- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes CoDelta, a new communication-efficient collaborative perception framework. The proposed method consists of sender-side priority-aware packetization and receiver-side delta fusion. The paper also considers partial reception (only a prefix is received) as an important challenge to be tackled in the field and provides a priority-aware ordering mechanism to enhance the performance under partial reception.
The proposed method's effectiveness is well validated. However, the way of dealing with baseline methods is not convincing.
Critical strengths
- It is valuable to discuss the partial reception scenario, which is a realistic challenge in real-world deployment.
- The compactness of the single-channel patch feature is impressive.
Critical weaknesses
-
The partial reception scenario is the major motivation, the first claimed contribution, and the major experimental setup. However, it is not well analyzed, and the baseline methods are treated in a questionable way: As the author stated in Sec 4.1, compared methods' messages are arranged in spatial order. However, for many of the compared methods, spatial confidence scores are used to select the area to be transmitted. Using the confidence score to arrange the messages is more reasonable for a fair comparison. In fact, at least in Where2comm/ERMVP, the paper provides a systematic measurement of the performance-communication volume tradeoff. The performance-communication tradeoff study can be adapted to the partial reception scenario via engineering approaches.
-
While the proposed method is well-motivated, the novelty is limited. In prior methods, feature fusion also uses a grid-wise 1*1 convolution. The incremental delta aggregation makes the previous F_fused-F_ego the predicted feature instead of the original F_fused, which could be treated as a residual connection. From my perspective, the novelty is limited to the patch-wise processing.
Questions for authors
- What's the major difference you consider when discussing "Packet Budget" and "Reception Ratio"?
- Could you compare the "priority score" and the confidence score used in previous work in some quantitative way?