- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The submission proposes FPMR-NO, a finite-propagation-aware multiresolution neural operator designed specifically for structural dynamics. Standard GNO / GNN often allows immediate message passing across established edges. This design creates unphysical shortcuts because computational connectivity outpaces actual physical wave reachability. The authors solve this by embedding finite wave propagation as a strict architectural prior.
Critical strengths
-
The reviewer appreciated that the formalization is easily verifiable. Assumption are clear and the propositions are generally mathematically correct.
-
The gate design is interpretable and permits continuous speed adjustments. The model is highly lightweight. It uses 0.21M parameters compared to AMG's 2.38M.
-
The architecture successfully recomputes material travel times at each graph scale. It applies differentiable arrival gates to separate P-wave, S-wave, and mixed message branches.
Critical weaknesses
-
One of biggest weaknesses of this method is that the gate enforces first-arrival support, not finite-propagation causality. Also, the performance gain is relatively marginal. For example, the accuracy improvement over the Transolver baseline on the Plate task is relatively marginal at 1.7%.
-
DeformingPlate is quasi-static. It lacks explicit time steps, material constants, and true wave speeds. The propagation gate merely acts as an unspecified structural graph bias here.
-
The ETH task predicts sparse accelerometer responses; only ablates the transfer initialization and geometry residual. A true elastodynamic multiscale benchmark with gating ablations is completely missing.
-
The ETH dataset provides sparse accelerometer channels instead of full-field stress or displacement measurements.
-
Long-horizon temporal stability remains a challenge. Errors clearly accumulate during autoregressive rollout on the DeformingPlate task.
Questions for authors
Which softness parameter do the main tables use?
Does the ungated baseline still receive arrival times?
What are the load inputs and wave speeds on Plate?
If this is the official AMG setting, AMG originally reported an error lower than your 0.0260. If you align with their numbers, your margin over AMG reverses.
How is NRMSE normalized on ETH?
Why does Figure 16 drop to roughly 0.50 at horizon 4096 when Table 2 explicitly reports 0.86?
If you run a two-pulse test, does the predicted response change when only later source loads are perturbed?