- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GeoCo-SAVi to address the inconsistency between explicit position and scale in Invariant Slot Attention (ISA) and the decoded center and extent. The method combines a spatially equivariant, object-wise decoder with factual position alignment and counterfactual appearance transplantation. The authors evaluate the method on the synthetic Obj3D and MOVi-C datasets.
Critical strengths
The paper presents a range of quantitative experiments, along with mathematical derivations and analysis.
Critical weaknesses
-
Concerns about the practical value of the task. All evaluations are conducted on synthetic datasets, and the qualitative demonstrations, such as Fig. 3, focus on simple geometric objects. Without results on real-world scenes, the practical relevance of the task remains unclear. For these simple geometric objects, the authors should explain what practical benefit the learned representation offers beyond parameter-based manipulation of available scene assets in software such as Blender, and whether this benefit justifies the model’s complexity. The paper also lacks clear qualitative demonstration of position editing, and its current formulation is limited to 2D image-plane position. Moreover, recent instruction-guided image and video editing models support increasingly complex object manipulation like pose editing beyond the simple editing the paper show. The paper does not adequately discuss how its task and capabilities differ from these approaches or what distinct practical need its formulation addresses.
-
Poor writing and presentation. For example, the Introduction section largely describes the proposed components without sufficiently explaining the motivation behind the individual design choice. The method appears to be an incremental improvement of prior ISA work, yet the paper does not clearly states why each proposed component is needed to address what specific limitations of prior work. Besideds, in Fig. 2(B2), the images before and after appearance transplantation look almost identical, making it difficult to understand what this comparison is intended to demonstrate.
-
Insufficient qualitative evaluation. The paper presents very few qualitative example. Although it focuses on object-centric representation learning in videos, the paper do not provide video demonstrations. This makes it difficult to assess the temporal behavior and consistency of the video edits. Qualitative ablation comparisons are also insufficient to clearly illustrate the contribution of individual components.
Questions for authors
Please address the critical weaknesses above.