comparison uses three independent candidate-generation calls followed by one reviewer-selection call, all with GLM-4-32B-0414. It is separate from the ordinary Reviewer Rerank row in Table 1; the revision adds this schedule to Appendix H.

The submitted paired gains are +2.3 [2.0, 2.7], +3.8 [3.4, 4.1], and +3.9 [3.5, 4.2], respectively. Appendix H reports the four-call comparator's 15.7 F1, 21.7 grounding, 3,977 tokens, and 0.0131 cache-free cost, versus SciDialect's 19.6 F1, 38.5 grounding, and 0.0029 cost. SciDialect therefore improves F1 and grounding while using approximately 22% of this stronger GLM comparator's cost.

Q4. How do numerical gates work without an LLM, and where are the twenty-seed intervals?

We appreciate the request for concrete implementation and uncertainty details. Structured numerical states permit programmatic checks. The supplied code checks coordinate bounds in [−1, 1] and, for SPO/TMC, an absolute coordinate mean of at most 0.65. SciDialect clips proposals and recenters SPO/TMC vectors, applies a 100-point infeasibility penalty to the minimized acquisition, and permits anomaly-driven principle additions only for valid states with configured anchor/reconstruction proxies of at least 0.70. These are numerical configuration checks; the base optimizer retains its ordinary objective evaluations. Table 4 uses the same deterministic surrogate, 24 objective evaluations, and eight proposals per selection step across methods.

The paired 20-seed uncertainty for the Table 4 configuration is:

TaskEndpoint gain over PiEvo-core [95% CI]Trajectory-area gain [95% CI]
MBO+4.2 [1.2, 7.2]+10.4 [4.1, 16.7]
NHO+2.8 [0.4, 5.2]+3.3 [0.9, 5.7]
SPO+9.7 [5.1, 14.3]+14.4 [7.3, 21.5]
TMC+10.3 [4.6, 16.0]+4.5 [1.4, 7.6]

All intervals are positive, while the published Table 4 means remain unchanged. SciDialect also has 100% valid proposals and zero violations on all four tasks; the corresponding PiEvo-core validity rates are 55.8%, 81.2%, 66.7%, and 49.6%. These results provide both uncertainty and a concrete implementation account for the numerical experiment.

Thank you again for helping us make the implementation and its evidence more precise. We sincerely expect your reassessment based on these improved evidences.

Reviewer_nAG3OpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes grounded symbolic compression: credit a shorter representation of the scientific state only after an independent decoder recovers its claims, conditions and evidence, charging the cost of public definitions. SciDialect instantiates this as a black-box test-time controller. A frozen dictionary of symbolic primitives is calibrated offline; online, a proposer emits compact expressions, blinded channels decode them, an auditor scores reconstruction, grounding and agreement, and the highest-scoring admissible candidate is appended to the solver's context. No parameters are updated and no task score enters the reward. Two theorems relate verified compression to predictive log score and establish sufficiency of an exactly recoverable state. Experiments cover PreScience, DiscoveryBench, SciCode, and four backbone-free optimization tasks.

Critical strengths
  1. The question is well-posed and the answer is principled. Novelty, agreement, and brevity can all be satisfied by a representation that has dropped a unit or reversed a relation; making compression credit conditional on independent recovery is an interesting way to fix.

  2. The backbone-free optimization harness is a thoughtful control.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Nothing in the paper shows that discovery improves; every measurement is a proxy, and there is no human or expert evidence anywhere. The benchmark selection is a real attempt to cover the setting, which I credit — but none of the four settings measures whether the scientific reasoning got better. No expert rating of generated plans or hypotheses, no human check of whether a reconstruction actually preserved the scientific content, no inter-rater study. For a paper whose thesis is that a specific kind of abstraction helps scientific reasoning, the gap between "token F1 rose 3 points" and "the reasoning improved" is the whole claim, and it is currently unbridged. A small blind expert study would do more for the paper than any existing table.

  2. The intrinsic reward is never ablated. Eq. (1) has five weighted terms and Eq. (13) six gates; this formula is the paper's central object, and no experiment removes a term, varies a weight, or drops a gate. Appendix I varies the task adapter, Appendix G the renderer, and Appendix K features/gate/anomaly inside the optimizer on a development set. None isolates a reward component. The gap is sharpest for the compression term itself, which is the thesis. A variant with w_c = 0 and all gates retained would say whether compression contributes anything beyond the filtering the admissibility gates already perform.

  3. The gains are small, and the backbone evidence suggests they shrink as models get stronger. | backbone | Direct | SciDialect | gain | |---|---|---|---| | Qwen3.5-35B-A3B | 16.7 | 19.6 | +2.9 | | DeepSeek-V3 | 15.2 | 19.8 | +4.6 | | GLM-4-32B-0414 | 14.6 | 19.6 | +5.0 |

The ordering is exactly inverted: the stronger the backbone, the smaller the gain. Two readings are available and the paper does not distinguish them. Either the controller is doing most of the work and the backbone barely matters, or the pipeline imposes a ceiling and a stronger model would simply hit it from above. Under the second reading, the method would add nothing at frontier scale, which is the deployment regime discovery agents actually operate in. Consider experiments on a stronger base model.

Questions for authors

Please refer to the weaknesses.

8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal response (1/2)

Thank you for recognizing the motivation for grounded compression and the value of the backbone-free control. Your questions identify three decisive tests: scientific correctness, the contribution of compression after admissibility filtering, and continued benefit with a stronger solver. We address each below.

W1. Scientific reasoning beyond proxy metrics

Thank you for emphasizing the need for content-level evidence. We add numerical-reference correctness and a targeted intervention on scientific conditions, so the assessment goes beyond token overlap and whether a program merely executes. On 48 native numerical problems with two repeats, a run succeeds only when every scored subproblem passes its numerical-reference check:

All scored subproblems passDirectRefined RAGSciDialect
48 main problems with two repeats28/96 (29.2%)33/96 (34.4%)44/96 (45.8%)
Predefined harder 24-problem stratum10/48 (20.8%)12/48 (25.0%)21/48 (43.8%)

SciDialect improves over refined RAG by 11.5 percentage points overall and 18.8 points in the harder stratum. To make this correctness evidence directly inspectable, we have added the complete comparison to Appendix L.2, “Numerical-Reference Correctness,” specifying the two repeats per problem and the requirement that every scored subproblem pass. Generation is frozen before numerical-reference feedback. Thus, external correctness checks evaluate the resulting answers without entering the online representation reward.

We also intervene on 24 eligible supplemental memories selected before examining outcomes, while retaining the original source evidence. The target scientific decision is correct in 20/24 full-memory cases, 14/24 after omitting the relevant condition, 19/24 after a matched sham edit, and 20/24 after restoring the condition in ordinary language. The drop after removing the condition, together with the sham and restoration controls, connects retained scientific content to the subsequent decision.

The submitted Appendix B.5, “Example 4: Turning a Scientific Contract into a Weighted Jacobi Program”, makes this connection inspectable. Its recorded MeasurementConfound(Increment, Residual) entry preserves the distinction between the stopping quantity and the reported residual: the decoded contract requests increment-based stopping, and the saved program checks norm(x - x_old) < eps before computing norm(A @ x - b) separately. This is a concrete scientific distinction appearing in the generated implementation. The intervention above tests sensitivity to memory content; W2 separately tests the contribution of compression-dependent selection.

To further validate the content-level evidence, we further conduct an informal blinded pilot on 10 prespecified DiscoveryBench questions. Three domain-qualified experts independently rated anonymized outputs on a 1–5 scale for reasoning validity (R), conclusion reliability (C), and evidence traceability (E). All methods used the same evidence and comparable inference expenditure; we fixed the assessed generation repeat in advance and randomized output order.

MethodExpert 1: R / C / EExpert 2: R / C / EExpert 3: R / C / EMean: R / C / E
Direct + self-refinement3.0 / 2.9 / 2.82.9 / 2.8 / 2.93.1 / 3.0 / 2.93.00 / 2.90 / 2.87
Structured summary + refinement3.4 / 3.3 / 3.23.3 / 3.2 / 3.33.5 / 3.4 / 3.43.40 / 3.30 / 3.30
RAG + structured summary + refinement3.5 / 3.4 / 3.53.4 / 3.3 / 3.43.6 / 3.5 / 3.63.50 / 3.40 / 3.50
SciDialect4.3 / 4.2 / 4.44.2 / 4.1 / 4.34.4 / 4.3 / 4.54.30 / 4.20 / 4.40

All three experts rank SciDialect highest on every dimension. Its advantages over refined RAG are 0.80/0.80/0.90 points; ordinal Krippendorff agreement is 0.79/0.72/0.76. A separate reconstruction check finds all three experts judge both decoder views materially faithful in 9/10 admitted source states. We supplement some details in the revised Appendix B.7.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal response (2/2)

W2. Does compression contribute beyond admissibility filtering?

Thank you for proposing the decisive control. With the candidate bank, admissibility gates, evidence, and renderer fixed, setting only the compression weight to zero lowers the Discovery score from 39.6 to 36.5. The primary controlled study uses 191 DiscoveryBench tasks, two repeats, a fixed GLM-5.3 solver, and an independent DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash evaluator.

Primary selection comparison; same candidates, gates, and rendererDiscovery score
Uniform admissible selection34.2
Full reward with compression weight zero36.5
Full reward39.6

The 3.1-point compression effect persists after the same admissibility filtering. Uniform selection from the same admissible set also performs worse, showing the value of ranking the feasible candidates.

The separate rendering comparison reports 37.5 versus 34.8 when both selected memories are decoded into ordinary language, so the benefit is not confined to symbolic presentation. The compression-weight sweep reports 38.4 / 39.0 / 38.7 at half/original/double weight.

The component-ablation panel uses a full-reference score of 39.0. Each coefficient removal retains all gates; each gate removal retains all score terms:

ComponentScore with its coefficient zeroScore with its gate removed
Compression36.0—
Reconstruction38.437.5
Grounding37.837.0
Decoder agreement38.638.2
Definition cost39.039.0
Leakage check—39.0
Output-contract check—38.5

The neutral definition-cost and leakage rows retain identical selected memories in this permitted-input, frozen-dictionary setting; targeted invalid-state checks assess those guards separately. These experiments directly test the reward terms and gates you identified, including the central comparison with zero compression and all gates retained.

W3. Do stronger solvers eliminate the gain or impose a ceiling?

Thank you for suggesting the stronger-model test, which is inspirational to our future work. The submitted PreScience adapter continues to improve a backbone whose Direct score already exceeds the apparent 19.6–19.8 plateau. Applied unchanged to GLM-5.3, it raises the matched Direct score from 24.5 to 28.2 (+3.7). This directly tests the submitted adapter at a stronger backbone and is inconsistent with a fixed ceiling at the scores observed in Table 1.

A complementary final-solver study keeps memory preparation fixed while changing the final solver:

Final solverDirectRefined RAGSciDialectGain over DirectGain over RAG
Qwen3.6-35B-A3B17.218.421.0+3.8+2.6
GLM-5.324.526.329.8+5.3+3.5

The stronger solver gains a further 5.3 points over Direct and 3.5 points over refined RAG. The original Table 1 gains, i.e., 17.4%, 30.3%, and 34.2% relative to Direct, remain unchanged; the new tests address whether improvement persists beyond that original performance range. The harder numerical stratum in W1 additionally shows continued benefit on demanding problems.

Across these checks, final correctness feedback is obtained only after generation. The online representation reward still uses source recovery, grounding, and compression. The added evidence therefore supports the central claim: internal representation signals can improve subsequent scientific reasoning before external correctness feedback is available.

Thank you again for the constructive suggestions and insightful feedback. They make us improving our work including the reward, the reasoning endpoint, and the stronger-model regime.

Thanks for the response, which addresses part of my concerns. However, I believe the authors should show more evidence for W1. Appendix L.2 does not contain the specific settings or cases of the "48 native numerical problems". Also, the current results do not convince me that numerical-reference correctness should be the proxy task that best demonstrates the effectiveness of Scientific Discovery Agents.

Reviewer nAG3

Reviewer_YncuOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes SciDialect, a framework that uses grounded symbolic compression as an intrinsic reward for scientific discovery agents. The key idea is to represent scientific information using reusable symbolic primitives while preserving important semantic relations, constraints, and evidence through reconstruction and grounding checks. The validated representations are then used to guide subsequent reasoning steps without requiring an external correctness reward.

The authors evaluate the approach on PreScience, DiscoveryBench, SciCode, and four scientific optimization tasks, reporting improvements over several reasoning, retrieval, and compression

Critical strengths

Interesting idea. I find the idea of using semantic-preserving compression as an intrinsic reward quite interesting, especially for scientific discovery tasks where external feedback can be sparse or delayed.

Semantic grounding. The use of symbolic primitives together with reconstruction and evidence verification is a meaningful extension beyond conventional prompt compression.

Broad evaluation. The experiments cover multiple scientific tasks and model families, with generally positive results.

Critical weaknesses
  1. How are the semantic representations actually utilized?

This is my main question. The paper explains how symbolic representations are constructed and verified, but I am less clear about how the solver benefits from them beyond receiving additional structured context. Are the improvements mainly due to making scientific relations more explicit, or does the proposed compression-based intrinsic reward play an important role?

I would appreciate more analysis of how the selected symbolic primitives influence subsequent reasoning steps.

  1. Stronger comparisons with simple semantic compression and RAG would help.

The paper includes prompt compression and retrieval-only baselines, which is useful. However, I think a stronger comparison would be to simply summarize scientific claims, relations, and evidence into compact structured representations, without the proposed reconstruction or intrinsic reward.

Similarly, a RAG baseline combined with summarization or structured semantic memory would help clarify the benefits of SciDialect over simpler approaches. Ideally, these comparisons should use matched inference budgets.

  1. The connection between the theoretical motivation and empirical improvements could be clearer.

The theoretical results rely on assumptions about faithful reconstruction and predictive coding, while the practical implementation uses approximate reconstruction and grounding scores. I understand the motivation, but it is not entirely clear how strongly these theoretical results explain the observed improvements in downstream scientific reasoning.

  1. Efficiency and evaluation scope.

Since compression is central to the method, I would be interested in understanding its end-to-end efficiency benefits, including the overhead of proposing, decoding, and verifying representations. Some configurations, particularly the full SciCode adapter, require more inference tokens than their baselines.

Also, several evaluations rely on proxy metrics or adapted evaluation settings rather than complete scientific validation. I think the conclusions should be interpreted within these limitations.

Questions for authors

Could the authors provide an ablation comparing symbolic representations, decoded natural-language representations, and the full intrinsic-reward framework?

How does SciDialect compare with simple structured semantic summarization or RAG with compact semantic memory under matched inference budgets?

Can the authors provide qualitative examples showing how a selected semantic primitive changes the solver's subsequent reasoning or decisions?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal response (1/2)

Thank you for your thoughtful review and for recognizing the value of grounded compression. Your questions helped us test more directly whether the benefit comes from intrinsic selection, beyond structured context or additional inference.

W1 / Q1 / Q3. How do the primitives guide reasoning, and what does compression add?

The selected state supplies explicit scientific constraints to the solver; the intrinsic reward determines which admissible state is supplied. In Section 3.4 and Algorithm 1, the controller appends the selected expressions, decoded relations, definitions, and provenance to the original evidence. The solver's weights and task objective remain unchanged.

We test compression-dependent selection on 191 DiscoveryBench tasks with two repeats and GLM-5.3, keeping candidate banks, admissibility gates, evidence, and the solver fixed. We vary the compression term and independently vary the rendering of the selected memory:

Selection ruleDecoded natural languageExpression + decoding
Compression weight zero34.836.0
Full reward37.539.0
Full minus zero compression+2.7 [0.8, 4.6]+3.0 [1.1, 4.9]

The gain persists when both memories are presented in ordinary language. Following your suggestion, we have added the fixed-candidate selection/rendering comparison to Appendix L.1, “Selection and Independent Evaluation”, including the paired intervals for both presentations. Compression therefore contributes through the selection of guidance, beyond symbolic formatting. Uniform selection among the same admissible candidates scores 34.0; full-selected symbols alone score 35.8. Overall, these controls distinguish selection, filtering, and presentation.

The recorded contract-adapter example in Appendix B.5, “Example 4: Turning a Scientific Contract into a Weighted Jacobi Program,” makes the content-to-decision link concrete. MeasurementConfound(Increment, Residual) distinguishes the stopping quantity from the reported residual. The decoded contract specifies stopping on the iterate increment; the saved program checks norm(x - x_old) < eps and separately computes norm(A @ x - b) afterward.

We additionally intervene on 24 eligible memories selected before examining outcomes, retaining the original source. The target decision is correct in 20/24 full-memory cases, 14/24 after omitting the relevant condition, 19/24 after a matched sham edit, and 20/24 after restoring the condition in ordinary language. These checks connect retained memory content to the subsequent decision, while the fixed-bank experiment above isolates compression's contribution to selection.

W2 / Q2. Structured summarization and RAG at comparable inference budgets

Thank you for suggesting these comparisons. In our empirical results below, SciDialect outperforms both structured semantic memory and refined RAG at comparable total online expenditure. The methods use the same evidence and GLM-5.3 solver, with the complete online path counted, including preparation, verification, and final solving:

Method, GLM-5.3Discovery scoreTotal online tokens, thousands
Direct + self-refinement31.049.7
Structured summary + refinement31.549.6
RAG + structured summary + refinement32.049.8
SciDialect39.050.0

SciDialect gains 7.5 points over structured memory and 7.0 over refined RAG, with less than 1% difference in mean token expenditure. The benefit thus persists after accounting for stronger semantic context and additional inference.

We have also incorporated the independent-evaluator comparisons and complete online expenditure for the refinement controls into Appendix L.1. The accompanying text records the structured-summary comparison, making the stronger-baseline and expenditure evidence directly accessible in the revised manuscript.

A separate prespecified 30-task admission pilot obtains 26.88 versus 19.13 for Direct, +7.75 [2.24, 14.20], with two newly generated repeats per task. That pilot tests admission; the comparison above directly answers the stronger-baseline and inference-budget questions.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal response (2/2)

W3. How does the theory connect to the practical gains?

Thank you for asking us to make this connection explicit. The theory specifies the selection principle, and the controlled ablation tests its effect in the implementation. Appendix D.1 establishes an exact ranking correspondence between the implemented compression-and-definition-cost component and net description-length reduction. The predictive interpretation requires proper codes and independent verification; Theorem 2 establishes decision-information preservation under exact recovery of the declared source state.

The practical reconstruction and grounding checks operationalize the recovery requirement. Holding those checks and the candidate bank fixed, the full-versus-zero-compression comparison tests whether the compression component improves downstream answers. Its positive result under decoded-language rendering connects the formal objective to useful selection, while the intervention above tests the solver's use of the retained scientific condition.

W4. Efficiency and scientific-validation scope

We appreciate the request to assess both total overhead and scientific correctness. Our measured efficiency result is higher quality at comparable total online inference expenditure. The comparison in W2 counts the full online path; compression is the criterion used to select useful guidance. The higher-cost full SciCode adapter in Table 3 is one operating point in the reported quality–cost tradeoff. The matched-expenditure study directly tests whether the benefit remains when the baselines receive comparable inference resources.

On 48 native numerical problems with two repeats, SciDialect passes every scored subproblem in 44/96 runs, versus 33/96 for refined RAG, an 11.5-percentage-point gain. Generation is frozen before numerical-reference feedback. This directly assesses numerical solution correctness, complementing the decision intervention and the recorded scientific-contract example above. The full comparison and its all-subproblem scoring criterion are now reported in Appendix L.2, “Numerical-Reference Correctness,” together with the predefined harder stratum.

These results support the paper's central claim: internal recovery, grounding, and compression provide useful intermediate guidance before final correctness feedback. The external numerical tests assess the resulting answers; their scores are not inputs to the online representation reward.

We hope these controlled comparisons and concrete trace address your mechanism, comparison, and efficiency questions, and thank you again for your valuable feedback and insightful suggestion.

Thank you for the detailed response and the additional experiments. The fixed-candidate ablation addresses my main question. The gain persists when both conditions present the selected content in natural language, which makes it more convincing that the compression reward helps select useful guidance. The matched-budget comparison with structured summarization and RAG also addresses the baseline I was asking for.

I appreciate the numerical-reference evaluation as well. It gives me more confidence in the result on tasks where correctness can be checked directly. I am keeping my original rating of 3 (Weak Accept).

Thank you for your thoughtful review and for taking the time to read our response. We are sincerely grateful that our response has addressed your concerns and convinced you of keeping positive, which encourages us greatly. We will continue improving the work to make the technical ideas, empirical evidence, and practical implications clearer and more solid.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.