- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3(+1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This article discusses how to sequentially correct the errors of expert models and provides a theory applicable to additive signal models and linear models. It also provides a lower-bound understanding of this model from the perspective of minimax optimality and min-max optimization.
Critical strengths
-
Provided a theory for the sequential error correction model and conducted experimental verification.
-
The exact finite-sample energy recursion and the necessary-and-sufficient stability criterion (Theorems 8 and 9) are mathematically clean and technically useful.
Critical weaknesses
-
The technical contribution of the entire study is mainly to establish precise error and stability characterization of specific models under existing residual queries (such as the cited study Frongillo et al. (2025)) and the local projection framework (a commonly used theoretical analysis method in statistics), rather than proposing a new information aggregation principle or universal learning algorithm. In addition, the discussion in the related work section of this article is not sufficient.
-
Section 5 only considers the noiseless form when using linear regression. However, in statistical research on linear models, it is often assumed that , which means there exists white noise. Therefore, the impact of the model's inherent randomness on expert aggregation has not been studied yet.
Questions for authors
-
Equation (13) given in Section 4 often does not hold in the linear model in Sec 5. In fact, Sec 5 uses equation (18). Therefore, the analysis of these two parts is relatively disjointed, and the connection between the previous minimax conclusion and subsequent analysis is unclear.
-
Why is the sum of Y considered as a learning objective in Section 2? Can we assume that $X_ {\ell} \sim N (\beta_ {\ell}, 1) $ and discuss the joint estimation of , would it be more intuitive?
-
Can the processing in Section 5 achieve minimax optimization for models with the (high-dimensional) sparse structure (a common statistical model)? And correspondingly, what would be the assumption on sample size at this point?
-
Is this study related to online learning?